BoundarEase: Fostering Constructive Community Engagement to Inform More Equitable Student Assignment Policies

Cassandra Overney, Cassandra Moe, Alvin Chang, Nabeel Gillani · 2025

Read BoundarEase: Fostering Constructive Community Engagement to Inform More Equitable Student Assignment Policies by Cassandra Overney, Cassandra Moe, Alvin Chang, Nabeel Gillani (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-08543.txt.

Introduction

Cassandra Overney, Cassandra Moe, and their co-authors describe BoundarEase, a 2025 system built to improve public debate over school attendance boundaries in the United States. Districts draw those boundary lines, and the lines shape who can attend which school. Public processes for changing them are often unclear, hard to follow, and sharply divided.

The team worked with a large district serving nearly 150,000 students. A first study with 16 community members found three frictions: people thought of their own family first, struggled to grasp how changes would hit others, and found impacts hard to understand. The system was designed against those frictions, aiming at debate that weighs the whole community. The paper reports the design and its evaluation with the district.

Catalog record

CREATORCassandra Overney, Cassandra Moe, Alvin Chang, Nabeel Gillani
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE115 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-08543

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

BoundarEase: Fostering Constructive Community Engagement to Inform More Equitable Student Assignment Policies Cassandra Overney, Cassandra Moe, Alvin Chang, Nabeel Gillani Abstract . Public school districts across the United States (US) play a pivotal role in shaping access to quality education through their student assignment policies—most prominently, school attendance boundaries. Community engagement processes for changing such policies, however, are often opaque, cumbersome, and highly polarizing—hampering equitable access to quality schools in ways that can perpetuate disparities in achievement and future life outcomes. In this paper, we describe a collaboration with a large US public school district serving nearly 150,000 students to design and evaluate a new sociotechnical system, “BoundarEase”, for fostering more constructive community engagement around changing school attendance boundaries. Through a formative study with 16 community members, we first identify several frictions in existing community engagement processes during boundary planning, like individualistic over collective thinking; a failure to understand and empathize with different community members when considering policy impacts; and challenges in accessing and understanding the impacts of boundary changes. We then use these frictions to inspire the design and development of BoundarEase, a web platform that allows community members to explore and offer feedback on potential boundaries based on their preferences. A user study with 12 community members reveals that BoundarEase prompts reflection among community members on how policies might impact families beyond their own, and increases transparency around the details of policy proposals. Our paper offers education researchers insights into the challenges and opportunities involved in community engagement for designing student assignment policies; human-computer interaction researchers a case study of how new sociotechnical systems might help mitigate polarization in local policymaking; and school districts a practical tool they might use to facilitate community engagement to foster more equitable student assignment policies. Journal: PACMHCI Volume: 9 2 CSCW040 4 DOI: 10.1145/3710938 CCS: Human-centered computing Visualization application domains CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI) CCS: Human-centered computing Interaction design 1. Introduction Across the US, student assignment policies play a foundational role in enabling, or impeding, access to quality public K-12 education. The policies school districts adopt can impact the opportunities and resources students have access to at their schools ( Monarrez and Chien, 2021 ) ; levels of racial/ethnic and socioeconomic integration ( Monarrez, 2023 ) —which in turn can affect students’ and parents’ access to social capital and other valuable network connections ( Chetty et al., 2022 ; Small, 2009 ) ; levels of school utilization ( Hawkins, 2023 ) ; and several other factors. One policy regime, in particular, continues to influence how the vast majority of students across the US are assigned to schools: school “attendance boundaries”. Attendance boundaries are catchment areas that districts draw to determine which neighborhoods should feed to which schools. Typically, students are assigned to the schools closest to their homes ( Monarrez, 2023 ) . This often means school assignments reflect the underlying geographic inequities in American communities ( Monarrez, 2023 ) . Attendance boundaries are powerful default settings: as of 2016, 71% of students attended their (presumably neighborhood-assigned) schools ( of Education, 2021 ) . This shows that, even in an era of growing school choice ( Houlgrave, 2021 ) , attendance boundaries continue to play a critical role in shaping the quality of education that students are able to access. Thus, changing attendance boundaries (“redistricting”) may serve as a powerful lever for advancing more equitable access to quality education—especially for students of color, students living in poverty, and other historically disadvantaged groups. Indeed, a recent study showed that changes to elementary school boundaries across a set of large US districts could induce moderate reductions in racial/ethnic segregation while also slightly reducing travel times ( Gillani et al., 2023a ) . Furthermore, some estimates suggest that attendance boundary changes are relatively common across the US, with approximately 15% of boundaries, annually, experiencing some type of change 1 1 1 https://www.attomdata.com/data/boundaries-data/school-attendance-zone-boundaries/ . . Still, changing attendance boundaries is highly contentious, particularly when doing so involves efforts to promote more equitable student assignments: such efforts can result in superintendent resignations ( Bridges, 2016 ) , family flight to other school options ( Mervosh, 2021 ) , and intense community strife ( Siegel-Hawley et al., 2017 ; Castro et al., 2022b ; Bridges, 2016 ) . Furthermore, such contention—particularly in the present day—happens against a backdrop of rising political polarization, with communities split on which books their children should be reading in school ( Smith, 2023 ) , how reading should be taught ( Wilkins and McNamara, 2023 ) , and a host of other factors. Given these challenges, how might we practically alter attendance boundaries to sustainably achieve more equitable student assignment policies? Exploring this question first requires defining what we mean by “equity”. The notion of equity, of course, has many definitions. A focus on increasing access to quality “goods” (in this case, schools), particularly among populations who lack such access, reflects elements of Rawlsian equity/justice ( Sen, 1979 ) . This is the notion we seek to advance throughout this study: student assignment policies have long relegated historically disadvantaged groups into segregated learning environments, which often lack the privileges and amenities of schools in more affluent areas. Parent power and preferences tend to reinforce these patterns and further reduce access to quality education among other groups. Addressing these inequities sustainably, however, also requires addressing inequities in access to information: families may have very different understandings of how student assignment policies work, and what their options under such policies might be ( Robertson et al., 2021 ) . We view addressing these informational inequities as an important part of fostering more equitable access to quality schools. Importantly, Rawlsian equity suffers from many limitations—including the fact that it does not account for the unique supports that different sub-populations may require to take full advantage of goods once they are able to access them ( Sen, 1979 ) . While it is incomplete, Rawlsian equity offers a useful lens for framing what a high-level objective of student assignment policy-making might be. However, if we wish to advance more equitable policy-making, it is worth first understanding some of the forces that currently impede it in practice. As described in ( Gillani et al., 2023b ) , one impediment is that the loudest voices during a redistricting process are often the ones that get the most attention ( Siegel-Hawley et al., 2017 ; Bridges et al., 2022 ) , drowning out others that may help moderate an otherwise polarized process. Another is transparency: families can thwart redistricting efforts by challenging their legitimacy, often citing a lack of transparency in the district’s policymaking and community engagement processes. A more deeply entrenched impediment is prioritizing the individual over the collective—a tendency that is often driven by fear. Families may fear a drop in home values if their zoned schools change ( Bridges, 2016 ; Kane et al., 2005 ) ; fear that their children won’t receive a quality education at their new school ( Zhang, 2008 ) ; etc. These fears, while sometimes legitimate, can block progress and lead families to exclusively support policies that benefit themselves, even if small amounts of compromise might produce vastly improved

Read the complete text