When Discourse Stalls: Moving Past Five Semantic Stopsigns about Generative AI in Design Research
Willem van der Maden, Vera van der Burg, Brett A. Halperin, Petra Jääskeläinen, Joseph Lindley, Derek Lomas, Timothy Merritt · 2025
Read When Discourse Stalls: Moving Past Five Semantic Stopsigns about Generative AI in Design Research by Willem van der Maden, Vera van der Burg, Brett A. Halperin, Petra Jääskeläinen, Joseph Lindley, Derek Lomas, Timothy Merritt (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-08565.txt.
Introduction
Willem van der Maden and co-workers name five phrases that shut down debate about generative AI in design research, in a 2025 essay. The field is changing fast, but discussion often collapses into slogans. The authors call these reductive framings semantic stopsigns, because they end inquiry instead of starting it.
Drawing on two expert workshops and interviews with practicing designers, they show how each stopsign appears in research and studio talk. Each one is then rebuilt into a more careful framing that designers can actually use. The aim is mid-level knowledge: stronger than slogans, closer to practice than grand theory. The authors invite readers to test the stopsigns against their own work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Willem van der Maden, Vera van der Burg, Brett A. Halperin, Petra Jääskeläinen, Joseph Lindley, Derek Lomas, Timothy Merritt |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-08565
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
When Discourse Stalls: Moving Past Five Semantic Stopsigns about Generative AI in Design Research Willem van der Maden, Vera van der Burg, Brett A. Halperin, Petra Jääskeläinen, Joseph Lindley, Derek Lomas, Timothy Merritt Abstract This essay examines how Generative AI (GenAI) is rapidly transforming design practices and how discourse often falls into over-simplified narratives that impede meaningful research and practical progress. We identify and deconstruct five prevalent “semantic stopsigns”—reductive framings about GenAI in design that halt deeper inquiry and limit productive engagement. Reflecting upon two expert workshops at ACM conferences and semi-structured interviews with design practitioners, we analyze how these stopsigns manifest in research and practice. Our analysis develops mid-level knowledge that bridges theoretical discourse and practical implementation, helping designers and researchers interrogate common assumptions about GenAI in their own contexts. By recasting these stopsigns into more nuanced frameworks, we provide the design research community with practical approaches for thinking about and working with these emerging technologies. August 24, 2026 1 Introduction It has been roughly three years since the open-source release of Stable Diffusion ignited a Generative AI (GenAI) boom ( Bengesi et al., 2023 ) . The proliferation of these technologies has since reshaped design practice and research. From early ideation to final implementation, these developments have significantly altered how design work is conceived, conducted, and evaluated ( Hou et al., 2024 ) . This essay examines the critical juncture at which the design research community finds itself, seeking to understand and shape these developments while grappling with their implications for creative practice, design education, and professional identities. Popular discourse around GenAI often centers on simplified unequivocal narratives: AI as a threat to humanity, as a solution to global challenges, as a force of disruption, or as a replacement for humans ( Gilardi et al., 2024 ) . While these narratives have sparked debate and interest, they can function as “semantic stopsigns”—conceptual framings that oversimplify complex issues, providing an illusion of resolution that hinders deeper inquiry ( LessWrong Community, n.d. ; Lifton, 1961 ) . For instance, claims like “AI is unreliable” can lead to outright dismissal of its potential, even in cases where it could support exploratory or creative workflows with proper oversight. Similarly, concerns such as “all GenAI infringes intellectual property” can lead to a dismissal that prevents stakeholders from exploring nuanced strategies for ethical and responsible implementation. Existing literature has provided valuable insights into GenAI’s technical capabilities and ethical concerns, laying a crucial foundation for understanding its potential. However, much of this work remains focused on theoretical questions or specific technical challenges, leaving practice-oriented implications—such as its influence on design education, workflows, and organizational strategies—less explored. For example, reductive assumptions about AI can lead to curricula that either prioritizes technical skills over critical thinking or avoid AI entirely due to excessive fears ( Walter, 2024 ; Jaramillo and Chiappe, 2024 ) . Similarly, organizations often adopt AI tools hastily without evaluation ( MIT Sloan Management Review and Boston Consulting Group, 2023 ) or dismiss them outright ( Forbes Technology Council, 2024 ) , missing opportunities for meaningful innovation. Addressing these barriers requires moving beyond semantic stopsigns to develop nuanced, practice-oriented knowledge that bridges theoretical discourse with grounded insights ( Kaila et al., 2024 ) . In our reflection on GenAI in design, we embrace critical optimism as our guiding perspective—an approach to technological engagement first explored by Anna Brynskov (2020) and further developed in social research ( Amaturo and Aragona, 2021 ) . Rather than adopting either uncritical acceptance or wholesale rejection, critical optimism encourages thoughtful engagement with new technologies through direct experience. This mindset, or "posture" as Amaturo and Aragona describe it, proposes that meaningful understanding of technologies like GenAI emerges through hands-on interaction—experimenting, playing, prototyping, and embedding these tools within practice. While critical optimism shapes our overall approach, we structure our analysis through Theory U ( Scharmer, 2009 ) , identifying five prevalent semantic stopsigns in GenAI discourse and demonstrating how to move beyond them through reflection and reframing. This paper examines how simplified narratives, or “semantic stopsigns,” impede meaningful engagement with GenI in design research. Drawing on two expert workshops at ACM Designing Interactive Systems Conference and semi-structured interviews with design practitioners, we identify and analyze five common stopsigns that halt deeper inquiry into GenAI’s role in design. Our analysis contributes to what Höök and Löwgren (2012) describe as intermediate-level knowledge: knowledge forms that are more abstract than specific instances but not as generalized as overarching theories. We deliberately adopt this approach to provide generative insights —knowledge that designers and researchers can adapt and apply within their own contexts to inform debates, guide practice, and advance their understanding of GenAI. By revealing the systemic structures behind these stopsigns and highlighting additional dimensions beyond their simplified framings, we aim to enable more nuanced conversations about GenAI’s implications for design research and practice. 2 Related work To situate our research, we explore the technical foundations of GenAI systems, their integration into design practices, and the ethical and practical challenges accompanying their adoption. While these systems have shown immense potential, current discourse often becomes ensnared in simplified narratives that impede deeper engagement and actionable progress. Despite the proliferation of frameworks, principles, and guidelines ( AlgorithmWatch (2020) catalogued 167 examples in 2020), high-level initiatives frequently fall short in practice. For example, Corrêa et al. (2023) highlight that while such frameworks are ostensibly generalizable, they often rely on unrepresentative samples and face substantial challenges when translated across diverse contexts. In practice, these frameworks tend to produce a “procedural orientation,” where practitioners follow predefined processes rather than cultivating the critical competencies necessary for meaningful engagement with these technologies ( Madaio et al., 2024 ) . 2.1 GenAI in design Over the past decade, GenAI has evolved from early proof-of-concept algorithms to powerful, commercially viable systems that are reshaping design practices ( Akhtar, 2024 ) . Initial breakthroughs with Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) demonstrated the feasibility of producing novel images from latent representations, sparking rapid innovation in creative and design fields ( Hughes et al., 2021 ) . More recently, diffusion models and large language models have further expanded these capabilities to support multimodal tasks, enabling designers to integrate text, image, and even audio data in unprecedented ways ( Zhang et al., 2023 ) . The practical applications of these technologies span a wide range of design processes ( He et al., 2023 ) , from AI-assisted architectural prototyping ( Ko et al., 2023 ) to automated user interface generation ( Wu et al., 2024 ) and algorithmic fashion design ( Choi et al., 2023b ) . Scholars and industry practitioners particularly emphasize GenAI’s capacity for co-creation —where designers and algorithms collaboratively generate novel solutions that neither party would have arrived at independently ( Zhou et al., 2024 ; Ding et al., 2023 ) . The promise of “faster ideation," wherein AI reduces time-intensive tasks like creating mood boards or generating style variations, suggests designers might be freed to focus on higher-level concerns ( Bursztyn et al., 2021 ; Choi et al., 2023a ; Choudhury et al., 2025 ) . However, this transformative narrative faces significant critique and challenges. Some scholars question whether GenAI truly “transforms" design methods or