Immersive Virtual Reality Assessments of Working Memory and Psychomotor Skills: A Comparison between Immersive and Non-Immersive Assessments Journal: arXiV

Panagiotis Kourtesis, Andrea Lizarraga, Sarah E. MacPherson · 2025

Read Immersive Virtual Reality Assessments of Working Memory and Psychomotor Skills: A Comparison between Immersive and Non-Immersive Assessments Journal: arXiV by Panagiotis Kourtesis, Andrea Lizarraga, Sarah E. MacPherson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-06333.txt.

Introduction

Panagiotis Kourtesis, Andrea Lizarraga, and Sarah MacPherson compare cognitive tests in virtual reality with the same tests on a plain computer in a 2025 study. Immersive tests feel more like real life and allow natural hand use, but it was unclear whether scores would match the standard forms.

Sixty-six people took memory and reaction tests in both formats. Scores matched on one memory test, while the computer form gave better results on a block task and faster reactions. Age and tech skill shaped computer scores far more than virtual scores. Users also rated the virtual form higher for ease and delight. Readers get evidence that virtual testing may be fairer across groups.

Catalog record

CREATORPanagiotis Kourtesis, Andrea Lizarraga, Sarah E. MacPherson
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-06333

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Immersive Virtual Reality Assessments of Working Memory and Psychomotor Skills: A Comparison between Immersive and Non-Immersive Assessments Journal: arXiV Panagiotis Kourtesis, Andrea Lizarraga, Sarah E. MacPherson Abstract Objective: Immersive virtual reality (VR) enhances ecological validity and facilitates intuitive and ergonomic hand interactions for performing neuropsychological assessments. However, its comparability to traditional computerized methods remains unclear. This study investigates the convergent validity, user experience, and usability of VR-based versus PC-based assessments of short-term and working memory, and psychomotor skills, while also examining how demographic and IT-related skills influence performance in both modalities. Methods: Sixty-six participants performed the Digit Span Task (DST), Corsi Block Task (CBT), and Deary-Liewald Reaction Time Task (DLRTT) in both VR- and PC-based formats. Participants’ experience in using computers and smartphones, and playing videogames, was considered. User experience and system usability of the formats were also evaluated. Results: While performance on DST was similar across modalities, PC assessments enabled better performance on CBT and faster reaction times in DLRTT. Moderate-to-strong correlations between VR and PC versions supported convergent validity. Regression analyses revealed that performance on PC versions was influenced by age, computing, and gaming experience, whereas performance on VR versions was largely independent of these factors, except for gaming experience predicting performance on CBT backward recall. Moreover, VR assessments received higher ratings for user experience and usability than PC-based assessments. Conclusion: Immersive VR assessments provide an engaging alternative to traditional computerized methods, with minimal reliance on prior IT experience and demographic factors. This resilience to individual differences suggests that VR may offer a more equitable and accessible platform for cognitive assessment. Future research should explore the long-term reliability of VR-based assessments. 1 Introduction Cognitive abilities underpin a wide spectrum of human behaviour, ranging from intricate problem-solving and learning tasks to routine, everyday activities. Within this domain, working memory and psychomotor skills have attracted extensive interest in research and clinical contexts due to their profound impact on functional independence and overall quality of life ( Alloway et al. 2009 ; Baddeley 1992 ; Deary and Der 2005a ) . Broadly, working memory enables the temporary storage and manipulation of information, forming the backbone of higher-level processes such as reasoning, language comprehension, and coherent response formation ( Gathercole et al. 2008 ; Raghubar et al. 2010 ; Rogers et al. 2011 ) . Psychomotor skills, by contrast, integrate sensory input, cognitive appraisal, and motor output, allowing humans to navigate their environment effectively—whether through basic object manipulation or more complex tasks like driving or operating machinery ( Chaiken et al. 2000 ) . Both working memory and psychomotor abilities are susceptible to age-related decline and to neuropathological conditions such as stroke or dementia, reinforcing the need for robust, reliable assessment tools ( Alloway et al. 2009 ; Hatem et al. 2016 ) . Traditionally, neuropsychological evaluations of these constructs have relied on well-established assessment tools and their computerized versions such as the Digit Span Task (DST; ( Ramsay and Reynolds 1995 ; Woods et al. 2011b ) ), Corsi Block Task (CBT; ( Corsi 1973 ; Kessels et al. 2000 ) ), and reaction-time measures like the Deary–Liewald Reaction Time Task (DLRTT; ( Deary et al. 2011 ) ). These assessments offer diagnostic clarity and standardized administration protocols, which is particularly advantageous for identifying cognitive impairment associated with neurological conditions such as Alzheimer’s disease and stroke ( Alloway et al. 2009 ; Petersen 2004 ) . The DST evaluates verbal short-term or working memory by requiring individuals to repeat or manipulate sequences of digits ( Baddeley 1992 ) , whereas the CBT assesses visuospatial short-term or working memory by calling for participants to replicate block sequences in a forward or backward order ( Corsi 1973 ) . Reaction-time tasks, whether simple (SRT) or choice-based (CRT), examine psychomotor coordination and have been linked to fluid intelligence, everyday motor functioning, and even mortality risk ( Deary and Der 2005b ; Der and Deary 2006 ; Jensen 2006 ) . Despite their proven utility, the computerized versions of these traditional assessments face significant limitations in capturing the complexity of real-world cognition. They predominantly rely on two-dimensional, highly controlled stimuli and environments that diverge substantially from the multifaceted, three-dimensional challenges people encounter in daily life ( Kourtesis and MacPherson 2021 ; Parsons 2015 ; Rizzo et al. 2004 ) . For instance, tasks like repeating digit sequences or selecting squares on a screen do not reflect the distractor-loaded contexts and spatial characteristics of everyday scenarios. Consequently, these tests may have limited ecological validity, reducing their capacity to predict real-life performance (veridicality) and/or emulate daily experiences (verisimilitude) ( Spooner and Pachana 2006 ; Suchy et al. 2024 ) . While their simplicity and standardization help isolate specific cognitive processes, these instruments cannot replicate the embodied performance of tasks in a three-dimensional, 360-degree, real-world setting, thus overlooking important visuospatial and motor aspects of everyday functioning. An additional concern relates to digital literacy confounds associated with computerized assessment. A growing body of evidence suggests that individuals with higher familiarity in video gaming, computing, or smartphone use often outperform less tech-savvy participants on computerized tasks ( Bauer et al. 2012 ; Feldstein et al. 1999 ; Iverson et al. 2009 ) . Technology-proficient individuals benefit from enhanced fine motor control, faster reaction times, and more adept navigation through on-screen interfaces ( Borecki et al. 2013 ) . Consequently, traditional computerized assessments requiring fine motor skills to press keys and/or control a mouse may inadvertently measure digital proficiency rather than purely cognitive constructs. Such a confound is particularly problematic when testing older adults or individuals from lower socioeconomic or educational backgrounds, who may lack consistent exposure to computers or gaming devices ( Bauer et al. 2012 ; Feldstein et al. 1999 ) . Thus, while computerized tasks facilitate automated data collection and scoring, they can introduce biases that undermine test fairness and inclusivity. Immersive Virtual Reality (VR) emerges as a promising solution to these challenges, enabling researchers and clinicians to preserve the structured control of laboratory settings while introducing greater ecological validity. By using head-mounted displays, motion tracking, and optional haptic feedback, VR can simulate complex, three-dimensional environments where participants interact via naturalistic and intuitive embodied interactions instead of keyboards or mice ( Kourtesis et al. 2020 ) . This shift may not only lessen the advantage conferred by prior computer experience but also offer a more intuitive means of completing cognitive tasks, as well as potentially improving usability, user experience, and data fidelity ( Kourtesis and MacPherson 2021 ; Zaidi et al. 2018 ) . Immersive VR neuropsychological assessments, such as the Virtual Reality Everyday Assessment Lab ( Kourtesis et al. 2021 ) and Nesplora Aquarium ( Climent et al. 2021 ) , have demonstrated robust validity. Notably, such immersive formats appear to reduce test fatigue, sustain participant attention, and accurately measure cognitive processes ranging from working memory to executive functions ( Kourtesis et al. 2020 ; Rizzo et al. 2004 ) . Another strength of VR-based methods lies in their capacity to systematically manipulate environmental factors. For example, clinicians can introduce or remove distractors, vary object placement, and alter time pressures in ways that are challenging to replicate in physical or 2D computerized settings ( Parsons 2015 ;

Read the complete text