Closing the intent-to-behavior gap via Fulfillment Priority Logic

B. El Mabsout *, A. Abdelgawad *, R. Mancuso · 2025

Read Closing the intent-to-behavior gap via Fulfillment Priority Logic by B. El Mabsout *, A. Abdelgawad *, R. Mancuso (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-05818.txt.

Introduction

Bassel El Mabsout, Abdelrahman Abdelgawad, and Renato Mancuso give reinforcement learning designers a logic for stating what they actually want, in a paper published in two thousand twenty-five. The chronic problem is translation: a designer's intent usually involves several goals at once, but reward functions are typically built by gluing single-goal scores together with weights.

That gluing is laborious and brittle, especially when goals fight each other, as speed and energy saving do in robotics. The authors build on the notion of objective fulfillment and define Fulfillment Priority Logic around it. A designer writes a logical formula that states the intentions and which goal outranks which. Their Balanced Policy Gradient algorithm then trains policies directly from such formulas. The authors report far better fulfillment of the stated intent than weighted rewards achieve. The work targets robots and other systems where trade-offs are the whole design problem.

Catalog record

CREATORB. El Mabsout *, A. Abdelgawad *, R. Mancuso
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-05818

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Closing the intent-to-behavior gap via Fulfillment Priority Logic B. El Mabsout *, A. Abdelgawad *, R. Mancuso Abstract Practitioners designing reinforcement learning policies face a fundamental challenge: translating intended behavioral objectives into representative reward functions. This challenge stems from behavioral intent requiring simultaneous achievement of multiple competing objectives, typically addressed through labor-intensive linear reward composition that yields brittle results. Consider the ubiquitous robotics scenario where performance maximization directly conflicts with energy conservation. Such competitive dynamics are resistant to simple linear reward combinations. In this paper, we present the concept of objective fulfillment upon which we build Fulfillment Priority Logic ( FPL ). FPL allows practioners to define logical formula representing their intentions and priorities within multi-objective reinforcement learning. Our novel Balanced Policy Gradient algorithm leverages FPL specifications to achieve up to 500% better sample efficiency compared to Soft Actor Critic. Notably, this work constitutes the first implementation of non-linear utility scalarization design, specifically for continuous control problems. I Introduction Reward design in reinforcement learning is a nuanced and intricate process that presents the complex challenge of aligning agent behavior with intended objectives [ 1 ] . Recent work by [ 2 ] , supported by findings from [ 3 ] , has exposed significant limitations in current practices, revealing that 92% of surveyed RL experts rely on trial-and-error approaches, leading to overfitted and inadequate reward functions. This issue fundamentally stems from the disconnect between human reward conceptualization and RL optimization mechanisms [ 2 ] , creating what we term the intent-to-behavior gap —the disparity between practitioners’ intended behavioral objectives and the actual behaviors exhibited by policies after optimization. We argue that traditional trial-and-error reward weight tuning in response to observed policy behaviors [ 4 , 5 ] is inherently flawed and propose a systematic solution. Researchers have approached this intent-to-behavior gap from various perspectives. Formal methods researchers adopted structured specifications such as temporal logics forming reward signals, providing a principled framework to express temporal controller behavior precisely [ 6 ] . Others focused on reward engineering, exploiting their domain knowledge as demonstrated by [ 7 ] in their quadrupedal locomotion work. They meticulously crafted a multi-component reward function (combining linear velocity, angular velocity, base motion stability, foot clearance, collision avoidance, trajectory smoothness, and torque minimization) with carefully balanced weights to achieve robust locomotion over challenging terrain. Other methods avoid this troublesome process altogether through inverse RL [ 8 ] , while more recent work delegates the whole reward design problem to Large Language Models [ 9 , 10 ] . Recognizing scalar rewards’ inherent limitations for expressing multifaceted intentions, multi-objective reinforcement learning (MORL) emerged to represent distinct objectives through vector rewards [ 11 , 12 ] . While there is support for Sutton’s reward hypothesis suggesting that maximization of any goals can theoretically reduce to maximizing a scalar signal [ 13 , 14 , 11 ] , later contributions [ 15 , 16 ] show that there are cases where this does not hold. Indeed, MORL research reveals that per-step scalarization is not expressive enough to represent desired behaviors adequately. This explains practitioners’ labor-intensive iterative reward tuning. The challenge shifts to developing methodologies that avoid multiple design-evaluate-adjust cycles. By maintaining vector representation throughout learning, MORL enables separate objective estimation before trade-offs. However, comparing policies in multi-objective spaces introduces a partial ordering problem—one policy may excel in certain objectives while underperforming in others—requiring scalarization utility functions (typically weighted sums) to establish total ordering. Yet even with this delayed scalarization, traditional linear utility functions often drive policies toward suboptimal local minima when objectives fundamentally conflict [ 17 ] . In this paper, we introduce Fulfillment Priority Logic ( FPL )—a logic transforming declarative policy behavior descriptions into utility functions through principled algebraic transformations, enabling practitioners to express objectives semantically while maintaining mathematical rigor and providing formal guarantees on objective fulfillment. Our approach directly addresses the ”Unspecified and Multi-Objective Reward Functions” challenge in real-world RL where traditional methods require complex, hand-crafted rewards [ 18 ] . FPL replaces weight-based specifications with logical priorities through three key innovations: (1) generalized mean operators for flexible objective composition, generalizing linear utilities, (2) Q-value level scalarization preserving intended relationships, and (3) principled normalization for stable cross-objective learning. Implementing these advances in our novel Balanced Policy Gradient ( BPG ) algorithm, we demonstrate up to 500% improvement in sample efficiency over Soft Actor Critic. Section II goes through the related works that tackled the intent-to-behavior gap . Section III provides theoretical foundations before introducing our core contributions—the Fulfillment Priority Logic ( Section IV ) and BPG algorithm ( Section V ). Empirical results follow in Section VI . Section VII concludes by offering limitations and future directions. II Related Works II-A Reward Design Reward design presents a fundamental challenge in reinforcement learning systems [ 1 ] . Traditional approaches integrate reward shaping techniques to improve learning efficiency [ 19 ] , yet remain constrained by the quality of underlying reward specifications. Research has progressed along multiple trajectories: inverse reinforcement learning extracts reward functions from demonstrations [ 8 ] , while recent LLM-based methods like Eureka [ 9 ] leverage natural language for behavior specification, though limited by reasoning capabilities and current reward engineering methods. Notably, complex real-world applications demonstrate an emerging pattern—practitioners inherently gravitate toward structured compositional approaches, as evidenced in tokamak reactor control [ 20 ] and various multi-objective domains [ 21 , 22 , 23 ] . This aligns with our earlier geometric reward composition work [ 24 ] , where we demonstrated that explicit attention to competing objectives produces more consistent policies with superior performance, even when evaluated against original environment reward functions. II-B Multi-Objective RL Multi-objective reinforcement learning (MORL) addresses environments requiring simultaneous optimization of multiple (possibly competing) objectives. MORL approaches divide into a-priori methods (preferences specified before training, yielding a single policy) and a-posteriori methods (generating multiple Pareto-optimal policies for post-training selection). Research has predominantly focused on a-posteriori approaches [ 25 , 26 ] , with advances including evolutionary algorithms [ 27 ] , hypernet-based Pareto front approximations [ 28 ] , and GPI-PD’s [ 29 ] sample-efficient Convex Coverage Sets. However, these methods typically rely on linear scalarization, which becomes limiting when objectives exhibit non-linear interactions [ 11 ] . While [ 12 ] introduced an actor-critic method that leverages a non-linear utility function, their approach assumes the utility exists and is confined to discrete action spaces. In contrast, our work explicitly designs the utility within a comprehensive framework, enabling its application to continuous control tasks. Our work introduces logical operators for objective composition that better captures intended trade-offs non-linearly. To our knowledge, this represents the first comprehensive a-priori MORL framework specifically designed for continuous robot control with non-linear utility functions. II-C Formal Methods Temporal logic frameworks [ 30 , 31 ] provide rigorous approaches for specifying temporal robot behavior, with extensions to learning-based control [ 32 ] and domain-specific languages like SPECTRL [ 33 ] . A fundamental limitation in applying formal methods to reinforcement learning is the challenge of optimizing non-differentiable logical specifications using gradient-based methods. The complementary nature of formal verification and priority-based optimization ( our work ) suggests potential integration pathways: formal methods could verify safety properties while

Read the complete text