A primer on optimal transport for causal inference with observational data

Florian Gunsilius · 2025

Read A primer on optimal transport for causal inference with observational data by Florian Gunsilius (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-07811.txt.

Introduction

Florian Gunsilius gives a primer on optimal transport for causal work in a 2025 review. Optimal transport is a frame for comparing chance spreads by their base states. Causal work also turns on states that could have been, so the two fields fit well.

Yet clear work at their crossing is only now taking shape. Many classic causal models, Gunsilius shows, used transport ideas for years without naming them. The review ties the terms and symbols of math, statistics, and economics into one tongue. It also points to new problems both fields can take up. Readers new to either field get a shared starting map.

Catalog record

CREATORFlorian Gunsilius
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE124 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-07811

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A primer on optimal transport for causal inference with observational data Florian Gunsilius Abstract The theory of optimal transportation has developed into a powerful and elegant framework for comparing probability distributions, with wide-ranging applications in all areas of science. The fundamental idea of analyzing probabilities by comparing their underlying state space naturally aligns with the core idea of causal inference, where understanding and quantifying counterfactual states is paramount. Despite this intuitive connection, explicit research at the intersection of optimal transport and causal inference is only beginning to develop. Yet, many foundational models in causal inference have implicitly relied on optimal transport principles for decades, without recognizing the underlying connection. Therefore, the goal of this review is to offer an introduction to the surprisingly deep existing connections between optimal transport and the identification of causal effects with observational data—where optimal transport is not just a set of potential tools, but actually builds the foundation of model assumptions. As a result, this review is intended to unify the language and notation between different areas of statistics, mathematics, and econometrics, by pointing out these existing connections, and to explore novel problems and directions for future work in both areas derived from this realization. keywords causal inference , difference-in-differences , identification , instrumental variables , monotone rearrangement , observational data , optimal transport , synthetic controls , treatment heterogeneity 1 Introduction At the heart of many scientific and practical problems lies the challenge of understanding causal relationships of interventions and modifications: will I feel better if I take this medication? What are the health effects on the population of opening up a factory near this neighborhood? These questions all revolve around a fundamental principle: identifying and analyzing the effect an intervention—taking the medication, building the factory in this neighborhood—has on the system under consideration, that is, my body or the neighborhood. Such questions are difficult to answer with data since they require the knowledge of two mutually exclusive states of the world, the counterfactual states . Either the factory is built at this location or it is not, but it is impossible to ever observe both states at the same time. This is the “fundamental problem of causal inference” [ holland1986statistics ] . This problem is amplified in settings where the statistician does not have the agency to devise the intervention directly—as is the case in randomized controlled trials for instance—but only has access to observational data. In such cases the treatment variable is endogenous to the system, meaning that it is not independent of the unobservables that affect the outcome of interest. A classic example is self-selection into treatment [ angrist2009mostly , imbens2015causal ] , where treatment is not randomized, but unobservable criteria affect both the uptake of the treatment as well as the outcome. For instance, motivation to find a new job after losing it recently will make individuals more likely to sign up for potential job training programs (the treatment) but also makes them more likely to send more applications and land a new job (the outcome), something documented by the classic Ashenfelter Dip [ heckman1999pre ] . Therefore, simply comparing the outcome in both groups—the people in the job training program versus the rest of the population—does not provide the causal effect of attending the job training program. One essentially compares two different groups based on characteristics and would falsely attribute the difference exclusively to the treatment effect of attending the job training program. Such problems have been at the center of interest in classical econometrics since the 1920’s [ haavelmo1943statistical , tinbergen1930determination , wright1928tariff ] , starting with the analysis of supply and demand models. Fundamentally, in such settings, identification, estimation, and inference of the effect of the intervention on the outcome of interest requires additional assumptions tailored to the specific case. Over the decades, statisticians and econometricians have developed a plethora of such methods, including instrumental variable estimation, matching, difference-in-differences, and synthetic controls. Traditionally, the focus in this literature has been on identifying average effects, essentially estimating an expected effect of the intervention on the outcome of interest in the system. While this is often an important measure, modern research in this area has emphasized the importance of accounting for treatment heterogeneity [ heckman1997making ] . A classical and influential example is the literature on the effect of minimum wage increases on employment [ card1994minimum , neumark2000minimum ] . To analyze the effect a minimum wage increase had on the employment growth rate at fast food chains in the state of New Jersey in 1992 , David Card and Alan Krueger [ card1994minimum ] used a difference-in-differences approach focusing on average effects; they compared the average change in the employment rate at the surveyed New Jersey fast-food restaurants to the average change of employment at fast-food restaurants in the neighboring Pennsylvania, where the minimum wage remained constant. Somewhat counterintuitively, they found that an increase in the minimum wage increased employment. In stark contrast, David Neumark and William Wascher [ neumark2000minimum ] , using a different dataset and different methodology, found a negative average effect. While the debate of the effects of the minimum wage on employment is still ongoing, an interesting contribution [ ropponen2011reconciling ] attempts to reconcile these two opposite results by considering the entire distribution of the size of fast-food restaurants in each state—using the changes-in-changes estimator [ athey2006identification ] , which is an extension of the difference-in-differences idea to account for individual heterogeneity, implicitly built using optimal transportation as shown below. The author finds that the positive effect seems to persist for smaller fast-food restaurants while a negative effect can be found for larger fast-food restaurants. This is a striking example of how accounting for heterogeneity in the causal framework can uncover important insights into the problem that an average effect cannot. The goal of this review is to show how optimal transportation can be used to resolve such and similar problems by allowing to capture heterogeneity within the respective setting [ heckman2001micro , imbens2007nonadditive ] . Importantly, optimal transport allows one to do this in two ways, the second being arguably more novel: the first way fundamentally focuses on identifying causal effects for different individuals in the outcome distribution. In contrast to classical approaches that focus on average causal effects, this framework explicitly focuses on the heterogeneity of effects, away from the average, often by considering the quantiles in the potential outcome distributions. The second way is based on a “systems view”. Here, the goal is not to identify the different individual effects within the system, but to analyze the different counterfactual states of the system as a whole . It is important to clarify what is meant by “heterogeneity” in this review, as the term is used differently across literatures. In much of the causal inference literature, treatment effect heterogeneity refers to variation in average treatment effects across subgroups defined by observed covariates, the so-called conditional average treatment effects (CATE). The notion of heterogeneity in this review is different, however. Here, heterogeneity refers to the variation in the causal mechanism induced by the unobservable U : different individuals, indexed by different realizations of U , experience different causal effects of the treatment X

Read the complete text