Comparison of bar formation mechanisms. II. does a tidally induced bar grow faster than an internally developed bar?
Yirui Zheng, Juntai Shen, Xufen Wu, Bin-Hui Chen · 2025
Read Comparison of bar formation mechanisms. II. does a tidally induced bar grow faster than an internally developed bar? by Yirui Zheng, Juntai Shen, Xufen Wu, Bin-Hui Chen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-10014.txt.
Introduction
Galaxies grow bar-shaped hearts two ways: from their own instability, or nudged by a passing neighbor. Yirui Zheng and co-authors race the two routes in a 2025 simulation study, the second in a series on bar formation.
In disks already prone to bars, tidally triggered bars grew on about the same timescale as home-grown ones. The passing galaxy's wave mainly shifted the start time, advancing it when the wave arrived in step with a seed bar at the center. Out of step, it delayed the start instead. Once growing, the bar's pace belonged to the disk itself. Truly foreign triggering, the series suggests, matters most for disks that would never bar on their own.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yirui Zheng, Juntai Shen, Xufen Wu, Bin-Hui Chen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-10014
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Comparison of bar formation mechanisms. II. does a tidally induced bar grow faster than an internally developed bar? Yirui Zheng, Juntai Shen, Xufen Wu, Bin-Hui Chen Abstract Bar structures can form internally due to the instability of their host galaxies or externally due to perturbations from other galaxies. We systematically quantify the growth timescales ( τ bar \tau_{\mathrm{bar}} ) of bars formed through these two mechanisms with a series of controlled N N -body simulations. In galaxies susceptible to bar instability, tidally induced bars display τ bar \tau_{\mathrm{bar}} values comparable to those of internally developed bars within the same disk. Tidal perturbations promote(delay) bar formation by advancing(postponing) its onset, but the growth rate of the bar structure remains largely unchanged. In these interaction scenarios, the bar formation is still driven primarily by the galaxy’s internal nature, which remains unaffected by tidal perturbations. As the external perturbation wave reaches the galaxy’s center, it evokes a “seed bar” that is then swing amplified. In this scenario, the onset of bar formation is advanced. Conversely, bar formation may be delayed if the external perturbation wave is out of phase with the preexisting spontaneously developed seed bar, which causes destructive interference and limits the bar growth. In the hot disk model that resists bar formation in isolation, the τ bar \tau_{\mathrm{bar}} of the tidally forced bar correlates with the strength of the perturbation. The bar growth in this model deviates from an exponential profile and is better described by a linear function. The varied τ bar \tau_{\mathrm{bar}} and the preference for linear growth contrast with bars formed in galaxies inherently susceptible to bar instability. These tidally forced bars may not adhere to the swing amplification mechanism that predicts an exponential bar growth. agama [ 53 ] , GADGET-4 [ 50 , 51 ] . NumPy [ 18 ] , SciPy [ 54 ] , Matplotlib [ 21 ] , Jupyter Notebook [ 28 ] I Introduction Bars are a common feature in spiral galaxies. Locally, about half of spiral galaxies possess bars in optical bands, with this proportion rising to two-thirds in infrared bands [ 39 , 42 , 12 , 30 ] . Although a smaller fraction of galaxies have bars at higher redshifts, they still represent 13% in the range 2<z\leq 3 [ 29 ] and appear as early as z\sim 4 [ 17 ] . Bars significantly influence the evolution of their host galaxies, including triggering gas inflow, affecting star formation, and contributing to the formation of pseudobulges [ 41 , 31 , 33 , 34 , 22 ] . The Milky Way also has a bar [ 8 , 5 , e.g.,] , and its boxy bulge and gas dynamics are directly linked to this bar [ 49 , 32 , e.g.,] . The prevalence and impact of bars on galaxies highlight the importance of studying their formation and evolution. Galactic bars can form via internal or external mechanisms. Internally, bars can develop spontaneously due to the gravitational instability of the disks [ 19 , 44 , 48 , 36 ] . A widely recognized mechanism for spontaneous bar formation is the swing amplification loop, initially developed by Goldreich & Lynden-Bell [16] and Julian & Toomre [25] and further elaborated by Toomre [52] . Binney [1] revisited this concept and provided a more accessible explanation. According to this model, any source of noise generates a packet of leading spiral waves, which are then amplified as they swing from leading to trailing. The amplified trailing waves propagate through the disk center and reemerge as a leading disturbance, which then triggers the next swing amplification loop. The repeated amplification process amplifies minor noise into a prominent spiral pattern and ultimately facilitates the formation of a coherent bar. The positive feedback loop predicts exponential growth of the spiral/bar strength. Several studies investigated the growth rate or equivalently the formation timescale of bars formed via internal instability. The formation timescale is found to depend on the bulge-to-disk mass fraction [ 26 ] , the Toomre Q parameter [ 20 , 55 ] , and the disk thickness [ 15 ] . Fujii et al. [13] found an exponentially decreasing relation between the bar formation timescale and increasing disk mass fraction. The “Fujii relation” was then confirmed in Bland-Hawthorn et al. [3] . An important improvement in the latter work is the quantification of the exponential growth timescale associated with the swing amplification loop instead of Fujii’s fixed threshold for when a bar appears ( A_{2,max}>0.2 ). Bland-Hawthorn et al. [3] demonstrated that an exponential fit to the growth of A_{2} over time provides a timescale and an onset time, and also reproduces the Fujii relation independently of any assumptions about A_{2} . Several studies have suggested that the disk mass fraction plays a primary role in determining the bar formation timescale [ 13 , 3 , 2 , 4 ] . Thus, it is important to control the disk mass fraction when investigating the effects of other parameters on bar formation. Besides the internal instability, bar formation can also be externally induced by various gravitational perturbations, including flyby encounters with other galaxies, collisions, mergers, or the tidal effects of galaxy clusters [ 6 , 14 , 38 , 40 , 37 ] . A comprehensive investigation is desired to compare the growth and evolution of bars formed through different mechanisms. Studies have indicated that tidal interactions can either promote or delay bar formation [ 38 , 43 , 35 , 45 , 56 ] . This raises a question: if tidal forces either promote or delay the formation of bars, do they result in bars that grow at a faster or slower rate compared to those formed internally? Alternatively, do these bars grow at similar rates but onset at different times? Moetazedian et al. [43] found that the exponential growth rate of tidal bars is independent of the number of satellite encounters and their orbits. However, the rescaled mass of the primary satellite in their simulation is only < 1% compared to the host halo mass of the galaxy, which limits the strength of the tidal perturbation. Previous studies have predominantly focused on either the internal or external mechanisms of bar formation, with less attention given to comparing these two mechanisms. In this series of papers, we aim to offer a comprehensive comparison between bars formed through different mechanisms. In Zheng & Shen [57, Paper I hereafter] , we conducted a series of controlled N -body simulations to examine the pattern speed \Omega_{p} of tidally induced bars and compared them with their spontaneous counterparts in the same galaxy model. We found that bars formed via both mechanisms exhibit similar distributions in the pattern speed–bar strength ( \Omega_{p}-A_{2} ) space and display comparable ratios of corotation radius to bar length ( {\cal R}={R_{\mathrm{CR}}}/{R_{\mathrm{bar}}} ). As for “tidally forced bars” that refer specifically to those in galaxies stable against bar instability, they indeed rotate slower than internally developed ones in less stable galaxies. However, this difference in pattern speed is attributed to the varying internal properties of bar host galaxies, rather than the different formation mechanisms. In this second paper, we broaden our investigation to compare