A demarcation criterion for hydrogen burning of millinovae Facilities: Swift(XRT), AAVSO, SMARTS, VSOLJ, OGLE IV
Izumi Hachisu, Mariko Kato · 2025
Read A demarcation criterion for hydrogen burning of millinovae Facilities: Swift(XRT), AAVSO, SMARTS, VSOLJ, OGLE IV by Izumi Hachisu, Mariko Kato (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-10019.txt.
Introduction
Izumi Hachisu and Mariko Kato set a test for telling which faint nova-like flares are truly powered by burning hydrogen. Their study appeared in twenty twenty-five. The flares, called millinovae, shine in soft X-rays and peak far below normal novae, and experts disagree on what drives them.
One view blames a belt of gas on a white dwarf star. The other blames steady hydrogen burning on its surface, fed fast during an outburst. The authors studied a bright classical nova to compare a gas disk lit by a burning star with one that is not. The lit disk glowed far brighter. Their rule uses the gap between quiet and peak brightness. Only two candidate flares with soft X-rays pass it.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Izumi Hachisu, Mariko Kato |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-10019
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A demarcation criterion for hydrogen burning of millinovae Facilities: Swift(XRT), AAVSO, SMARTS, VSOLJ, OGLE IV Izumi Hachisu, Mariko Kato Abstract Millinovae are a new class of transient supersoft X-ray sources with no clear signature of mass ejection. They show similar triangle shapes of V / I V/I band light curves with thousand times fainter peaks than typical classical novae. Maccarone et al. regarded the prototype millinova, ASASSN-16oh, as a dwarf nova and interpreted the supersoft X-rays to originate from an accretion belt on a white dwarf (WD). Kato et al. proposed a nova model induced by a high-rate mass-accretion during a dwarf nova outburst; the X-rays originate from the photosphere of a hydrogen-burning hot WD whereas the V / I V/I band photons are from the irradiated accretion disk. Because each peak brightness differs largely from millinova to millinova, we suspect that not all the millinova candidates host a hydrogen burning WD. Based on the light curve analysis of the classical nova KT Eri that has a bright disk, we find that the disk is more than two magnitudes brighter when the disk is irradiated by the hydrogen burning WD than when not irradiated. We present the demarcation criterion for hydrogen burning to be I q − I max > 2.2 I_{\rm q}-I_{\rm max}>2.2 , where I q I_{q} and I max I_{\rm max} are the I I magnitudes in quiescence and at maximum light, respectively. Among many candidates, this requirement is satisfied with the two millinovae in which soft X-rays were detected. I Introduction A millinova is a transient supersoft X-ray source ( L_{X}\gtrsim 10^{35} erg s -1 ) with no clear signature of mass ejection. The outburst shape of its optical light curve is almost a symmetric triangle, the peak of which are thousand times fainter than those of typical classical novae. Such a new class of cataclysmic variables were dubbed millinovae by P. Mróz et al. [26] . A representative example of millinovae is ASASSN-16oh, which is a peculiar transient supersoft X-ray source in the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC) with no mass ejection signature [ 24 ] . The I light curve of the outburst shows a triangle shape, as plotted in Figure 1 . This figure also shows the X-ray count rates observed with the Swift/XRT (0.3–10.0 keV). The peak count rate is converted to the X-ray luminosity of L_{X}\sim 1\times 10^{37} erg s -1 [ 24 ] . Figure 1: The I light curve of ASASSN-16oh as well as the soft X-ray count rates observed with the Swift/XRT. The data are taken from the OGLE IV [ 36 ] and the Swift website [ 3 ] . The I_{\rm C} and Swift/XRT data of the Galactic classical nova KT Eri are overplotted at the distance of the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC), the data of which are the same as those in I. Hachisu et al. [11] . The brightnesses of the first and second plateau phases of KT Eri are indicated by the blue arrows. A nova is a thermonuclear runaway event on a mass-accreting white dwarf (WD). We show the optical and X-ray light curves of the Galactic classical nova KT Eri in Figures 1 and 2 . Novae usually brighten up by \Delta V\sim 10 mag or more in a few or tens days and decline in a few months or years. After hydrogen ignites on the WD, the hydrogen-rich envelope expands to a giant star size and emits strong winds [e.g. 20 , for a recent fully self-consistent nova model] . The nova brightness is dominated by free-free emission from optically thin ejecta outside the photosphere (see Figure 2 b). Thus, the peak optical brightness depends on the maximum wind mass-loss rate [ 5 , 6 , e.g.,] . Due to strong mass loss, the envelope loses its mass and the photosphere gradually shrinks and the photospheric temperature increases. Eventually the nova enters a supersoft X-ray source (SSS) phase after a large part of the initial envelope mass is lost. The envelope mass decreases further due to nuclear burning after the winds stop. Hydrogen burning ends when the envelope mass reaches a critical value. As a definition, a nova accompanies strong winds (mass-ejection) in the optical bright phase. The V/I light curve shapes and peak V/I brightnesses of KT Eri are typical in fast novae and very different from those of millinovae. There seem no common properties between ASASSN-16oh and KT Eri except showing a SSS phase and having a bright disk during the outburst. A dwarf nova is an rapid accretion event in an accretion disk, the mass accretion of which is temporarily enhanced by a thermal instability of an accretion disk [e.g. 27 , for a review] . If the instability develops from the outer region (outside-in outburst), the brightness rapidly rises toward maximum. On the other hand, when the outburst is inside-out (the instability starts from inside of the disk), the rise is slow and the light curve is more symmetric (triangle) [ 23 ] . Dwarf novae usually brighten up to M_{V,\rm peak}\sim+6 – +0 (or by \Delta V\sim 2 – 9 mag) in a day or so and stays at the brightness from a few days to a few weeks. The peak brightness depends on the orbital period; the longer the orbital period, the brighter the M_{V,\rm peak} [ 29 ] . However, no bright SSS phase ( L_{X}\gtrsim 1\times 10^{35} erg s -1 ) has ever been observed in dwarf nova outbursts [ 32 , 35 , typically L_{X}=10^{29} – 10^{32} erg s -1 ; ] . ASASSN-16oh was discovered by the All Sky Automated Survey for Supernovae (ASASSN) at V=16.9 [ 16 ] . Then, the brightness reaches M_{V}=-2.3 , where we assume that the distance modulus is \mu_{0}\equiv(m-M)_{0}=18.9 and the absorption in the V band is A_{V}=0.13 toward ASASSN-16oh [ 16 , 25 ] . The Optical Gravitational Lensing Experiment IV (OGLE-IV) [ 36 ] data show that the object is an irregular variable for several years with the quiescent luminosity of I=20.3 and V=21.1 [ 24 ] . The V and I light curves of ASASSN-16oh show a resemblance with those of long orbital-period dwarf novae such as V1017 Sgr in the peak brightness, outburst amplitude, and timescales. The orbital period of V1017 Sgr is P_{\rm orb}=5.786 days [ 33 ] . Therefore, T. J. Maccarone et al. [24] expected the orbital period of ASASSN-16oh to be several days. A. Rajoelimanana et al. [31] reported two peaks (0.1925 and 5.6619 days) in the periodgram of He II \lambda 4686 spectroscopic velocity data. It is in favor of the longer P_{\rm orb}=5.6619 days from the resemblance with V1017 Sgr. It has been argued whether or not soft X-rays in millinovae come from a hydrogen burning WD like in the SSS phase of a nova. In the present paper, we find that the classical nova KT Eri is one of the best examples for us to draw such a demarcation line for hydrogen burning in the color-magnitude diagram. In Section II , we summarize the previous studies on the origin of supersoft X-rays of ASASSN-16oh. In Section III , we explain physical properties of KT