Artificial Utopia: Simulation and Intelligent Agents for a Democratised Future

Yannick Oswald · 2025

Read Artificial Utopia: Simulation and Intelligent Agents for a Democratised Future by Yannick Oswald (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-07364.txt.

Introduction

Yannick Oswald proposed in 2025 a research agenda that uses simulation and AI to test democratic, bottom-up futures before trying them in real life. Top-down political and economic systems struggle with climate change, inequality, and conflict, he argues. Bottom-up options are debated, but how their institutions shape behavior is little understood.

Simulated utopias offer a safe test ground with less risk of harm. Methods range from agent models and reinforcement learning to large language models. Two cases anchor the discussion: the citizen assembly and the democratic firm. The agenda aims to learn which rules help collective choices work, without betting real communities on untested designs.

Catalog record

CREATORYannick Oswald
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-07364

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Artificial Utopia: Simulation and Intelligent Agents for a Democratised Future Yannick Oswald Abstract Prevailing top-down systems in politics and economics struggle to keep pace with the pressing challenges of the 21 st century, such as climate change, social inequality and conflict. Bottom-up democratisation and participatory approaches in politics and economics are increasingly seen as promising alternatives to confront and overcome these issues, often with ’utopian’ overtones, as proponents believe they may dramatically reshape political, social and ecological futures for the better and in contrast to contemporary authoritarian tendencies across various countries. Institutional specifics and the associated collective human behavior or culture remains little understood and debated, however. In this article, I propose a novel research agenda focusing on ’utopian’ democratisation efforts with formal and computational methods as well as with artificial intelligence – I call this agenda ’Artificial Utopia’. Artificial Utopias provide safe testing grounds for new political ideas and economic policies ’in-silico’ with reduced risk of negative consequences as compared to testing ideas in real-world contexts. An increasing number of advanced simulation and intelligence methods, that aim at representing human cognition and collective decision-making in more realistic ways, could benefit this process. This includes agent-based modelling, reinforcement learning, large language models and more. I clarify what some of these simulation approaches can contribute to the study of Artificial Utopias with the help of two institutional examples; the citizen assembly and the democratic firm. 1 Introduction The evolution of human societies has been profoundly shaped by our capacity for collective decision-making and the development of complex cultural, political and economic systems ( Brinkmann et al. 2023 ; Carballo et al. 2014 ) and it will continue to shape our future. Historically, at least since the emergence of Western empires, top-down governance structures have dominated ( McNeill 1963 ) , but they evidently struggle to address multifaceted collective coordination challenges such as climate change, social inequality, and geopolitical conflicts. In response, there is a growing interest in bottom-up democratization and participatory approaches, which advocate for decentralized decision-making processes encompassing both political institutions as well as economic decision-making. Despite the theoretical appeal of participatory systems, our understanding of the specific institutional frameworks and collective behaviors that facilitate or hinder their success remains limited. To address this gap, in this work, I propose a novel research agenda termed Artificial Utopia, which involves computer simulations of alternative economic and democratic political systems, exploring the nature of bottom-up collective decision-making in novel and innovative contexts. Additionally, I outline concrete proposals for building bridges between related social sciences and computational approaches. I argue that alternative and improved democratic systems, systems that go beyond electoral representative democracy, are important objects of scientific inquiry in the context of this agenda. I pay particular attention to not only collective decision-making but also to ensuing challenges, and I discuss how modern simulation and artificial intelligence (AI) methods aid our understanding of those challenges and probe them for a wide range of traits and dynamics. Lastly, I speculate on the future of Artificial Utopia research, related methodological questions and ethical considerations. I begin by motivating the research field of Artificial Utopia in more detail. The 21 st century presents humankind with unprecedented challenges. Almost every aspect of human life has greatly accelerated. Population and resource consumption have grown exponentially over the past 200 years ( Steffen et al. 2015 ; Rockström et al. 2024 ) . Several indicators improved globally, like average life expectancy ( Dattani et al. 2023 ) , but immense ecological pressures, such as climate change have emerged, too. Various studies demonstrate that current human civilization is not sustainable and destroys the ecological foundations of life including biodiversity, atmospheric and oceanic health ( Richardson et al. 2023 ; Gupta et al. 2024 ) . At the same time, inequalities are wide-ranging, both in terms of economic wealth and responsibility for environmental impact ( Oswald et al. 2020 ; Chancel 2022 ) . No country currently achieves decent social and health outcomes while using resources sustainably ( O’Neill et al. 2018 ) . This tension between sustainability and human well-being has led to growing scrutiny of the existing economic and political systems that civil society depends on to meet human needs. Beyond social and ecological realms, geopolitical crises and wars are escalating and it is not clear whether the international community will ever cooperate to a degree sufficient to resolving ecological breakdown ( Scheffran 2023 ) . On the contrary, several previously democratic nations worldwide are turning to authoritarian forms of government, and political parties with fascist ideological elements on their agenda are on the rise ( Waldner & Lust 2018 ) . In response to these intertwined crises - ecological, social, and political - many scholars and practitioners are increasingly turning to bottom-up utopian democratisation efforts as a means to reimagine governance, redistribute power, and create participatory systems that can navigate the challenges of the 21 st century ( Durand et al. 2024 ; Steinberger et al. 2024 ) . Although it can be challenging to define utopia, it is generally seen as a society in which everything works better as compared to the above described status quo, and does so through a reinvention of how society functions at the governmental and economic level ( Giroux 2003 ) . Some scholars have explicitly argued that applying utopian thinking to the social and ecological crises of the 21 st century is valuable and can help shape our vision for humanity’s future ( Żuk 2020 ) . Of course, utopian re-imagination of society is not new or unique to the 21 st century. Conceptualizations of ’utopia’ span a broad historical spectrum, from antiquity and Plato’s early philosophical visions in ’The Republic’ ( Grube 2004 ) to early twentieth-century thinkers like Bertrand Russell and his ’Proposed Roads to Freedom’ ( Russell 1918 ) . Today, alternative political and economic systems are once again at the forefront of discussions and often espouse an explicitly utopian character ( Schmelzer et al. 2022 ; Bastani 2019 ; Bregman 2017 ) . At the same time, many questions around decision-making in these systems remain and there is no coherent framework for assessing them and little clarity on what tools to use to do so. Can radical and sweeping changes to society really work? Which proposals are feasible? Are there fundamental limits to ’utopian’ ideas that arise from decision-making challenges? How can we ensure novel forms of social and economic organisation are reliably democratic and participatory? And how can we study these questions systematically, what scientific and computational tools are suited for what aspect? For the purpose of tractability and having a meaningful analytical lens, I focus on two specific kinds of widely proposed, and partially implemented, democratic decision-making systems that are often associated with utopian futures: (i) in politics; the citizen assembly and (ii) in economics; the democratic firm. Both are intuitive entry points to utopia since they constitute quite radical alternatives compared to existing ’mainstream’ democratic institutions, but also are practiced by several communities and collectives. The departure from established institutions is in explicitly participatory and deliberative processes that go beyond the interplay of competitive political parties and the voter. People are meant to

Read the complete text