Propulsion of flapping foils undergoing in-plane clap-and-fling and deviation motions
Antoine Papillon, Mathieu Olivier · 2025
Read Propulsion of flapping foils undergoing in-plane clap-and-fling and deviation motions by Antoine Papillon, Mathieu Olivier (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-08304.txt.
Introduction
Antoine Papillon and Mathieu Olivier simulate two flapping foils that clap and fling against each other like insect wings, in a 2025 paper. Some insects boost lift by clapping their wings together and peeling them apart. The study models two flat plates mirroring each other, pitching, heaving, and sliding sideways in a fluid at moderate flow speed. A commercial solver handled the moving meshes. The pair's timing offset and closest spacing were varied first.
The best pairing reached an efficiency of about fifty-four percent, beating the best single foil by over thirteen percent. Sideways deviation motion was then tested for its own effect. Paired flapping could inform small flying or swimming robots that borrow the insect trick.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Antoine Papillon, Mathieu Olivier |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 71 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-08304
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Propulsion of flapping foils undergoing in-plane clap-and-fling and deviation motions Antoine Papillon, Mathieu Olivier Abstract This study examines the performance of two flapping flat-plate foils interacting with each other while generating thrust at a Reynolds number of 800 through two-dimensional numerical simulations. These fluid dynamics simulations were conducted with a commercial computational fluid dynamics solver implementing a finite-volume method and an overset mesh capability. The foils performed a combined motion involving pitching, heaving, and deviation. Both foils exhibit similar movements, with one foil mirroring the other. The heaving and pitching motions occur at the same frequency but with a phase shift between them. The effects of varying the phase shift and the minimum spacing between the foils during motion were first explored. The study revealed that a maximum efficiency of 0.542 can be achieved by using two foils, representing an increase of 13.5% relative to the optimal single-foil case. Then, the impacts of the deviation motion were investigated. The deviation motion was introduced with a frequency twice as fast as the other motions, and a phase shift relative to the heaving motion. The other parameters such as the minimum spacing between the foils, the heaving and pitching amplitudes, and the frequency were those of the best configuration without deviation. The numerical simulations demonstrated that deviation can increase efficiency further to a value of 0.560, a relative increase of 3.95%. Journal: Fluid Dynamics Research 1 Introduction The pursuit of leveraging useful aerodynamic forces from fluid flows has captured the interest of researchers throughout the years. Numerous studies have investigated flapping wings to either generate thrust or extract energy from such flows ( Tuncer and Platzer, 1999 ; Anderson et al., 1998 ; Miller and Peskin, 2005 ; Wu et al., 2020 ) . This concept draws inspiration from the efficient aerodynamics observed in various species of insects and small birds that continuously flap their wings at specific frequencies to achieve flight. This approach contrasts with intermittent flapping and gliding, a technique used by most larger birds subject to larger Reynolds numbers. In some cases, an intriguing phenomenon known as clap and fling is used. This mechanism was initially reported by Weis-Fogh (1973) who studied the flight of the diminutive wasp Encarsia formosa . They also demonstrated that this clap-and-fling mechanism has been adopted by some birds and insects for flight. It involves wings coming into proximity during flapping, resulting in enhanced thrust or lift generation through their interaction. Conventional aerodynamic theories have often fallen short in explaining how sufficient lift is generated at low Reynolds numbers, particularly for hovering. Earlier studies identified that unsteady mechanisms play a crucial role in this matter ( Ansari et al., 2006 ; Dickinson et al., 1999 ; Ellington et al., 1996 ) . Among them, the clap-and-fling mechanism, illustrated in Figure 1 , has been widely studied for its efficient circulation generation around flapping wings through mutual interaction. During the clap phase, the wings move toward each other and nearly touch. This is followed by the fling phase, where the wings separate, inducing circulation that rapidly reaches a steady state ( Lighthill, 1973 ) . Unlike traditional steady-state aerodynamics, this mechanism bypasses the need for the Kutta condition to establish circulation. The rapid reach of steady circulation allows the wings to maximize lift during each oscillation cycle, explaining why several species evolved to use this mechanism for flight at lower Reynolds numbers. Building on these biological insights, computational and experimental studies have advanced the understanding of flapping-wing aerodynamics. Platzer et al. (1993) analyzed thrust and lift in oscillating airfoils using a panel code, revealing the impact of unsteady forces. Later work by Tuncer and Platzer (1999) introduced a Navier-Stokes solver to account for flow separation and wake profiles, highlighting the role of attached flows in achieving higher propulsive efficiencies. At higher plunging frequencies, leading-edge vortices were observed to generate more thrust but at the cost of reduced efficiency. These insights have inspired biomimetic designs, such as developing flapping-wing vehicles with features mimicking species at comparable Reynolds numbers ( Jones and Platzer, 2009 ) . Such designs leverage unsteady aerodynamic advantages, including ground effects and wake ingestion, to optimize thrust and efficiency ( Platzer et al., 2008 ) , underscoring the continued relevance of biological flight mechanics to engineering innovation. Figure 1 : Schematic of wing sections during clap (a-c) and fling (d-f). The motion occurs sequentially from (a) to (f) and the generated force is upward. Meanwhile, numerous studies about flapping wings revealed the importance of kinematic parameters on aerodynamic performances. In the case of harmonic wing motions involving clap and fling, the phase shift between the heaving and pitching movements has a significant impact since it controls the kinematics of the foils when they reach proximity. For single harmonically flapping foils, the optimal phase shift depends on the location of the pivot point on the oscillating foil. Anderson et al. (1998) have shown that this optimal phase shift when the pivot point is at one-third of the chord length is 75\degree . They also pointed out that changing the pivot point location has similar effects to modifying the phase shift in the case of small amplitude motions. This is also supported by Isogai et al. (1999) , who found that the optimal efficiency occurs at a phase shift of 90\degree when the pivot point is located at the middle of the chord length. The impact of the interactions between two foils undergoing clap-and-fling motion has been examined by some authors with two-dimensional numerical simulations ( Mao and Xin, 2003 ; Miller and Peskin, 2005 ; Zhu and Lei, 2018 ) . In the work by Mao and Xin (2003) , a hovering configuration with a Reynolds number of 17 and a motion described by piecewise-continuous functions is used. This configuration corresponds to the kinematics and physical scales of a wasp ( Encarsia Formosa ). They reported that reducing the minimum spacing between the foils increases the lift coefficient. Yet, the moment coefficient, which is directly related to the necessary power that needs to be injected to accomplish the motion, increases significantly as the foils are closer initially. Mao and Xin (2003) discussed that when the initial spacing varies between the smallest values considered (10 to 20 percent of the chord length), the lift coefficient barely diminishes while the moment coefficient becomes much smaller. Hence, a compromise has to be made when setting the initial spacing to maximize the lift while minimizing the power required to execute the motion. They have also reported strong lift peaks during the clap phase, which correspond to the moment when the trailing edges of the foils are close to each other. They concluded that the clap-and-fling interaction can increase the lift coefficient by a factor of up to 1.6 when compared to single foils. This confirms, to some extent, that this mechanism can significantly improve lift. Subsequently, Miller and Peskin (2005) determined that a lower Reynolds number could increase the lift of heaving and pitching foils. The spacing between the two foils at the end of the fling movement was specified as 1/6 of the chord length, which allows proximity effects to occur. Their simulations were carried out for