Metastable Cosmic Strings and Gravitational Waves from Flavour Symmetry Breaking
Stefan Antusch, Kevin Hinze, Shaikh Saad · 2025
Read Metastable Cosmic Strings and Gravitational Waves from Flavour Symmetry Breaking by Stefan Antusch, Kevin Hinze, Shaikh Saad (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-05868.txt.
Introduction
Antusch, Hinze, and Saad propose an origin for a network of cosmic strings that may explain a faint hum of gravitational waves picked up in 2023. Cosmic strings are thin relics of symmetry breaking in the early universe, and a slowly decaying kind fits the signal well. Their 2025 model grows the strings from the staged breaking of a flavor symmetry, the rules that sort matter particles into families.
In their example, a small symmetry acts only on the first two families inside a grand unified frame. The setup also explains why particle masses span such a wide ladder, and it suits the large mixing seen among leptons. The string scale it predicts lands in the range the timing data favor. Inflation ties to the last breaking step, whose end seeds the string network.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Stefan Antusch, Kevin Hinze, Shaikh Saad |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-05868
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Metastable Cosmic Strings and Gravitational Waves from Flavour Symmetry Breaking Stefan Antusch, Kevin Hinze, Shaikh Saad Abstract Metastable cosmic strings (MSCSs) are among the best-fitting explanations of the 2023 pulsar timing array (PTA) signal for gravitational waves at nanohertz frequencies. We propose the novel possibility that a network of MSCSs generating this signal originates from the multi-step spontaneous breaking of a gauged flavour symmetry. As a specific example, we construct a model of S U ( 2 ) SU(2) flavour symmetry in the context of S U ( 5 ) SU(5) grand unification, where the S U ( 2 ) SU(2) acts exclusively on the first two generations of the matter 10-plet, such that it is “right for leptons” and allows for large lepton mixing. The model explains the mass hierarchies of the Standard Model fermions, and predicts the string scale of the MSCSs in a range compatible with the 2023 PTA signal. Cosmic inflation is associated with the latter step of (two-step) family symmetry breaking, and the phase transition ending inflation generates the cosmic string network. I Introduction In summer 2023, pulsar timing arrays (PTAs) NANOGrav:2023gor ; Antoniadis:2023ott ; Reardon:2023gzh ; Xu:2023wog found strong evidence of Hellings-Downs angular correlation Hellings:1983fr in pulsar time-of-arrival perturbations, providing a first clear signal of a stochastic gravitational wave background (SGWB) at nanohertz frequencies. Remarkably, metastable cosmic strings (MSCSs) arising from gauge groups are among the best-fitting explanations NANOGrav:2023hvm of this signal, which has sparked interest within the particle physics community, see Refs. Antusch:2023zjk ; Buchmuller:2023aus ; Fu:2023mdu ; Lazarides:2023rqf ; Ahmed:2023rky ; Afzal:2023cyp ; Maji:2023fhv ; Ahmed:2023pjl ; Afzal:2023kqs ; King:2023wkm ; Roshan:2024qnv ; Ahmed:2024iyd ; Antusch:2024ypp ; Maji:2024pll ; Antusch:2024nqg ; Datta:2024bqp ; Maji:2024cwv ; Pallis:2024joc ; Ahmad:2025dds for works on metastable strings, and Refs. Lazarides:2023ksx ; Yamada:2023thl ; Servant:2023mwt ; Lazarides:2023bjd ; Pallis:2024mip for other works on unstable cosmic strings. In the above mentioned studies the origin of MSCSs has been linked to particle physics extensions where the gauge group of the Standard Model (SM) is embedded into a larger (e.g. unified) group, which is then spontaneously broken to the SM in multiple steps, generating first monopoles Kibble:1976sj ; Preskill:1979zi ; Vilenkin:2000jqa and then cosmic strings Kibble:1976sj ; Vilenkin:2000jqa . If the two symmetry breaking scales are close, and if certain conditions are satisfied Vilenkin:1982hm ; Preskill:1992ck , monopole-antimonopole pairs can form along the strings through quantum tunneling, causing the strings to decay and resulting in the metastability of the cosmic string network. MSCSs can generate a GW spectrum across a wide range of frequencies, with a characteristic drop, as observed by the PTAs, when the decay happens. However, in addition to extensions of the gauge symmetry of the SM towards unification of forces, there exists another class of symmetry extensions of the SM, namely “ flavour symmetries ”, which act “horizontally” between different generations. Flavour symmetries are postulated to address the so-called “ flavour puzzle ” of the SM, which becomes apparent when considering the SM flavour sector: The SM flavour sector contains in total fourteen unknown parameters, which include the six quark masses, three charged lepton masses, and four quark mixing angles. Experimental determination of these parameters reveals a strong hierarchical pattern in the masses and mixings of the charged fermions. While neutrinos are massless in the SM, observations from various experiments have confirmed neutrino oscillations, implying nine (seven, if neutrinos are Dirac particles) additional parameters, including three neutrino masses, three mixing angles, and three CP-violating phases. Unlike the charged fermion sector, the mixing angles in the neutrino sector are large. The lack of a fundamental understanding of the strong hierarchical structure of the charged fermions – spanning approximately six orders of magnitude – and the apparently anarchical structure of the neutrino sector is one of the major challenges in particle physics, referred to as the flavour puzzle. In this paper, we propose the novel possibility that a network of MSCSs generating the 2023 PTA signal originates from the spontaneous breaking of a gauged “ flavour symmetry ”. In Sec. II , we outline the specifications for generating metastable cosmic strings and discuss how they can emerge, for example, from an SU(2) flavour symmetry. In Sec. III , we construct a realisation of a flavour model with SU(2) flavour symmetry in the context of SU(5) grand unification. Finally, we conclude in Sec. IV . II MSCSs and Flavour Symmetry When the flavour symmetry group G_{F} and its breaking dynamics satisfies the following criteria, it can give rise to a MSCS network: To start with, the theory has to give rise to cosmic strings as well as monopoles, both originating from the same parent group (here G_{F} ). We consider here the multi-step breaking of G_{F} to subgroups, for example G_{F}\to G_{F}^{\prime}\to G_{F}^{\prime\prime} , but of course the breaking may happen in a larger number of steps. Monopoles Kibble:1976sj ; Preskill:1979zi are generated when, e.g. for the breaking G_{F}\to G^{\prime}_{F} , the second homotopy group of the quotient space G_{F}/G^{\prime}_{F} is non-trivial, i.e. when \pi_{2}(G/G^{\prime})\neq{1} , while cosmic strings Kibble:1976sj appear in case of a non-trivial first homotopy group, e.g. when \pi_{1}(G^{\prime}_{F}/G^{\prime\prime}_{F})\neq{1} . When for the breaking G_{F}\to G_{F}^{\prime}\to G_{F}^{\prime\prime} both above-mentioned conditions are satisfied, but the homotopy groups of G_{F}/G^{\prime\prime}_{F} are all trivial, then none of these topological defects can be stable. The monopoles and cosmic strings form an unstable hybrid topological defect. Whether the cosmic strings, generated after the monopoles, are long-lived enough to explain the 2023 PTA observations, depends on further criteria: The first one is that the abundance of monopoles produced from the breaking G_{F}\to G_{F}^{\prime} has to be diminished before cosmic string production, to avoid that the cosmic strings that form at the later breaking G^{\prime}_{F}\to G^{\prime\prime}_{F} attach to the monopoles and antimonopoles, which would cause a too quick decay of the cosmic string network. One way to resolve this is to realise a phase of inflation Guth:1980zm ; Albrecht:1982wi ; Linde:1981mu ; Linde:1983gd between the two stages of symmetry breaking, diluting the monopoles. Nevertheless, pairs of monopoles and antimonopoles can spontaneously nucleate along the strings by quantum tunneling, making the cosmic strings decay. However, this process is only efficient if these two formation scales are close to each other. If they are well separated, the cosmic string network effectively behaves as a stable one. Therefore, this second condition – that these scales are of the same order – guarantees that the lifetime of the hybrid network coincides with the PTA signal. Last but not least, this hybrid network must originate from a gauge group to be capable of explaining the PTA data. SU(2) Flavour Symmetry Example To illustrate the above let us consider a non-Abelian gauged SU(2)_{F} flavour symmetry, which is a popular route towards addressing why the first two families of charged fermions are lighter than the third (cf. Barbieri:1995uv ; Barbieri:1996ae ; Barbieri:1996ww ; Barbieri:1999pe ; Masiero:2001cc ; Linster:2018avp ; Barbieri:1997tu ; Carone:1997qg ; Roberts:2001zy ; Raby:2003ay ; Dudas:2013pja ; Falkowski:2015zwa ; Feruglio:2019ybq ; Barbieri:2019zdz ; Linster:2020fww ; Greljo:2023bix ; Antusch:2023shi ; Greljo:2024zrj for models using U(2) or SU(2) as flavour symmetries). When the first two generations of fermions are doublets of SU(2)_{F} , then their