More about quark Yukawa textures from selection rules without group actions
Tatsuo Kobayashi 1, Yume Nishioka 1, Hajime Otsuka 2 , and, Morimitsu Tanimoto 3 · 2025
Read More about quark Yukawa textures from selection rules without group actions by Tatsuo Kobayashi 1, Yume Nishioka 1, Hajime Otsuka 2 , and, Morimitsu Tanimoto 3 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-09966.txt.
Introduction
Tatsuo Kobayashi and co-authors derive rules for which quark couplings a certain kind of symmetry allows, in a 2025 paper. Yukawa textures, patterns of zeros in the coupling matrices, shape quark masses and mixing. Usually they come from group symmetries acting on fields. This work instead uses non-group symmetries built by gauging a discrete symmetry, which obey subtler selection rules.
For three small cases the authors map exactly which textures the rules produce. The harvest includes the classic nearest-neighbor interaction pattern and extensions beyond it. Some textures cannot be obtained from any ordinary group symmetry at all. The exotic cases are not just curiosities: they open phenomenology such as solving the strong CP problem without an axion particle.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tatsuo Kobayashi 1, Yume Nishioka 1, Hajime Otsuka 2 , and, Morimitsu Tanimoto 3 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 71 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-09966
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
More about quark Yukawa textures from selection rules without group actions Tatsuo Kobayashi 1, Yume Nishioka 1, Hajime Otsuka 2 , and, Morimitsu Tanimoto 3 Abstract We study the coupling selection rules associated with non-group symmetries, i.e., ℤ 2 \mathbb{Z}_{2} gauging of ℤ M \mathbb{Z}_{M} symmetries. We clarify which Yukawa textures can be derived by our selection rules for M = 3 , 4 M=3,4 , and 5, and obtain various textures including the nearest neighbor interaction type and its extension. Some of them cannot be realized by a conventional group-like symmetry. They lead to interesting phenomenology such as a solution to the strong CP problem without axion. Preprint: EPHOU-25-003 KYUSHU-HET-312 1 Introduction Symmetries are important in physics. In particle physics, symmetries determine selection rules of allowed couplings and forbidden couplings. We often consider group symmetries in theory leading to definite coupling selection rules. In models with group symmetry, each field corresponds to a representation of the group. Their couplings are allowed only if a product of their representations becomes the identity of the group. When we choose representations of (n-1) fields in the n -point coupling, the representation, which the n -th field should have in the allowed coupling, is fixed automatically. When we apply such a group selection rule to the Yukawa couplings, the Yukawa matrices must be diagonal for flavors with different quantum numbers of the group, and we can not realize flavor mixing. In order to realize the flavor mixing, the flavor group must be broken, e.g. by flavon fields. Effective Yukawa couplings including vacuum expectation values (VEVs) of flavons behave as spurions with non-trivial representations of the group. Note that flavor mixing appears after group symmetry breaking in Abelian flavor group models [ 1 ] and non-Abelian ones [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] . One exception is modular flavor symmetric models [ 9 ] . In those models, Yukawa couplings are modular forms, which are holomorphic functions of modulus, and transform non-trivially under finite modular groups such as S_{3} , A_{4} , S_{4} , and A_{5} [ 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] . (See for reviews Refs. [ 13 , 14 ] , including a possible set of ultraviolet completions.) Recently, the symmetries, which have no group structure, were studied intensively. They satisfy the fusion algebra U_{i}\otimes U_{j}=\sum_{k}c^{k}_{ij}U_{k} , where U_{i} are topological operators. These symmetries were discussed in two-dimensional conformal field theories and four-dimensional quantum field theories. More than one operator appears on the right-hand side of the above fusion algebra. On the other hand, in group theory, the product of two group elements a and b is uniquely fixed, i.e., ab=c . That is an important difference. Thus, it would be possible to derive flavor mixing from symmetry without group structure, even if such a symmetry is not broken. Such a situation happens when the four-dimensional theory has, for instance, a non-invertible symmetry, where fields \phi_{i} can be labeled by conjugacy classes [g_{i}] of a certain group G . Then, one can arrive at the following fusion of two conjugacy classes [g_{i}]\otimes[g_{j}]=\sum_{k}d_{ij}^{k}[g_{k}] [ 15 , 16 ] , which put constraints on the interaction of fields [ 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 ] . In Ref. [ 21 ] , we applied this concept to flavor physics. We studied the symmetries and coupling selection rules, which are obtained by \mathbb{Z}_{2} gauging of \mathbb{Z}_{M} symmetries, where \mathbb{Z}_{2} is the outer automorphism of \mathbb{Z}_{M} symmetries. These coupling selection rules can be derived from a certain string compactification as non-invertible symmetries [ 22 , 23 ] . For instance, in the context of four-dimensional (4D) effective action of higher-dimensional Yang-Mills theory compactified on T^{2}/\mathbb{Z}_{2} with magnetic fluxes, momentum operators on T^{2} are constrained in the \mathbb{Z}_{2} -invariant form. These topological operators induce the non-invertible symmetries. Then, it was found that the non-invertible symmetries provide flavor symmetries of chiral zero modes and determine their flavor structure. The obtained selection rules do not correspond to those associated with group-like symmetries. Furthermore, one can derive the flavor mixing without symmetry breaking. In our approach, various texture zeros can be realized in the 3\times 3 Yukawa matrices, which can not be obtained from group selection rules before symmetry breaking. Some of them have not been studied until now because they were not derived from conventional flavor symmetries. The texture zeros approach has a long history, but it does not have a strong theoretical basis. In the framework of two families of quarks, Weinberg put a mass matrix by hand for the down-type quark sector with zero (1,1) entry in the basis in which the up-type quark mass matrix is diagonal [ 24 ] . Fritzsch extended the above approach to the three family case [ 25 , 26 ] . Ramond, Roberts and Ross have studied four or five zeros textures, which were also put by hand, for symmetric or hermitian quark mass matrices [ 27 ] . Their textures are not viable today since they cannot describe the current rather precise data on the CKM quark mixing matrix. However, the texture zero approach to the mass matrices of quarks and leptons is still promising because it has the big prediction power in the flavor physics [ 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 ] . In this paper, we systematically study the texture structures, which can be derived by our coupling selection rules associated with \mathbb{Z}_{2} gauging of \mathbb{Z}_{M} symmetries. Also, we discuss the phenomenological implication of interesting texture zeros we obtain in the quark sector. This paper is organized as follows. In section 2 , we explain how to apply non-trivial fusion rules to particle physics. In section 3 , we review our coupling selection rules. In section 4 , we systematically study which Yukawa textures can be derived for M=3 . Similarly, we study textures for M=4 and 5 in section 5 . In section 6 , we discuss the phenomenological implications of interesting textures in the quark sector. Section 7 is our conclusion. In Appendices A and B , we show our detailed results for M=4 and 5. In Appendix C , we show the relation about the Jarlskog invariant. 2 Coupling selection rules and fusion rules Here, we explain how to apply non-trivial fusion rules to particle physics. We start with the selection rules due to group theory in order to emphasize the difference of selection rules. Suppose that the elements, a,b,c , belong to the group G , and they satisfy the following multiplication law: \displaystyle ab=c. (2.1) The element appearing in the right hand side is unique in group theory. In G -invariant field theory, each field corresponds to a (representation of) element of G . For example, the scalar fields \phi_{a},\phi_{b},\phi_{c},\phi_{d} correspond to the elements a,b,c,d in G . If ab=c , group theory allows the process \phi_{a}+\phi_{b}\to\phi_{c} . If ab\neq d , the process \phi_{a}+\phi_{b}\to\phi_{d} is forbidden. That is the coupling selection rules due to group theory. When G is Abelian, that is the charge conservation law. The important point is that the element appearing in the right hand side of Eq. ( 2.1 ) is