Earth as an Exoplanet: Investigating the effects of cloud variability on the direct-imaging of atmospheres

Soumil Kelkar, Prabal Saxena, Ravi Kopparapu, Joy Monteiro · 2025

Read Earth as an Exoplanet: Investigating the effects of cloud variability on the direct-imaging of atmospheres by Soumil Kelkar, Prabal Saxena, Ravi Kopparapu, Joy Monteiro (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-09136.txt.

Introduction

Soumil Kelkar and co-authors treat Earth as an exoplanet to study cloud effects in a 2025 paper. A planet's spectrum is a snapshot that shifts with weather, above all with clouds. That shifting can hide air components and confuse efforts to pin down a baseline atmosphere. Instead of modeling clouds from scratch, the team used real Earth cloud data from a major archive.

Cloud cover and height strongly changed how detectable key gases were, including oxygen, ozone, and water vapor. Varying cover could also confound attempts to retrieve a stable atmosphere for a planet. The findings bear directly on future direct imaging missions hunting habitable worlds. Readers see why weather may be the noise that limits life detection.

Catalog record

CREATORSoumil Kelkar, Prabal Saxena, Ravi Kopparapu, Joy Monteiro
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE71 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-09136

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Earth as an Exoplanet: Investigating the effects of cloud variability on the direct-imaging of atmospheres Soumil Kelkar, Prabal Saxena, Ravi Kopparapu, Joy Monteiro Abstract A planet’s spectrum is dynamic and only represents a time-dependent snapshot of its properties. Changing atmospheric conditions due to climate and weather patterns, particularly variation in cloud cover, can significantly affect the spectrum in ways that complicate the understanding of a planet’s baseline atmospheric properties. Variable cloud cover and cloud properties affect the detectability of atmospheric constituents, and also greatly influence the radiative transfer that determines a planet’s spectrum. This has considerable implications for direct imaging observations of potentially habitable exoplanets and thus it is critical to study and characterize the effects of clouds on their spectra. Clouds have been extensively modeled before and their effects have been incorporated across climate frameworks spanning a spectrum of complexity. Given the challenges associated with modeling clouds, we adopt a novel approach in this work to study the effects of clouds by using real-time cloud data from Earth observations. Treating Earth as an exoplanet and using detailed observations from the MERRA-2 data collection, we quantify the effects of cloud variability on the spectrum as well as on the detectability of atmospheric constituents, specifically biomarkers like O 2 \text{O}_{2} , O 3 \text{O}_{3} and H 2 ​ O \text{H}_{2}\text{O} . The coverage and vertical position of clouds significantly affects the SNRs of these gases and subsequently their detectability in exo-Earth atmospheres. Moreover, we show that variations in the amount of cloud cover will potentially confound efforts to retrieve a stable baseline atmosphere for a planet. This work has important applications to future direct-imaging missions like the Habitable Worlds Observatory (HWO). I Introduction Amongst all the 5700 exoplanets detected so far 1 1 1 https://exoplanetarchive.ipac.caltech.edu/ , there is a significant dearth of exoplanets with properties similar to the inner rocky worlds of our Solar System, including Earth (see figure 1 in [ 11 ] ). This deficiency is mainly in part due to the higher sensitivity of current detection methods toward massive planets on short orbital periods. To address this issue, the ‘Pathways to Discovery in Astronomy \& Astrophysics for the 2020s’ report [ 43 ] recommended an ultraviolet/optical/infrared space observatory to find and characterize Earth-like planets around nearby stars, specifically the ones which might be potentially habitable. Based on this recommendation, NASA is laying the groundwork for its next flagship mission, currently referred to as the Habitable Worlds Observatory (HWO) which draws from previous mission concepts like the LUVOIR [ 37 ] and Habex [ 12 ] . A significant part of the science pre-cursor work for these mission concepts is devoted to simulating reflected light spectra of planets, computing exposure times, and quantifying the detectability of important atmospheric constituents and biosignatures. However, the surface of the planet and/or its atmospheric composition may not be homogeneous, and thus a planet’s spectrum is not static but rather dynamic. Moreover, natural variation in cloud coverage due to weather and climate patterns can also significantly affect the characterization of exoplanet atmospheres. Clouds are ubiquitous on Earth and other solar system planets, and observations strongly suggest their presence on exoplanets as well ( [ 35 , 53 , 34 ] ). A cloud is defined as the condensate that forms when the vapor pressure of an atmospheric constituent exceeds its saturation vapor pressure ( [ 38 ] ). In this way, cloud formation provides a sink for an atmospheric constituent. Earth is dominated by clouds composed mostly of water vapor, however, there is a huge diversity in the composition of clouds on planets in our Solar System. This includes sulphuric acid clouds on Venus ( [ 20 ] ), \text{CO}_{2} ice clouds on Mars ( [ 42 ] ), and ammonia clouds on Jupiter ( [ 2 ] ), to name a few. Given the diversity in the estimated planetary and atmospheric compositions of exoplanets detected so far, we would also expect their atmospheres to host clouds and other aerosols of varied compositions. A haze is referred to as any condensate produced by photochemistry or other non-equilibrium chemical processes ( [ 38 ] ), however, the term is often used interchangeably with cloud. A general framework of clouds in the atmospheres of Solar system planets is given in [ 48 ] and a comprehensive summary of clouds and cloud formation in exoplanet atmospheres is given in [ 38 , 22 , 10 ] . Clouds affect a planet’s radiation budget in three important ways - (i) by reflecting/scattering shortwave stellar radiation back to space, (ii) by absorbing and re-emitting longwave thermal radiation emitted by the surface, and (iii) also by emitting their own thermal radiation. Clouds can complicate the radiative transfer processes in an exoplanet’s atmosphere and significantly impact the planet’s spectrum. Clouds tend to have high albedos, especially in the visible wavelength band, and thus any planet with a cloudy atmosphere will reflect much more light than a cloudless planet, enhancing the continuum in the reflected light spectrum. Clouds improve the detectability of atmospheric constituents in the visible band, especially those present in significant amounts above the cloud layer, by increasing the albedo and subsequently boosting their absorption signals ( [ 25 , 66 ] , section 3.2 of this work). The effects of clouds on the reflected light spectra were modelled by [ 39 , 59 , 4 ] for giant exoplanets and by [ 29 ] for Earth-like exoplanets. Since clouds enhance a planet’s albedo, they may impact whether a planet is visible or not via direct imaging. The impact of clouds on the planet’s albedo is explored in [ 30 ] . Clouds are a significant contributor to the greenhouse effect as they absorb and re-emit outgoing longwave radiation emitted by the surface. Thus, the presence of clouds has a profound impact on the thermal emission spectrum of a planet. Due to the greenhouse effect, clouds dampen the spectral features of certain gases in the infrared. The effects of clouds on the thermal emission spectra of planets have been discussed in [ 60 , 21 , 30 , 62 ] . Furthermore, clouds also affect spectral signatures originating from the surface, for example, the vegetation red edge signal characteristic of surface vegetation, as shown in models ( [ 61 , 41 ] ) and observations of Earth ( [ 1 , 19 ] ). Clouds have been extensively modelled with different models spanning a spectrum of complexity. The simplest of cloud models are parametrized models ( [ 10 ] and references therein) which are typically used for retrieval studies. These models do not include any treatment of the physical processes associated with cloud formation and composition but simply use a set of parameters to estimate the first order effects of clouds. More complex models, on the other hand, involve cloud microphysics and they typically assume a functional form for the cloud particle size distribution. These cloud models are incorporated into general climate model frameworks ranging from 1D radiative-convective models to 3D general circulation models (GCMs). 1D climate models, by virtue of their definition, cannot estimate differences in horizontal cloud coverage and thus cannot model atmospheres with patchy clouds. Naturally, they

Read the complete text