On the million-degree signature of spicules

Souvik Bose, Jayant Joshi, Paola Testa, Bart De Pontieu · 2025

Read On the million-degree signature of spicules by Souvik Bose, Jayant Joshi, Paola Testa, Bart De Pontieu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-08887.txt.

Introduction

Souvik Bose, Jayant Joshi, Paola Testa, and Bart De Pontieu hunt for the million-degree glow of solar spicules. Spicules are thin jets that leap from the Sun's surface. They clearly reach the warm layer above it, but whether they heat to true coronal levels is contested. Their speed, small size, and tangled heat states make proof hard.

The team paired two space instruments watching the same quiet regions and a coronal hole. Heat maps built from the coronal images show small jets at one million degrees. Those jets line up in place and time with spicules seen in cooler light. Their glow runs two to three times the background level. The jets also race outward in step with the spicules. The authors read this as firm evidence that spicules do reach coronal heat.

Catalog record

CREATORSouvik Bose, Jayant Joshi, Paola Testa, Bart De Pontieu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-08887

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the million-degree signature of spicules Souvik Bose, Jayant Joshi, Paola Testa, Bart De Pontieu Abstract Spicules have often been proposed as substantial contributors toward the mass and energy balance of the solar corona. While their transition region (TR) counterpart has unequivocally been established over the past decade, the observations concerning the coronal contribution of spicules have often been contested. This is mainly attributed to the lack of adequate coordinated observations, their small spatial scales, highly dynamic nature, and complex multi-thermal evolution, which are often observed at the limit of our current observational facilities. Therefore, it remains unclear how much heating occurs in association with spicules to coronal temperatures. In this study, we use coordinated high-resolution observations of the solar chromosphere, TR, and corona of a quiet Sun region and a coronal hole with the Interface Region Imaging Spectrograph (IRIS) and the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (AIA) to investigate the (lower) coronal ( ∼ \sim 1MK) emission associated with spicules. We perform differential emission measure (DEM) analysis on the AIA passbands using basis pursuit and a newly developed technique based on Tikhonov regularization to probe the thermal structure of the spicular environment at coronal temperatures. We find that the EM maps at 1 MK reveal the presence of ubiquitous, small-scale jets with a clear spatio-temporal coherence with the spicules observed in the IRIS/TR passband. Detailed space-time analysis of the chromospheric, TR, and EM maps show unambiguous evidence of rapidly outward propagating spicules with strong emission (2—3 times higher than the background) at 1 MK. Our findings are consistent with previously reported MHD simulations that show heating to coronal temperatures associated with spicules. Journal: ApJL SunPy [ 3 ] , SciPy [ 65 ] , Matplotlib [ 33 ] , Numpy [ 29 ] , SSWIDL I Introduction Spicules are thin, dynamic, thread-like features that appear ubiquitously on the surface of the Sun. They are one of the most abundantly observed features in the chromosphere, and their origin and role have long been a subject of debate [ 4 , 61 , 32 , 11 ] . Being ubiquitous, the mechanisms that drive spicules have held promise as contributing to coronal heating events [ 2 , 22 ] , and the chromospheric mass-flux that these events propel to coronal heights is estimated to be two orders of magnitude higher than required to balance the mass-loss due to solar wind [ 67 ] . It is estimated that at any given moment, the Sun’s surface hosts at least a million spicules [ 4 , and possibly significantly higher based on high-resolution observations] in active regions or quiet Sun, [ 34 ] rapidly propagating outward. Historically, spicules have mainly been observed in the chromospheric and transition region (TR) passband [ 4 , 26 ] , but due to the lack of adequate high-resolution observations, a coronal counterpart was missing until high-resolution extreme ultraviolet (EUV) observations from space became available in the past decade. As a result, the possibility of energizing the solar corona through spicules was dismissed as unlikely in many of these early studies. The discovery of the short-lived and more dynamic ( \sim 50 - 100 km/s) off-limb “type-II” spicules by [ 21 ] sparked renewed interest in their role of outer atmospheric heating since many of these spicules appeared to “fade” from the Hinode Ca ii H passband unlike their classical type-I counterpart. Such fading suggested a scenario where the opacity of Ca ii H type-II spicules rapidly dropped during the spicule lifetime, possibly because of a combination of their dynamic evolution or even heating, to higher temperatures. Coordinated observations between Hinode and Atmospheric Imaging Assembly [ 38 , AIA,] channels onboard NASA’s Solar Dynamics Observatory [ 51 , SDO,] , and later with the Interface Region Imaging Spectrograph [ 23 , IRIS,] revealed that significant heating occurs in at least a subset of threads in type-II spicules along their whole length to TR temperatures [ 22 , 50 , \sim 80,000 K,] . The on-disk counterparts of type-II spicules, termed rapid blue/red-shifted excursions [ 54 , RBEs and RREs,] , were also associated with heating to at least TR [ 63 , 53 , termed as network jets,] and possibly even coronal temperatures [ 22 , 30 , 16 ] . Despite substantial advancements in our understanding of the impact of spicules in the TR, their role in mass loading and heating the corona has remained a subject of significant debate both from an observational and a theoretical point of view. Several studies challenged their importance for the coronal mass and energy balance and argued that type-II spicules either play no role in coronal emission/heating [ 39 ] or their role is likely not a dominant one [ 64 ] . This continued controversy is, in part, because the relatively poor resolution (compared to the size of the spicules) of existing coronal instruments has rendered it challenging to assess their impact on the coronal energy balance. Moreover, the presence of cooler (TR, < 0.5 MK) ions in the optically thin lines in the AIA passbands [ 47 , 43 , 25 ] renders an additional challenge because the observed emission could well be attributed to these “cooler” ions instead of \geq 1 MK coronal emission. Furthermore, simplifying numerical assumptions [ 36 , 60 ] on the nature of the spicular plasma and the single-field-line approach of modeling spicules underestimates the complexity of the spicular environment, as evidenced by the complex processes involved in the coronal heating associated with spicules in multi-dimensional radiative MHD simulations [ 42 ] . The focus of this paper is not on the contribution of spicules towards coronal heating but rather we take a step back and attempt to investigate their \sim 1 MK signature unambiguously, by targeting a quiet Sun (QS) and a coronal hole (CH) region, using coordinated IRIS and SDO/AIA observations. By narrowing our target to the above regions, we are most likely studying the \sim 1 MK signature associated with type-II spicules since they are the more abundantly found in QS and CHs [ 48 ] . Therefore, unless otherwise mentioned, we refer to type-II spicules generally as spicules in this paper. We exploit the high-resolution observations from IRIS to track the TR counterpart of (chromospheric) spicules and investigate their impact on the associated coronal structures, which can be observed in the form of propagating coronal disturbances [ 19 , 55 , 10 , 8 , PCDs,] . Differential emission measure (DEM) analysis using two independent approaches is performed to study the thermal structure of the spicular plasma/PCDs within a temperature range centered around \sim 1 MK. II Observations and data analysis Figure 1: Overview of the coordinated IRIS–SDO/AIA quiet-Sun dataset 1 and the derived space-time maps. Top row, panel (a) : IRIS Si iv 1400 Å SJ image, panel (b) : corresponding SDO/AIA 171 Å image, panel (c) : EM map at log T[K]=5.9 computed from the sparse-matrix method [ 12 ] , panel (d) : EM map at log T[K]=5.95 obtained from the Tikhonov regularization method [ 52 ] . The white dashed vertical lines in the above panels indicate the FOV covered by the IRIS rasters and the rectangular

Read the complete text