Spacetime events from the inside out.

Gerard Milburn · 2025

Read Spacetime events from the inside out. by Gerard Milburn (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-08715.txt.

Introduction

Gerard Milburn, a physicist, argues in 2025 that relativity quietly treats each event in spacetime as the outcome of a quantum measurement. That starting point, he says, changes how we should think about the link between spacetime and gravity. His paper builds the case from the view of an agent living inside spacetime, acting and sensing from within.

He describes a Bell test that uses measurements ordered in time and points to a causal pattern that is not classical, yet sends no signals. On his reading, known Bell test results already show the non-classical shape of flat spacetime for an inside observer. He also argues that such an agent can learn the shape of spacetime from its own internal measurements.

Catalog record

CREATORGerard Milburn
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-08715

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Spacetime events from the inside out. Gerard Milburn Abstract We argue that special and general theories of relativity implicitly assume spacetime events correspond to quantum measurement outcomes. This leads to a change in how one should view the equivalence of spacetime and gravity. We describe a Bell test using time-like measurements that indicates a non classical causal structure that does not violate no-signaling. From this perspective, the violation of the Bell inequalities are already evidence for the non classical structure of flat spacetime as seen by an agent embedded in it. We argue that spacetime geometry can be learned by an embedded agent with internal actuators and sensors making internal measurements. Physics alone may not be able to provide answers to the space and time issue. Instead, it is up to neuroscience to address them. [ 1 ] 1 Introduction. It has been apparent since at least the Chapel Hill conference in 1955 [ 2 ] that the world revealed by Schrödinger and Heisenberg is incompatible with the world revealed by Einstein, despite the astounding experimental success of quantum theory and general relativity. The resulting discontent has fueled a search for a quantum theory of gravity despite the lack of any compelling experimental evidence to do so. There is a general belief that a quantum understanding of space and time will emerge from a quantum theory of gravity. Or have we missed something? The experimental tests of quantum theory via Bell violations are among the top-shelf achievements of quantum theory and quite consistent with the theory of relativity. Yet there is something mysterious about this consistency. As Gisin puts it, ”no story in space–time can describe nonlocal correlations” [ 3 ] . Gisin, like many others, describes the quantum correlations revealed in Bell tests as ‘nonlocal’ correlations. It is hard to describe it any other way, yet it is easy to design expressions which violate the Bell inequalities even for time-like separated observers. In fact, the spacetime coordinates of the observers play no role at all. It is in this sense that that quantum correlations seem to be coming from outside spacetime itself. What is at stake here is our deep-seated intuition that that an agent, like us, can only act here and now according to internal states. This perspective has been emphasised by Buzaski [ 1 ] . In this paper, we will discuss a version of the Bell tests that use a single agent and time-like separation of the detection events. One might think that this is unlikely to raise issues of non locality. However, using the same logic as the standard Bell violation argument, the single agent scenario suggests a surprising interpretation: retro causation without superluminal signalling to the past. Prior to quantum theory, we could describe the world as being built from classical variables that describe objective properties of that world. In quantum optics, for example, we perform experiments on the electromagnetic field using sources and detectors. The quantum field is not a classical field like Maxwell’s fields. It does not have independent properties like electric or magnetic field magnitudes that have independent causal efficacy. Only measurements results in a particular experiment context have causal efficacy. The value of the electric field is established by a particular class of experiments (homodyne and heterodyne detection). If we want to estimate the intensity of the field, we do a very different kind of measurement; we count photons. These are complementary experiments in the sense of Bohr. If we have a single charge in a superposition of two locations in an ion trap, we do not worry that the resulting EM field has no classical interpretation. We simply measure what QM predicts. The classical gravitational field, as revealed in GR, is a very different matter. In Einstein’s formulation gravity is represented by the same mathematical object as space-time geometry. To measure the gravitational field we need to find ways to estimate the metric. Einstein used imaginary clocks and rulers. Today, we use quantum field theory … QED. The objective is to estimate the components of a metric as best we can given the bounds imposed by quantum uncertainty [ 4 ] . A good example is measurement of the perturbations to the Minkowski metric that define gravitational waves, h_{\mu\nu} . That is what LIGO does, and it certainly uses quantum fields. We tend to think that the gravitational field is an objective fact in the world as it is highly classical. We do not need to worry about graviton statistics. The analogue, in the context of the electromagnetic field, are those states excited by large classical current sources. Recently, experimentalists have started probing highly non classical sources of gravity. A simple example is a single massive object in a superposition of ‘two places’ . This only makes sense if there is a background reference frame. The idea of ‘two places’ presupposes a further background spacetime metric in addition to that produced by the gravitational field of the massive object itself. This is the analogue of the EM field of a charge in a superposition at two places in an ion trap. We could simply claim that there is no objective field until we measure it. But there is a big difference. Gravity has the same mathematical structure as spacetime (the strong equivalence principle). Do we really want to say spacetime is not an objective feature of the world but only revealed, however obscurely, by particular measurement results? This would require us to claim that spacetime events are comprehensively equivalent to measurement results and thus contingent on the kinds of measurement we make. What is at stake in these new experiments is not the reality of gravity or wether gravity is quantum or classical, but the reality of spacetime. It must emerge as an observer-dependent feature by making measurements on something more fundamental. Is this an opening for a better spacetime story of the Bell violations? 1.1 Bell tests with three agents. The standard description of photonic tests of Bell inequalities involves two agents and an entangled photon source. I will include an additional agent to make it clear how the required correlation functions are constructed. A standard Bell test with polarization-entangled photons is shown in Fig.( 1 ). Figure 1: A two-party Bell experiment with entangled photons. A source at the origin produces pairs of entangled photons. The photons occupy oppositely directed spatial modes; one goes to detector-A and the other goes to detector-B. Both observers are space-lie separated. After each measurement, the setting and the outcome are sent, over classical channels, to a checker, observer-C, who stores the data for each trial and constructs the appropriate correlation function to check a Bell inequality. In an ideal experiment, we use single-photon excitations of polarised spatio-temporal modes such that the photons are emitted in opposite directions, with anti-correlated polarisation states. The photons are entangled in the polarisation. For example, the source could prepare, in every trial, the two-photon state, |\Psi^{-}\rangle=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(|HV\rangle-|VH\rangle) (1) where |HV\rangle=|1\rangle_{k_{A},H}\otimes|1\rangle_{k_{B},V} and the subscripts label spatio-temporal modes with wave vectors k_{A},k_{B} and corresponding polarisation. A single trail corresponds to emitting a two-photon state and counting two photons; one at observer-a and one at observer-B. If for some reason

Read the complete text