Finite-size corrections from the subleading magnetic scaling field for the Ising and Potts models in two dimensions

Yihao Xu, Jesús Salas, Youjin Deng · 2025

Read Finite-size corrections from the subleading magnetic scaling field for the Ising and Potts models in two dimensions by Yihao Xu, Jesús Salas, Youjin Deng (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-07117.txt.

Introduction

Yihao Xu and co-authors hunt for a long-hidden correction in how phase-change models behave at finite size, in a 2025 paper. Near a critical point, measured quantities drift with system size, and analysts correct for that drift. Theory long predicted one correction source: a weaker, secondary magnetic field. Its signal, though, stayed buried under other corrections in past studies.

The team simulated a loop model on a honeycomb lattice, a cousin of the Potts model with quieter background corrections. There the predicted correction finally stood out clearly. Oddly, its sign flipped between small and large clusters, so in one key measure the two effects partly cancel. Future scaling analyses, they argue, must include this field.

Catalog record

CREATORYihao Xu, Jesús Salas, Youjin Deng
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE66 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-07117

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Finite-size corrections from the subleading magnetic scaling field for the Ising and Potts models in two dimensions Yihao Xu, Jesús Salas, Youjin Deng Abstract In finite-size scaling analyses of critical phenomena, proper consideration of correction terms, which can come from different sources, plays an important role. For the Fortuin-Kasteleyn representation of the Q Q -state Potts model in two dimensions, although the subleading magnetic scaling field, with exactly known exponent, is theoretically expected to give rise in finite-size-scaling analyses, numerical observation remains elusive probably due to the mixing of various corrections. We simulate the O( n n ) loop model on the hexagonal lattice, which is in the same universality class as the Q = n 2 Q=n^{2} Potts model but has suppressed corrections from other sources, and provides strong numerical evidence for the attribution of the subleading magnetic field in finite-size corrections. Interestingly, it is also observed that the corrections in small- and large-cluster-size regions have opposite magnitudes, and, for the special n = 2 n=2 case, they compensate with each other in observables like the second moment of the cluster-size distribution. Our finding reveals that the effect of the subleading magnetic field should be taken into account in finite-size-scaling analyses, which was unfortunately ignored in many previous studies. I Introduction Monte Carlo (MC) methods [ 1 , 2 ] constitute a very important research tool to investigate the dynamic and static properties of many systems in science, and in particular, in statistical mechanics. In the latter field, the typical setup is a finite system of dimension d and linear size L that undergoes a phase transition at a certain critical temperature. In most cases, MC simulation can only handle finite system, even though phase transitions only occur in the thermodynamic limit N=L^{d}\to\infty . So, in addition to the statistical error inherent to any MC simulation, finite systems are frequently a source of systematic errors (an exception are MC simulations of self-avoiding random walks or other polymer models.; see e.g., [ 3 ] .) Therefore, in every MC study, one has to extrapolate the results obtained in finite lattices to the infinite-volume limit L\to\infty . Finite-size-scaling (FSS) theory [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] explains how thermodynamic quantities (like the magnetic susceptibility) behave close to a phase transition when we take the thermodynamic limit L\to\infty . Let us consider for simplicity a finite physical system of dimension d , linear size L , and periodic boundary conditions. This system undergoes a continuous phase transition that is characterized (for simplicity) by a single relevant thermal field t (that measures the “distance” to the critical point), and an irrelevant field u , in the framework of renormalization group (RG) theory. The singular part of the free energy density scales like [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] f_{\text{s}}(g_{t},g_{u},L)\;=\;b^{-d}\,f_{\text{s}}\left(g_{t}\,b^{y_{t}},g_{u}\,b^{y_{u}},L^{-1}\,b\right)\,. (1) Here, b is any positive number, g_{t} and g_{u} are the nonlinear scaling fields associated to t and u , respectively, and y_{t}=1/\nu>0 and y_{u}<0 are the corresponding RG eigenvalues, where \nu is referred as the correlation-length exponent. Note that the inverse linear size L^{-1} behaves like a relevant operator with exponent y_{L}=1 . The nonlinear scaling fields g_{t} and g_{u} are analytic functions of t , u , and L^{-1} . In particular, g_{t}=a_{1}(u,L^{-1})\,t+a_{2}(u,L^{-1})\,t^{2}+\cdots , and g_{u}=b_{0}(u,L^{-1})+b_{1}(u,L^{-1})\,t+b_{2}(u,L^{-1})\,t^{2}+\cdots . Guo and Jasnow [ 10 , 11 ] have argued, using the field-theoretic RG, that g_{t} and g_{u} do not depend on L^{-1} . If this is the case, then the functions a_{i} and b_{i} would depend solely on u . The full free energy density is equal to f(t,u,L)\;=\;f_{\text{s}}(g_{t},g_{u},L)+f_{\text{r}}(t,u)\,, (2) where the regular part f_{\text{r}} is an analytic function of t and u , even at the critical point t=0 [ 12 , page 101] . If we take the infinite-volume limit L^{-1}=0 , and we choose b such that b^{y_{t}}\,|g_{t}|=1 , we obtain f_{\text{s}}(g_{t},g_{u})\;=\;|g_{t}|^{d\nu}\,f_{\text{s}}\left(\mathrm{sign}(g_{t}),g_{u}\,|g_{t}|^{-y_{u}\nu},0\right)\,. (3) Notice that the behavior at t=0^{\pm} might be different. We now require b\,L^{-1}=1 , so that ( 1 ) becomes f_{\text{s}}(g_{t},g_{u},L)\;=\;L^{-d}\,f_{\text{s}}\left(g_{t}L^{1/\nu},g_{u}L^{y_{u}},1\right)\,. (4) At criticality ( t=0 ), Eqs. ( 2 ) and ( 4 ) reduce to f(0,u,L)\;=\;f_{\text{r}}(0,u)+L^{-d}\,f_{\text{s}}\left(0,g_{u}L^{y_{u}},1\right)\,. (5) The leading behavior of f_{\text{s}} is L^{-d} , and we obtain FSS corrections of order L^{y_{u}},L^{2y_{u}},\ldots when we expand f_{\text{s}}\left(0,g_{u}L^{y_{u}},1\right) as a power series in u . We can obtain similar expressions for the internal energy and the specific heat if we differentiate Eqs. ( 2 ) and ( 4 ) with respect to t once or twice, and then take the t\to 0 limit. In these cases, we have also FSS corrections of order L^{-1},L^{-2},\ldots due to the functions a_{i}(u,L^{-1}) . The same arguments can be followed to derive the equation for the correlation length (actually, for a definition of the correlation length that makes sense in a finite system, e.g., the second-moment correlation length) \xi(t,u,L)\;=\;L\,\mathcal{F}_{\xi}\left(g_{t}L^{y_{t}},g_{u}L^{y_{u}}\right)\,. (6) Given a thermodynamic quantity A(t) that diverges at the critical point (in the infinite-volume limit) like A(t)\;\propto\;|t|^{-\rho}\,, (7) we can generalize Eq. ( 6 ) as follows A(t,u,L)\;=\;L^{\rho/\nu}\,\mathcal{F}_{A}\left(g_{t}L^{y_{t}},g_{u}L^{y_{u}}\right)+A_{\text{r}}(t,u)\,, (8) where we have added a regular background term A_{\text{r}} playing a similar role as the term f_{\text{r}} in the free energy density [cf. Eq. ( 5 )]. Barring the effect of the irrelevant field g_{u} in Eqs. ( 6 ) and ( 8 ), we see that the divergence of the bulk correlation length at criticality is smoothed out; i.e., \xi(0,L)\sim O(L) , and the behavior of A(t,L) becomes analytic in the scaled variable g_{t}L^{1/\nu} , even at the critical point t=0 . FSS effects can be observed in a scaling window of width O(L^{-1/\nu}) . Outside this window, |t|\gg L^{-1/\nu} , A(t,L) behaves basically like A(t) . In this context, Li et al. [ 13 ] studied the crossover FSS theory, which shows that, as the critical point is approached at a slower rate with |t|\sim L^{-\lambda} and \lambda<1/\nu , the FSS becomes dependent on the parameter \lambda . This description can be generalized to include more relevant and irrelevant fields. In some models, we can also find marginal operators characterized by zero eigenvalues y_{u}=0 . These fields give rise to multiplicative [ 14 , 15 ] and additive [ 16 ] logarithmic corrections not taken into account in the previous equations. Logarithmic corrections can also appear when there is a “resonance” between the RG eigenvalues [ 17 ] , like e.g., the two-dimensional (2D) Ising model. In this paper, we will not consider logarithmic corrections of any type. FSS techniques allow to compute reliable estimates of physical quantities that describe the infinite-volume limit (like the location of the critical point, and its critical exponents and universal amplitudes) solely from finite-size data. In order to achieve this goal, one needs a good ansatz based on Eq. ( 8 ). At criticality, we have that [cf. ( 7 )] \displaystyle A(0,u,L) \displaystyle= \displaystyle L^{\rho/\nu}\,\mathcal{F}_{A}\left(0,g_{u}L^{y_{u}}\right)+A_{\text{r}}(0) (9) \displaystyle\propto \displaystyle L^{\rho/\nu}\,\left(1+aL^{y_{u}}+bL^{-\rho/\nu}+\cdots\right)\,.\qquad It is very important to have a fairly good knowledge of the RG exponents (i.e., y_{t} , y_{u} , etc) for the model at hand. This is provided in many 2D models by conformal field theory (CFT) [ 18 ] . It is also worth noticing that FSS corrections do depend on the observable A : distinct observables may have different

Read the complete text