Noise-Robust Estimation of Quantum Observables in Noisy Hardware

Amin Hosseinkhani, Fedor Šimkovic, Alessio Calzona, Tianhan Liu, Adrian Auer, Inés de Vega · 2025

Read Noise-Robust Estimation of Quantum Observables in Noisy Hardware by Amin Hosseinkhani, Fedor Šimkovic, Alessio Calzona, Tianhan Liu, Adrian Auer, Inés de Vega (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-06695.txt.

Introduction

Hosseinkhani and co-authors present a 2025 method for reading results from noisy quantum hardware with less bias. Today's quantum machines are prone to noise, which skews the values users need. Their method, called NRE, cleans up the readings after the run, with no need to know the noise type.

Readings from a target circuit are paired with a twin circuit built to cancel noise. A spread measure then shows how much bias is left, and the last step pushes the value to the zero-spread limit. Tests on a twenty-qubit chip with deep circuits cut bias far below past methods.

Catalog record

CREATORAmin Hosseinkhani, Fedor Šimkovic, Alessio Calzona, Tianhan Liu, Adrian Auer, Inés de Vega
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-06695

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Noise-Robust Estimation of Quantum Observables in Noisy Hardware Amin Hosseinkhani, Fedor Šimkovic, Alessio Calzona, Tianhan Liu, Adrian Auer, Inés de Vega Abstract Error mitigation is essential for counteracting noise in quantum computations until fault-tolerant quantum technologies become viable. Here, we introduce Noise-Robust Estimation (NRE), a noise-agnostic framework that systematically reduces estimation bias through a two-step post-processing approach. At its core, NRE exploits a bias-dispersion correlation uncovered in this work, wherein a measurable metric—normalized dispersion—quantifies and helps suppress unknown residual bias in expectation value estimations. To reveal this correlation, we leverage bootstrapping on the existing measurement counts. We experimentally validate NRE on an IQM superconducting quantum processor, executing quantum circuits with up to 20 qubits and 240 entangling CZ gates. Our results demonstrate that NRE consistently achieves near bias-free estimations across different implementation settings while maintaining a manageable sampling overhead. These findings establish NRE as a reliable and broadly applicable error mitigation method for quantum computation with noisy hardware. I Introduction The utility of quantum computing hinges not only on increasing qubit counts but also on efficiently mitigating the inherent noise that disrupts computations. While fault tolerance remains a long-term goal, quantum error mitigation (QEM) is essential for obtaining reliable results from today’s Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices and improving the performance of partially error-corrected quantum processors in the future. Indeed, even as quantum error correction (QEC) advances, quantum error mitigation will remain relevant to suppress residual errors and extend the effective fidelity of quantum computations, in regimes where full fault tolerance is impractical. Various error mitigation techniques have been proposed, particularly in estimating expectation values Endo et al. 2021 ; Cai et al. 2023 . However, they introduce a sampling overhead that scales exponentially with circuit size and per-qubit operation error rate Takagi et al. 2023 ; Tsubouchi et al. 2023 ; Quek et al. 2024 ; Filippov et al. 2024 , making scalable error mitigation a key challenge. Broadly, quantum error mitigation methods can be classified as noise-aware or noise-agnostic. Noise-aware techniques, such as probabilistic error cancellation (PEC) Temme et al. 2017 ; Endo et al. 2018 ; Song et al. 2019 ; van den Berg et al. 2023 , leverage precise noise models to reconstruct noiseless results. While PEC can theoretically eliminate the impact of noise, it critically depends on accurate noise characterization. Fundamental limitations of Pauli noise learnability Chen et al. 2023 ; Calzona et al. 2024 , parameter drifts and error model violations can thus introduce a finite bias in PEC results Govia et al. 2024 ; Calzona et al. 2024 . Fig. 1 : (a) Workflow of NRE, with each step detailed in Sec. II . (b) Schematic illustration of expectation values obtained from executing the target circuit \langle\tilde{O}\rangle_{t} , the noise-canceling circuit \langle\tilde{O}\rangle_{ncc} , and of the auxiliary quantity \mathcal{A} as a function of the noise scale factor \lambda_{i} . Expectation values and the auxiliary quantity are shown for two different bootstrap indices (s). The mean absolute deviation (MAD) of the sets {\langle\tilde{O}\rangle_{t}^{\mathrm{s}}(\lambda_{i})} and {\mathcal{A}^{\mathrm{s}}(\lambda_{i})} is schematically represented. As explained in Sec. II , the first post-processing step ensures that \mathcal{A}(\lambda_{1}) serves as the baseline estimator for the ideal expectation value. (c) Experimentally observed correlation between the normalized dispersion \mathcal{D} and the residual bias error \mathcal{B} . The light blue shaded region represents a total of 8\times 10^{6} baseline estimations, obtained from 2.4\times 10^{5} measurement shots. The blue and red data points correspond to the mean and standard deviation of the baseline and final estimations, respectively. A detailed explanation of this plot is provided in Sec. II.2 . Noise-agnostic approaches, such as zero noise extrapolation (ZNE) Temme et al. 2017 ; Li and Benjamin 2017 ; Kim et al. 2023 , do not require explicit noise models. In ZNE, a noiseless expectation value is estimated by amplifying noise and extrapolating to the zero-noise limit. However, ZNE suffers from two major limitations. First, expectation values in non-Clifford circuits with Pauli noise exhibit a multi-exponential decay Kim et al. 2023 ; Cai 2021 with a generally unknown number of parameters. As a result, common extrapolation techniques—such as polynomial Temme et al. 2017 ; Li and Benjamin 2017 ; Krebsbach et al. 2022 or single-exponential fits Endo et al. 2018 ; Kim et al. 2023 —introduce systematic bias due to fitting-model mismatch. Second, noise amplification (to implement noise scale factors \lambda_{i} ) is implemented via pulse-level control Temme et al. 2017 ; Kandala et al. 2019 or gate-level techniques such as unitary folding Giurgica-Tiron et al. 2020 ; Dumitrescu et al. 2018 ; He et al. 2020 . In practice, experimental noise channels often do not commute with the circuit unitary, leading to uncertainties in noise amplification Koenig et al. 2024 . Recent efforts have sought to improve the accuracy of noise amplification, such as probabilistic noise amplification Kim et al. 2023 ; Ferracin et al. 2022 ; Hour et al. 2024 , but these methods reintroduce a reliance on noise models, partially defeating the noise-agnostic principle. Other noise-agnostic methods, such as Clifford data regression (CDR) Czarnik et al. 2021 and its extension variable-noise CDR (vnCDR) Lowe et al. 2021 , attempt to learn noise effects using near-Clifford circuits. While effective for shallow circuits, their accuracy may degrade for deeper circuits due to the mismatch in noise scaling behavior between non-Clifford and near-Clifford circuits. Similarly, the depolarizing-error-mitigation method proposed in Ref. Urbanek et al. 2021 mitigates the effects of local depolarizing noise (by introducing an estimation circuit) before performing standard ZNE. While this approach can be more effective than ZNE under the assumption that depolarizing noise is the dominant error mechanism, real quantum devices often exhibit more complex noise characteristics, thereby limiting the accuracy of this method. These limitations highlight the need for a noise-agnostic approach that systematically reduces bias while maintaining a manageable sampling overhead. In the following, we introduce Noise-Robust Estimation (NRE), a novel framework that leverages a bias-dispersion correlation uncovered in this work to enhance the accuracy of expectation value estimation. NRE introduces an auxiliary quantity, \mathcal{A} , which is less sensitive to noise than the directly measured expectation value of the observable O , obtained by executing the noisy target ( t ) quantum circuit, \langle\tilde{O}\rangle_{t} . Unlike existing methods, NRE employs a distinctive two-step post-processing framework to achieve robust estimations. First post-processing layer: Baseline estimation. This step constructs an initial estimator, \langle O\rangle^{\mathrm{b-NRE}} , using a noise-canceling circuit ( ncc ) and a tunable control parameter. As explained in the Results, the ncc is structurally similar to the target circuit but designed such that its noiseless expectation value is known. While the baseline estimation suppresses noise effects, it generally retains an unknown residual bias, \mathcal{B} . Second post-processing layer: Bias-Dispersion correlation. A key insight of NRE is the discovery of a strong correlation between the unknown residual bias and a measurable quantity, the normalized dispersion ( \mathcal{D} ). The latter quantifies the noise sensitivity of the auxiliary quantity relative to that of the observable of interest. Ideally, after the first post-processing step, the auxiliary quantity should be completely insensitive to noise, implying \mathcal{D}\to 0 . Since \mathcal{D} quantifies noise sensitivity, a smaller \mathcal{D} statistically correlates with a reduced residual bias \mathcal{B} ,

Read the complete text