Investigating ferromagnetic response in monolayer CVD grown MoS 2 flakes using quantum weak measurement
Wardah Mahmood, Muhammad Hammad Raza Gardezi, Muhammad Arshad, Muddasir Naeem, Ammar Ahmed Khan, Syed Adnan Raza, Muhammad Sabieh Anwar · 2025
Read Investigating ferromagnetic response in monolayer CVD grown MoS 2 flakes using quantum weak measurement by Wardah Mahmood, Muhammad Hammad Raza Gardezi, Muhammad Arshad, Muddasir Naeem, Ammar Ahmed Khan, Syed Adnan Raza, Muhammad Sabieh Anwar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-10038.txt.
Introduction
Wardah Mahmood and co-authors hunt magnetism in a material one atom thick, using a trick from quantum measurement. Molybdenum disulfide flakes grown by vapor deposition can end in sulfur or molybdenum edges, and theory says the edges decide the magnetism. The team grew flakes under varied conditions and probed them with a light-based magneto-optic setup sharpened by weak measurement.
The probe, built on the spin Hall effect of light, sensed the flakes' ultra-small magnetic response. Molybdenum-terminated edges emerged as the main source of the ferromagnetic signal, a verdict backed by X-ray, Raman, and light-emission spectroscopy. The authors also pitch the technique itself: a robust way to measure faint properties in atomic-scale materials that ordinary instruments miss.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Wardah Mahmood, Muhammad Hammad Raza Gardezi, Muhammad Arshad, Muddasir Naeem, Ammar Ahmed Khan, Syed Adnan Raza, Muhammad Sabieh Anwar |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 52 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-10038
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Investigating ferromagnetic response in monolayer CVD grown MoS 2 flakes using quantum weak measurement Wardah Mahmood, Muhammad Hammad Raza Gardezi, Muhammad Arshad, Muddasir Naeem, Ammar Ahmed Khan, Syed Adnan Raza, Muhammad Sabieh Anwar Abstract We synthesize MoS 2 atomic layer flakes at different growth conditions to tailor S-terminated and Mo-terminated edge defect states that are investigated for their ferromagnetic response. We leverage quantum weak measurement principles to construct a spin Hall effect of light-based magneto-optic Kerr effect (SHEL-MOKE) setup to sense the ultra-small magnetic response from the synthesized atomic layers. Our findings demonstrate that Mo-terminated edge states are the primary source of ferromagnetic response from MoS 2 flakes, which is consistent with X-ray photoelectron, Raman and photoluminescence spectroscopic results. In the process, we demonstrate SHEL-MOKE to be a robust technique to investigate ultra weak properties in novel atomic-scale materials. I Introduction Two-dimensional (2D) materials have become central to the field of spintronics. Numerous studies reveal that semiconducting 2D materials display superior spin transport properties compared to their metallic counterparts li2014electrical ; tian2014topological . Transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs) are an interesting class of materials that show unique thickness dependent electronic and optical properties. Among these compounds, molybdenum disulfide (MoS 2 ) is a highly stable material possessing a number of interesting properties, including relatively high carrier mobility mir2020recent , a moderate layer-dependent electronic band gap splendiani2010emerging , and strong spin-orbit coupling fan2016valence . Prior attempts at extrinsic ferromagnetism primarily involved either creating spin polarization through doping or defect engineering, mostly in bulk MoS 2 . In this direction a significant amount of work has been done to produce dilute magnetic semiconductors (DMS) by substituting Mo with transition metal elements. Sanikop et al. compared the ferromagnetic response in Co and Mn doped bulk MoS 2 , concluding that both elements enhanced ferromagnetism when doped in small quantities. However, at higher doping levels, Mn substitution of Mo became inefficient, while Co doping lead to the segregation of an antiferromagnetic phase, resulting in paramagnetic behavior SANIKOP2021168226 . Fu et al . synthesized Fe doped monolayer MoS 2 that demonstrated ferromagnetic behavior fu2020enabling . However, precise control over doping and the resulting crystal structure remained a significant challenge. In addition to imparting a magnetic response, dopants are also expected to affect the electronic structure, which may be undesirable for a given application. Recently, ferromagnetism in pure MoS 2 single crystals was investigated after annealing the material at high temperatures, resulting in an increase in the amount of S vacancies park2024strong . Similarly, another study reported ferromagnetism in MoS 2 nanosheets by generation of S vacancies through a hydrothermal synthesis method, which resulted in localized transformation of 1H MoS 2 to 1T MoS 2 within the lattice cai2015vacancy . In both works, the increased ferromagnetism was linked to exchange of these interaction between the S vacancies and the Mo 4+ state. However, these investigations were limited to bulk MoS 2 and did not explore atomic layers which are more viable and important for spintronics applications due to their direct band gap mak2010atomically ; wang2017defects . Experimental studies on spontaneous magnetism in pristine MoS 2 are limited. Tongay et al. obtained ferromagnetic signal from bulk MoS 2 single crystals and attributed the phenomenon to zigzag edges at the grain boundaries tongay2012magnetic . Similarly, Zhou et al. studied ferromagnetism in CVD-grown MoS 2 flakes and pyramids via vibrating sample magnetometry (VSM), and their study of pyramid structures using magnetic force microscopy (MFM) showed phase contrast indicating the origin of ferromagnetism in MoS 2 flakes to indeed be from the edge states. However, while these authors detected ferromagnetism in MoS 2 pyramids, they were unable to discover this behavior in monolayer flakes zhou2018robust . Thus, it becomes evident that more sensitive experimental techniques may be required to overcome the limitations of traditional instruments and conventional techniques to measure the magnetic behavior in such materials at single-layer atomic thickness. Side by side with experimental investigation, theoretical studies on ferromagnetism in MoS 2 have indicated the existence of intrinsic magnetism resulting from edge states zhou2018robust . Depending on the type of edge, the atoms present in the bulk material have different coordination compared to the edge atoms. Mo-zigzag terminated edges in atomic layers consist of Mo with 4-fold coordination, compared to 6-fold coordination present within the bulk of flake, normally showing a diamagnetic behavior. The 4d orbitals of Mo within the bulk of the flake are spin-paired under 6-fold coordination due to ligand field splitting. In comparison, the unsaturated Mo at the edges of the flake show a spin polarized 4d orbital. Similarly, unsaturated S atoms in the S-terminating edges result in spin polarization in the 3p orbital zhang2007magnetic . On the other hand, armchair edges produce no magnetic moment as the S and Mo atoms alternate along the edge resulting in absence of unpaired electrons. Therefore, in order to study magnetic behavior in MoS 2 , it is imperative to synthesize flakes with high density of zigzag edges. In this study, we examine ferromagnetism in monolayer CVD grown MoS 2 flakes using quantum weak value measurement. The weak value based quantum measurement technique, originally formulated within quantum mechanics, provides a tool to amplify and probe small physical changes that otherwise pose a challenge to detection xu2024progress . Weak measurement theory proposes that a quantum observable can be weakly coupled to a measuring device, leading to an amplified shift in the measuring device’s pointer reading. Unlike a strong measurement, weak measurement does not collapse the wave function and allows for projection of state evolution on a post-selected state. This is where the most dramatic effects emerge with notably ultra large deviations in the pointer reading, far surpassing the range of allowed eigenvalues of the quantum state aharonov1988result . The first experimental realization of weak measurement in the field of optics was demonstrated in 1989 by Duck et al. providing experimental conditions required to access “weak values” duck1989sense . Since then, weak value amplification has been exploited to observe beam splitting like the spin Hall effect of light (SHEL), a phenomenon where a linearly polarized state of light splits into right and left circularly polarized light after interacting with a birefringent surface. This separation in space is extremely sensitive to changes in polarization of the incident state qin2011observation . Other examples of mechanical spatial beam shifts include Goos–Hänchen and Imbert–Fedorov goswami2014simultaneous . These ultrasensitive sensing techniques have been pivotal in enriching our understanding of novel phenomena in nanoscale materials li2020measurement . Measuring ferromagnetic response, especially from atomic layer structures poses a significant challenge due to the weak signal strength. Conventional techniques like superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID magnetometry) and magneto-optical Kerr effect (MOKE) setups struggle to detect minute polarization changes as the signal drops out of range of typical detectors cai2022room . In this work, we leverage SHEL combined with quantum weak value amplification, enabling detection of such magnetic responses that would otherwise remain inaccessible. This article discusses details of the synthesis of monolayer MoS 2 flakes under varying growth conditions, highlighting the impact of growth temperature, gas flow rate and substrate position relative to precursors, on the defect state and edge state density. We present details on morphology and compositional variations