Redshift-Space Distortions in Massive Neutrinos Cosmologies
Francesco Verdiani a,b,c,d, Emilio Bellini e,b,c, Chiara Moretti a,b,c,d, Emiliano Sefusatti b,c,d, Carmelita Carbone f,g, Matteo Viel a,b,c,d,g · 2025
Read Redshift-Space Distortions in Massive Neutrinos Cosmologies by Francesco Verdiani a,b,c,d, Emilio Bellini e,b,c, Chiara Moretti a,b,c,d, Emiliano Sefusatti b,c,d, Carmelita Carbone f,g, Matteo Viel a,b,c,d,g (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-06655.txt.
Introduction
Francesco Verdiani and co-authors test a classic formula for how galaxies cluster when their distances come from redshifts. Their 2025 paper works in universes with heavy neutrinos, where the standard Kaiser formula faces an ambiguity. The open question is which velocity field halos follow: that of all matter, or only of its cold part.
The team compares the formula against a large suite of N-body simulations, fitting halo power spectra and cross-spectra in full. The fits speak clearly for the cold matter field, made of cold dark matter and baryons. Using total matter instead fits worse and can drag model parameters to false values. The result steadies a tool used to read cosmic structure from galaxy surveys.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Francesco Verdiani a,b,c,d, Emilio Bellini e,b,c, Chiara Moretti a,b,c,d, Emiliano Sefusatti b,c,d, Carmelita Carbone f,g, Matteo Viel a,b,c,d,g |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-06655
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Redshift-Space Distortions in Massive Neutrinos Cosmologies Francesco Verdiani a,b,c,d, Emilio Bellini e,b,c, Chiara Moretti a,b,c,d, Emiliano Sefusatti b,c,d, Carmelita Carbone f,g, Matteo Viel a,b,c,d,g Abstract We study the Kaiser formula for biased tracers in massive neutrino cosmologies by comparing its predictions with a large set of N-body simulations. In particular, we examine the ambiguity in the definition of the peculiar velocity contribution at linear level, whether it should be expressed in terms of the total matter velocity field or only the cold-matter component, comprised of cold dark matter and baryons. We revisit and extend previous qualitative studies on the topic with larger statistics and including a full fit of halo power spectrum and halo-matter cross-power spectrum measurements. We find clear evidence that the clustering of halos in redshift space is correctly described assuming that halo velocity is tracing the velocity field of cold-matter. The opposite assumption provides a worse fit to the simulated data and can lead to a spurious running of nuisance parameters in the perturbative galaxy power spectrum model. Preprint: APS/123-QED I Introduction Recent advances in observational precision and theoretical modeling brought us to the verge of directly measuring neutrino masses through their imprints on cosmic structures (see, e.g. [ 1 ] ), with current and upcoming spectroscopic galaxy surveys playing a key role in this endeavor [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 ] . The peculiar suppression of small-scale growth of matter perturbations due to massive neutrinos’ free streaming [ 10 ] leads to a potentially distinctive feature in the shape of the galaxy power spectrum. It is therefore essential to accurately describe the relation between matter and galaxy density both in real and redshift space in the context of massive neutrino cosmologies. At the linear level, such relation is described by the celebrated Kaiser expression [ 11 ] \delta_{g,s}(\mathbf{k})=\delta_{g}(\mathbf{k})-\mu^{2}\frac{\theta_{g}(\mathbf{k})}{\mathcal{H}}\,, (1) where the redshift-space galaxy perturbations in Fourier-space, \delta_{g,s}(\mathbf{k}) , are given by their real-space value, \delta_{g}(\mathbf{k}) , plus a correction that depends on the peculiar galaxy velocity along the line of sight \hat{n} , with \mu\equiv\hat{k}\cdot\hat{n} , {\mathcal{H}} the Hubble parameter and \theta_{g}\equiv{\bf\nabla}\cdot{\bf u}_{g} is the divergence of the galaxy peculiar velocity field {\bf u}_{g} . The galaxy distribution density and velocity must be related to the underlying matter distributions in order to constrain the cosmological model from galaxy observations. In massive neutrino cosmologies, a natural ambiguity arises w.r.t. the definition of the matter density field. One option is to consider the combination of dark matter and baryons in standard \Lambda CDM models, hereafter denoted as “cold matter”, since baryonic effects can be neglected at large scales. In addition, since massive neutrinos behave as dark matter at low redshift, an alternative definition of matter could include dark matter, baryons, and neutrinos. In what follows, we will denote this “total matter”. As far as the galaxy density is concerned, numerical simulations have shown that a proper definition of galaxy bias expansion in terms of constant bias parameters must be defined w.r.t. the cold matter density [ 12 , 13 ] . The alternative option of a galaxy bias defined w.r.t. the total matter perturbations would lead to bias parameters affected by a spurious scale dependence. The second term in the Kaiser formula is also affected by the same ambiguity. The galaxy velocity field is usually presumed to be unbiased w.r.t. the matter field velocity, but for massive neutrinos cosmologies the cold matter and total matter velocities are not the same. Although it is often assumed, sometimes implicitly following the results of [ 12 , 13 ] , that the galaxy velocity coincides with the cold-matter velocity, this has not found a proper, quantitative confirmation from numerical simulations. Some early work looked at the issue, but with a relatively limited cumulative simulation volume [ 14 , 15 ] . In particular, in [ 15 ] a few quantities such as the growth rate f , scale-dependent when neutrinos are massive, have been directly estimated from simulations and compared to linear theory predictions under different assumptions. The lack of statistical significance could not lead to any clear result. Perhaps the most directly relevant work in the past literature is [ 16 ] , taking advantage of a much larger set of simulations, then denoted as HADES , now part of the even larger QUIJOTE suite [ 17 ] . In [ 16 ] the bias between the halo and cold-matter momenta is estimated and shown to approach unity at large scales. However this result, while not directly dealing with the velocity field, is also not compared to the same bias defined w.r.t. the total matter momentum. As we will show, such comparison would have led, taken alone, to the same qualitative conclusion. In this work we revisit some of these prior results and extend them in order to obtain a firm, quantitative assessment on the galaxy velocity field in massive neutrino cosmologies. In the first place, we reproduce some of the results of both [ 15 ] and [ 16 ] , in some cases with better statistics or with more complete comparisons. In addition, we perform full fits of a theoretical model based on Perturbation Theory (PT), for both the cold-matter or total matter velocity options, to a set of measurements of halo auto-power spectra and halo-cold matter cross-power spectra both in real and redshift space. This allows to make a quantitative assessment on which assumption provides the best fit to the simulated data. This work is organized as follows. In Sect. II we introduce the theoretical background both at linear and nonlinear level in PT leading to predictions for both auto- and cross-power spectra. In Sect. III we briefly present the simulations sets employed and the power spectra measurements. In Sect. IV we perform a direct, qualitative comparison of measurements from the halo catalogs and linear theory predictions, while in Sect. V we present the results for the fit of the nonlinear model. We conclude in Sect. VI . II Theory II.1 Linear theory In the large-scale limit, the density contrast of tracers (e.g. galaxies or dark-matter halos) in redshift space is distorted by the effect of peculiar velocities as in Eq. ( 1 ), [ 11 ] (see [ 18 ] for a general introduction to redshift-space distortions). In the standard \Lambda CDM picture, with massless neutrinos and baryons approximated as cold dark matter, the velocity bias of tracers with respect to matter perturbations has been shown to be a higher-derivative effect, with the large-scale limit of unity bias dictated by the equivalence principle [ 19 , 20 ] . In linear theory we can set \theta_{h}=\theta_{m} and, along with the linear bias relation \delta_{h}=b\delta_{m} , rewrite Eq. ( 1 ) as [ 11 ] \delta_{h,s}(\mathbf{k})=\left(b+f\mu^{2}\right)\delta_{m}(\mathbf{k})\,, (2) in terms of the linear growth rate f\equiv\frac{d\log D}{d\log a}\,. (3) with a the scale factor and D(a) the linear growth factor. In the context of massive neutrino cosmologies, however, matter perturbations are made up of two components with different properties, even at large scales. These are the cold component, composed of dark matter and baryons, here assimilated to DM, and the neutrino component. In what follows, we will