Liquidity Competition Between Brokers and an Informed Trader Note:
Ryan Donnelly, Zi Li · 2025
Read Liquidity Competition Between Brokers and an Informed Trader Note: by Ryan Donnelly, Zi Li (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-08287.txt.
Introduction
Ryan Donnelly and Zi Li model competition between brokers trading with an informed trader, in a two thousand twenty-five paper. Brokers supply liquidity to the informed trader. They learn from that flow of orders as they do so. They can speculate on what they learn, while they manage inventory risk in the wider market at the same time.
The play is framed as a sequential Stackelberg-type game. The team solves in closed form for the strategy the informed trader uses with each broker. A set of equations then sorts the brokers' equilibrium strategies, and it is solved on a computer. Brokers mix internalization and externalization. In plain terms, they weigh their own book against the lit market. A second game, a competitive one, sets the liquidity prices put forth under precommitment. One case worked out on a computer shows the equilibrium that comes out is not Pareto efficient.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ryan Donnelly, Zi Li |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-08287
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Liquidity Competition Between Brokers and an Informed Trader Note: Ryan Donnelly, Zi Li Abstract We study a multi-agent setting in which brokers transact with an informed trader. Through a sequential Stackelberg-type game, brokers manage trading costs and adverse selection with an informed trader. In particular, supplying liquidity to the informed traders allows the brokers to speculate based on the flow information. They simultaneously attempt to minimize inventory risk and trading costs with the lit market based on the informed order flow, also known as the internalization-externalization strategy. We solve in closed form for the trading strategy that the informed trader uses with each broker and propose a system of equations which classify the equilibrium strategies of the brokers. By solving these equations numerically we may study the resulting strategies in equilibrium. Finally, we formulate a competitive game between brokers in order to determine the liquidity prices subject to precommitment supplied to the informed trader and provide a numerical example in which the resulting equilibrium is not Pareto efficient. Journal: TBA 1 Introduction In financial markets, it is common that different parties have different information, a phenomenon referred to as information asymmetry. When dealing with order flow from informed traders, counterparties are generally adversely selected against and provide liquidity at a loss. There is extensive literature on informed and uninformed trading. Early models that deal with information asymmetry include Glosten and Milgrom (1985) and Kyle (1985) . In Kyle (1985) , the informed trader has superior information about the payoff of the asset, while noise traders trade randomly. Both the informed and uninformed traders interact with a dealer who specifies execution prices contingent on total order flow. The problem is analyzed by solving for an equilibrium between the dealer’s price strategy and the informed trader’s order flow strategy. Recently, Herdegen et al. (2023) studies a one-shot Nash competition between an arbitrary number of identical dealers that compete for the order flow of a client. When quoting their price schedules, the dealers do not know the client’s type but only the distribution of clients. Cartea and Sánchez-Betancourt (2025) characterizes a perfect information Stackelberg equilibrium between a broker and her clients — an informed trader and an uniformed trader in an over-the-counter market. Different from Herdegen et al. (2023) , the broker can distinguish the type of traders and therefore quote bespoke prices as well as extract superior information from the informed trading flow. In addition to the game setting, some work studies brokers’ optimization of trading performance despite the presence of an exogenous informed flow. Barzykin et al. (2024) considers a central trading desk which aggregates the inflow of clients’ orders with unobserved toxicity, and formulates this optimal unwinding problem as a partially observable stochastic control problem. The academic work on detection and prediction of toxic flows also receives a significant amount of attention, see Cartea et al. (2023) and Easley et al. (2011) . In addition to utilizing information to make profitable trades, agents are concerned with minimizing trading costs and managing inventory risks. This type of optimal execution problem has also been heavily studied. Bertsimas and Lo (1998) and Almgren and Chriss (2001) provide a groundwork for this type of problems in discrete time by modeling the permanent and temporary price impact caused by an agent’s trades. Analogous models and results in continuous time are provided in Guéant et al. (2012) and Forsyth et al. (2012) . Optimal execution models can also be adapted to scenarios that include trading based on access to information, for example statistical arbitrage. One of the early studies in this line of research is Cartea et al. (2014) , which develops a market-making model with a mean-reverting alpha component in the underlying asset price. Other market signals based on book volume imbalance have also been used, e.g. Cartea et al. (2018) ; Donnelly and Lorig (2020) . The actions of an individual agent in a financial market will impact the behaviour of other agents. It is essential to formulate and study models in which multiple agents act simultaneously. There are numerous works in optimal execution which model the interaction between multiple agents, including Schied and Zhang (2019) , Huang et al. (2019) , and Donnelly and Lorig (2020) . Our model is a generalization of the single broker and the single informed trader model considered in Cartea and Sánchez-Betancourt (2025) . While Bergault and Sánchez-Betancourt (2025) is an extension of Cartea and Sánchez-Betancourt (2025) where a large group of informed traders and one broker are considered in a mean-field setting, here we consider a setting in which a finite number of brokers trade strategically with a single informed trader. This paper studies the optimal strategies of a group of brokers who act as liquidity providers to other agents. These brokers have as clients an informed trader and an uninformed trader, both of whom trade with all of the brokers simultaneously on bespoke quotes streamed by each broker. The informed trader has privileged information about the trend component of the asset price, while the uninformed trader has no informational advantage and their trades are exogenous and non-directional. In our model, the brokers can extract this privileged information from the informed order flow. Therefore, they can speculate based on the signal in the lit market while externalizing flow from both the informed and uninformed traders. The brokers and the informed trader maximize their expected wealth, while minimizing inventory holdings. When the finite time horizon is reached, each agent that has unsold units of the asset recovers a salvage cost for their remaining inventory. Once the optimal actions of each agent are determined, we demonstrate how the brokers select the liquidity price they offer to the informed trader through an equilibrium mechanism. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2 introduces the model and optimization problems solved by the broker and the informed trader. We first study the informed trader’s problem, and derive his optimal strategy in closed-form. With the informed trader’s optimal strategy at hand, we then turn to the brokers’ problem. In Section 3 we conduct a numerical simulation of the strategies of all agents. In Section 4 we demonstrate how brokers will select their liquidity prices in equilibrium in order to maximize their own value, and investigate how risk-aversion parameters affect the selection of these liquidity prices in equilibrium. Section 5 concludes. 2 Model Consider a market with N brokers, an informed trader, and an uninformed trader. 1 1 1 The model treats each the informed and uninformed trader as an individual agent, but they could represent an aggregate of all informed and uninformed trading activity. In this market only the N brokers can provide liquidity by streaming quotes to the informed and uninformed traders. The informed and uninformed traders submit trades to all brokers simultaneously. The brokers know the identity of clients, and so they can supply different quotes to informed and uninformed traders. Additionally, the brokers are able to submit trades to a lit market. Let T>0 be a finite-time horizon and \mathcal{T}=[0,T] . We work in a probability space \left(\Omega,\mathcal{F},\mathbb{F}=\left(\mathcal{F}_{t}\right)_{t\in\mathcal{T}},\mathbb{P}\right) satisfying the usual conditions and supporting N+2 Brownian motions W^{S} , W^{\alpha} , and W^{U,j} for j=1,\dots,N . The