Simulating the shaping of point-symmetric structures in the jittering jets explosion mechanism

Jessica Braudo, Amir Michaelis, Muhammad Akashi, Noam Soker · 2025

Read Simulating the shaping of point-symmetric structures in the jittering jets explosion mechanism by Jessica Braudo, Amir Michaelis, Muhammad Akashi, Noam Soker (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-10326.txt.

Introduction

Jessica Braudo and co-authors simulate exploding stars whose jets wobble, to explain the mirrored shapes of supernova leftovers, in a 2025 paper. Many remnants show point-symmetric patterns: blobs and lobes paired on opposite sides of the centre. In the jittering jets picture, a newborn neutron star fires pairs of jets in shifting directions, and the jets blow the star apart. The team launched such jet pairs into a collapsing stellar core in three-dimensional simulations.

The jets varied in direction, energy, width, and duration, a few dozen pairs over about two seconds of modelled time. They carved matched pairs of filaments, clumps, bubbles, and lobes, the very symmetry seen in about a dozen real remnants. Turbulent instabilities and vortices added finer structure. The match strengthens the case that jittering jets, not a single fixed blast, explode massive stars.

Catalog record

CREATORJessica Braudo, Amir Michaelis, Muhammad Akashi, Noam Soker
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE43 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-10326

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Simulating the shaping of point-symmetric structures in the jittering jets explosion mechanism Jessica Braudo, Amir Michaelis, Muhammad Akashi, Noam Soker Abstract We conduct three-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations of core-collapse supernovae by launching several pairs of jets into a collapsing core model and show that the jittering jets explosion mechanism (JJEM) can form a point-symmetric morphology that accounts for observed morphologies of about a dozen core-collapse supernovae (CCSN) remnants. Point-symmetric morphologies are composed of pairs of opposite structures around the center of the CCSN remnant. In the JJEM, the newly born neutron star launches several to a few tens of pairs of jets with stochastically varying directions, and these jets explode the star. In the simulations with the FLASH numerical code, we launch pairs of jets with varying directions, energies, opening angles, and durations into the massive stellar core and follow their evolution for about two seconds. We show that the jets form pairs of opposite filaments, clumps, bubbles, and lobes, namely, prominent point-symmetric morphologies. The interaction of the jets with the core leads to vigorous Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities and excites many vortices, which also shape clumps and filaments. Our results suggest that the JJEM could play a central role in the explosion mechanism of CCSNe; neutrino heating can boost the role of jets. I Introduction The gravitational energy of the collapsing core powers core-collapse supernovae (CCSNe). Neutrinos carry most of the released gravitational energy as the neutron star (NS) cools down. A small fraction of this energy explodes the star. Two alternative theoretical models consider two different processes to deliver this energy to explode the star (for recent reviews, see Soker 69 , Janka 32 ). In the delayed neutrino explosion mechanism, a small fraction of the neutrinos interact with the collapsing core in the gain region, at \approx 100{~\rm km} from the newly born NS, heat the material, revive the stalled shock and explode the star (e.g., Andresen et al. 4 , Boccioli & Fragione 11 , Burrows et al. 16 , Janka & Kresse 33 , Müller 45 , Müller et al. 46 , van Baal et al. 84 , Wang & Burrows 86 , Laplace et al. 35 , Huang et al. 30 , Boccioli et al. 13 , Boccioli et al. 12 , Imasheva et al. 31 , Nakamura et al. 47 , Janka 32 , Wang & Burrows 87 , for some very recent studies). In the magnetorotational explosion mechanism, in rare cases of CCSNe, those that have a rapidly rotating pre-collapse core (e.g., Shibagaki et al. 57 , Zha et al. 88 , Shibata et al. 58 , for recent studies of this mechanism), jets along a fixed axis explode the star; however, according to this mechanism, in most CCSNe, neutrino heating explodes the star. Therefore, we consider the magnetorotational explosion mechanism part of the neutrino-driven mechanism, even though, for these rare cases, fixed-axis jets deliver most of the gravitational energy to the exploding star. In the jittering jets explosion mechanism (JJEM), jets deliver the gravitational energy of the collapsing core to the star and explode it (for a recent detail on the JJEM and its parameters, see Soker 70 ). The newly born NS accretes material via intermittent accretion disks; the disks launch pairs of opposite jets with varying directions, i.e., jittering jets. Only in rare cases, when the pre-collapse core is rapidly rotating, do the pairs of jets have a common axis. The stochastic behavior of the accretion disks results from angular momentum fluctuations in the pre-collapse core’s convection zones; instabilities around the newly born NS amplify these fluctuations (e.g., Gilkis & Soker 23 , Gilkis & Soker 24 , Shishkin & Soker 60 , Shishkin & Soker 61 , Wang et al. 85 ). Neutrino heating plays a secondary role in boosting the effect of the jets [ 66 ] . Jets supply most of the explosion energy even when the newly born NS is highly magnetized and rapidly rotating, i.e., an energetic magnetar (e.g., Soker & Gilkis 77 , Kumar 34 ). One robust outcome of the JJEM is that many, but not all, CCSN remnants should possess point-symmetric morphology. Namely, the CCSN remnant has pairs of structural features opposite to the center of the CCSN remnant, and the pairs do not share their symmetry axes. The opposite structural features might be filaments, clumps, bubbles (faint zones closed by a brighter rim), lobes (bubbles with partial rims), and ears (protrusions from the main remnant’s shell having a decreasing cross-section with distance from the center). The neutrino-driven explosion mechanism cannot account for the point-symmetric morphologies of about a dozen CCSN remnants. The JJEM accounts for the point-symmetric morphology by pairs of jets that shape the supernova ejecta, hence the remnant. Many jets are choked inside the core, leaving no imprints on the remnants. Only one to several of the N_{\rm 2j}\simeq 5-30 pairs of exploding jets [ 70 ] leave observable marks. In many cases, the point-symmetric morphology is not sharp and clear because several processes smear it (e.g., Soker & Shishkin 78 ), including interaction with circumstellar material, interaction with the interstellar medium, instabilities in the explosion process, the NS natal kick, heating of the ejecta by radioactive decay and the reverse shock, and the pulsar wind nebula. In recent years, studies have identified point-symmetric morphologies in over ten CCSN remnants and connected them to jet shaping, solidifying the JJEM as the primary and even sole explosion mechanism of CCSNe. Some of these point-symmetric CCSN remnants have a pair or more of opposite clumps, e.g., SNR 0540-69.3 [ 67 ] , Vela ( Soker 68 , Soker & Shishkin 78 ), SN 1987A [ 71 , 72 ] , Cassiopeia A [ 10 ] , W49B, [ 79 ] , and possibly also the Crab Nebula [ 62 ] . Other CCSN remnants do not show prominent pairs of clumps; these are N63A [ 73 ] , G321.3–3.9 [ 74 , 63 ] , G107.7-5.1 [ 74 ] , the Cygnus Loop [ 59 ] , W44 [ 75 ] , CTB 1 [ 9 ] , Puppis A [ 7 ] , and SNR G0.9+0.1 [ 76 ] . In attributing the point-symmetric pairs to shaping by jets, these studies applied a very common tool in the study of planetary nebulae, where studies consider jets to be behind the shaping of multipolar planetary nebulae and other point-symmetric morphologies (e.g., Morris 44 , Soker 65 , Sahai & Trauger 55 , Akashi & Soker 3 , Estrella-Trujillo et al. 21 , Tafoya et al. 81 , Balick et al. 6 , Rechy-García et al. 52 , Clairmont et al. 17 , Danehkar 18 , Moraga Baez et al. 43 , Ablimit 1 , Derlopa et al. 20 , Miranda et al. 42 , Sahai et al. 56 ). The tool of identifying point-symmetric morphologies and connecting them to jet-driven explosions is new in the study of CCSNe. Our study is on that topic. In many planetary nebulae, the jets precess, namely, continuously varying their direction (e.g., Guerrero & Manchado 29 , Miranda et al. 41 , Sahai et al. 54 , Boffin et al. 14 , Sowicka et al. 80 , Rechy-García

Read the complete text