Sets of equiangular lines in dimension 18 18 constructed from A 9 ⊕ A 9 ⊕ A 1 A_{9}\oplus A_{9}\oplus A_{1}

Yen-chi Roger Lin, Akihiro Munemasa, Tetsuji Taniguchi, Kiyoto Yoshino · 2025

Read Sets of equiangular lines in dimension 18 18 constructed from A 9 ⊕ A 9 ⊕ A 1 A_{9}\oplus A_{9}\oplus A_{1} by Yen-chi Roger Lin, Akihiro Munemasa, Tetsuji Taniguchi, Kiyoto Yoshino (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-06377.txt.

Introduction

Yen-chi Roger Lin, Akihiro Munemasa, Tetsuji Taniguchi, and Kiyoto Yoshino count huge sets of equal-angle lines in eighteen dimensions, in a paper from two thousand twenty-five. A prior build found sets of fifty-seven such lines from a lattice with a switch root. The lattice is pinned down here as a cover of a named root lattice sum.

At least a quarter million such sets arise this way, up to exact congruence. All are proved strongly maximal, meaning no larger set can contain them even in higher space. Some sets show just six distinct angle marks. Readers in discrete geometry get both a census and a maximality proof for a record family.

Catalog record

CREATORYen-chi Roger Lin, Akihiro Munemasa, Tetsuji Taniguchi, Kiyoto Yoshino
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-06377

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Sets of equiangular lines in dimension 18 18 constructed from A 9 ⊕ A 9 ⊕ A 1 A_{9}\oplus A_{9}\oplus A_{1} Thanks: The research of A. Munemasa was supported by JSPS KAKENHI Grant Number 20K03527. The research of T. Taniguchi was supported by JSPS KAKENHI Grant Number 21K03344. The research of Y. R. Lin is partially supported by Taiwan NSTC grant 113-2115-M-003-016-MY2. Yen-chi Roger Lin, Akihiro Munemasa, Tetsuji Taniguchi, Kiyoto Yoshino Abstract . In 2023, Greaves et al. constructed several sets of 57 equiangular lines in dimension 18. Using the concept of switching root introduced by Cao et al. in 2021, these sets of equiangular lines are embedded in a lattice of rank 19 spanned by norm 3 vectors together with a switching root. We characterize this lattice as an overlattice of the root lattice A 9 ⊕ A 9 ⊕ A 1 A_{9}\oplus A_{9}\oplus A_{1} , and show that there are at least 246896 246896 sets of 57 equiangular lines in dimension 18 18 arising in this way, up to isometry. Additionally, we prove that all of these sets of equiangular lines are strongly maximal. Here, a set of equiangular lines is said to be strongly maximal if there is no set of equiangular lines properly containing it even if the dimension of the underlying space is increased. Among these sets, there are ones with only six distinct Seidel eigenvalues. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 05B40, 05B20, 05C50, 05C70 1. Introduction A set of lines through the origin in a real vector space is equiangular if any pair of these lines forms the same angle. The maximum cardinality N(d) of a set of equiangular lines in dimension d has been studied since 1948 [ 14 ] . The values or bounds of N(d) for d\leq 23 are summarized in Table 1 [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 16 , 23 ] . Table 1. The values or bounds of N(d) for d\leq 23 . d 2 3 4 5 6 7–14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 N(d) 3 6 6 10 16 28 36 40 48 57–59 72–74 90–94 126 176 276 In any dimension, a general upper bound N(d)\leq d(d+1)/2 [ 16 ] and lower bounds [ 6 , 10 ] are known. For a fixed common angle \arccos(\alpha) , the maximum cardinality N_{\alpha}(d) of a set of equiangular lines with common angle \arccos(\alpha) in dimension d has also been studied. It is known that 1/\alpha must be an odd integer if N_{\alpha}(d)>2d [ 16 , Theorem 3.4] . In the case of \alpha=1/3 , sets of equiangular lines with common angle \arccos(1/3) have been enumerated [ 21 , 26 ] , and their maximality has been determined [ 3 ] . In the case of \alpha=1/5 , the so-called Lemmens-Seidel conjecture N_{1/5}(d)=\max\left\{276,\left\lfloor(3d-3)/2\right\rfloor\right\} for d\geq 23 has been proved [ 2 , 16 , 26 ] . In high dimensions, Jiang et al. proved that for every integer k\geq 2 , N_{1/(2k-1)}(d)=\lfloor k(d-1)/(k-1)\rfloor for all sufficiently large d [ 15 ] . As mentioned above, determining N(d) and N_{\alpha}(d) has attracted significant attention, and a natural question arises as to whether existing sets of equiangular lines can be extended to construct new ones. To address this, the concept of strongly maximal sets of equiangular lines was introduced [ 3 ] . A set of equiangular lines is said to be strongly maximal if there is no set of equiangular lines properly containing it even if the dimension of the underlying space is increased. Cao et al. [ 3 ] proved that any set of equiangular lines achieving the so-called absolute bound is strongly maximal and determined strongly maximal sets of equiangular lines with common angle \arccos(1/3) . The main focus of this paper is on sets of equiangular lines in dimension 18 , which is the smallest dimension where N(d) remains unknown. From the relative bound [ 16 ] , it follows that N(18)=N_{1/5}(18)\leq 61 . Greaves et al. [ 11 ] further refined this bound, proving that N(18)\leq 59 . Also, Taylor remarked that N(18)\geq 48 [ 22 , p. 124] . Szőllösi [ 20 ] improved the lower bound to N(18)\geq 54 . Subsequently, Lin and Yu [ 17 ] proved N(18)\geq 56 , and show that no extra line can be added to either of the two sets of equiangular lines in [ 17 , 20 ] . Their approach to constructing large sets of equiangular lines involved removing specific lines from a set of 276 equiangular lines in dimension 23 , which is known to be unique [ 9 , Theorem A] . More recently, Greaves et al. [ 13 ] proved that N(18)\geq 57 by searching for vectors in \mathbb{Z}^{18} of norm 10 with pairwise inner product \pm 2 . They explicitly provided four Seidel matrices corresponding to four sets of 57 equiangular lines in dimension 18 and claimed to have identified numerous others. They then posed the question of whether their four sets of equiangular lines are contained in the set of 276 equiangular lines in dimension 23 . Yoshino [ 24 ] resolved this question in the negative, and moreover proved that the four sets are strongly maximal. In this paper, we show that there are a large number of strongly maximal sets of 57 equiangular lines in dimension 18 which are realized by sets of norm 3 vectors in a certain overlattice \Lambda of the root lattice A_{9}\oplus A_{9}\oplus A_{1} . We note the lattice \Lambda in Theorem 1.1 is chosen in such a way that it realizes four sets of 57 equiangular lines in [ 13 ] . In fact, we verify in Appendix that the sets of equiangular lines we found include those explicitly given in [ 13 ] . Our main theorem is as follows. The definition of affine equiangular sets will be given in Definition 2.1 . It makes possible to represent a set of equiangular lines with common angle \arccos(1/5) in terms of a set of norm 3 vectors in an integral lattice. Theorem 1.1 . There are at least 246896 affine equiangular sets of cardinality 57 with norm 3 with respect to (0,0,(1,-1)) in the lattice \Lambda up to isometry. Furthermore, all of these affine equiangular sets are strongly maximal. Since affine equiangular sets essentially correspond to sets of equiangular lines, as will be introduced and explained in Section 2 , this theorem immediately implies the following corollary. Corollary 1.2 . There are at least 246896 sets of 57 equiangular lines in dimension 18 with common angle \arccos(1/5) up to isometry. However, all the sets of equiangular lines we found are strongly maximal as well, and as a result, our result does not directly contribute to a possible of improvement the lower bound on N(18) . It may well be true that N(18) is 57 . The main tool in our study is the concept of switching roots, introduced in [ 3 ] , which significantly simplifies the search for vectors that form sets of equiangular lines. A natural approach to searching for vectors that form a set of equiangular lines with common angle of \arccos(1/5) is to

Read the complete text