Collaborative Drill Alignment in Surgical Robotics
Daniel Larby, Joshua Kershaw, Matthew Allen, Fulvio Forni · 2025
Read Collaborative Drill Alignment in Surgical Robotics by Daniel Larby, Joshua Kershaw, Matthew Allen, Fulvio Forni (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-05791.txt.
Introduction
Daniel Larby and co-authors describe, in a 2025 paper, a robotic system that helps surgeons align a drill during operations. The robot works under the surgeon's direct control, pairing machine steadiness with human judgment. A virtual guide holds the tool on the planned axis while the surgeon controls movement along it.
Older guide systems shaped motion with simple springs and dampers. This controller instead uses a virtual sliding joint with nonlinear springs, which makes the system's feel easier to shape. Extra visual feedback keeps the surgeon informed as the drill advances. The paper details how the system is calibrated and built. Such guides aim to make delicate bone work both safer and more repeatable.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daniel Larby, Joshua Kershaw, Matthew Allen, Fulvio Forni |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 57 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-05791
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Collaborative Drill Alignment in Surgical Robotics Daniel Larby, Joshua Kershaw, Matthew Allen, Fulvio Forni Abstract Robotic assistance allows surgeries to be reliably and accurately executed while still under direct supervision of the surgeon, combining the strengths of robotic technology with the surgeon’s expertise. This paper describes a robotic system designed to assist in surgical procedures by implementing a virtual drill guide. The system integrates virtual-fixture functionality using a novel virtual-mechanism controller with additional visual feedback. The controller constrains the tool to the desired axis, while allowing axial motion to remain under the surgeon’s control. Compared to prior virtual-fixture approaches—which primarily perform pure energy-shaping and damping injection with linear springs and dampers–our controller uses a virtual prismatic joint to which the robot is constrained by nonlinear springs, allowing us to easily shape the dynamics of the system. We detail the calibration procedures required to achieve sufficient precision, and describe the implementation of the controller. We apply this system to a veterinary procedure: drilling for transcondylar screw placement in dogs. The results of the trials on 3D-printed bone models demonstrate sufficient precision to perform the procedure and suggest improved angular accuracy and reduced exit translation errors compared to patient specific guides (PSG). Discussion and future improvements follow. I Introduction Robotic surgery has many potential advantages for treatment of humeral intracondylar fissure in dogs: these include enhanced precision, accuracy and reliability. We propose a robotic system to assist with drilling in preparation for transcondylar screw placement [ 1 ] . The novelty of our approach is to cast the problem into the setting of collaborative robotics: replacing the physical guide with a virtual one, combining the skills of the surgeon with the precision of the robot, and implementing this in an interactive way, not obscured by teleoperation or taken out of the surgeons hands by automation. We ask: can a mechanical drill guide be replaced by a virtual-drill guide, enforced by the robot? How can a controller be designed to implement such a behaviour? Can we show that the performance/accuracy of this system is sufficient and compares favourably to other methods? We will contrast our approach with a state-of-the-art assistive technology: 3D printed Patient-Specific-Guides (PSGs). A PSG is made by taking a template 3D model of a guide and subtracting the shape of the bone from it (taken from the CT scan), so that the surface of the PSG conforms to the bone. A clearance hole is then added to constrain the motion of the drill bit along an axial direction [ 2 ] . Compared to a PSG, a virtual guide offers several benefits. A PSG must be prepared for each individual surgery, increasing the lead time. PSGs require more soft tissue to be cleared so that the drill guide can sit cleanly on the bone. In contrast, a robotic approach does not require a custom part to be made and drilling can be performed minimally invasively, possibly decreasing the risk of infection. As shown in Figure 1 , our system utilizes a two-feedback approach. Firstly, a virtual mechanism [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] forms the fast inner-loop robot controller and allows compliant co-manipulation with the surgeon, so that the robot can act as an assistive controller. Secondly, a low-rate outer-loop vision feedback controller adapts the virtual mechanism based on it’s more accurate but slower measurements, to improve accuracy to the required level. The robot performs the same function as a physical drill guide, ‘automating’ the task of maintaining an accurate position/orientation, while leaving axial motion in the hands of the surgeon. The virtual mechanism that defines the control action in the inner loop is designed using simple physical analogies that make the purpose of the controller easy to understand. The virtual mechanism takes the form of a virtual drill interconnected to the robot arm via nonlinear saturating springs. These springs limit the maximum force the robot will apply, improving safety during interaction. The vision controller in the outer loop updates the position of the virtual drill to match the measured position of the bone. It also continuously adapts the offset of the saturating springs in response to visually measured error. The combined inner- and outer-loop actions lead to a torque reference for the torque controlled joints of the robot. The motion of the robot is constrained by the virtual mechanism while preserving backdrivability in the null-space of the constraints, so the redundancy of the robot can be exploited to change the pose during operation. Fig. 1: a) Experimental setup in position for drilling, from the perspective of the vision sensor. b) Block diagram of the control architecture, showing inner and outer control loops. The signals between each block are described in Section V . Compared with existing work in surgical robotics and virtual fixtures, we emphasize several novelties. There exist commercial systems for spinal screw placement [ 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] , but these simply position a drill guide, which means there is no ability to shape dynamics along the drilling axis. Another difference is that in [ 11 , 10 ] the custom miniature-robot is rigidly fixed to the spine to avoid relative motion—we instead track the bone with the vision system and use a standard serial robot arm. Other orthopaedic surgical systems which use a virtual fixture approach focus on knee and hip replacement/arthroplasty rather than screw placement [ 13 , 14 , 15 ] . Compared to virtual-fixture/active constraints works [ 16 , 17 , 18 ] we emphasize the novelty of the nonlinear springs in our approach, which are used to perform energy shaping to saturate the control effort; the novelty of the simulated/proxy virtual drill, which allows shaping of the dynamics along the direction of motion; and the novelty of the integration the vision system into the virtual mechanism. In Section II we provide an overview of the functionality of the whole system and it’s constituent parts. Section III discusses in the mathematical methods used for system calibration while Section IV discusses the calibration procedure. Section V explains the controller. We feature results and discussion from a trial of 16 3D printed bones in Section VI and future directions in Section VII . I-A Notation Bold typeface denote vectors (e.g. \bm{p} ). The letter T is used for rigid transforms. Uppercase letters are used for matrices unless otherwise indicated. We will use the notation T^{ab} to represent the rigid transform from frame b to frame a , and superscript to denote the frame of reference an object is represented in e.g. \bm{p}^{b} is the representation of \bm{p} in frame b . The frame abbreviations used throughout the paper are: Frame Abrv. Vision Sensor v Robot r CT Scan s Probe p Frame Abrv. Bone tracker b Measuring rod m Drill tracker d Robot End-Effector e TABLE I: Frame abbreviations. Equation ( 1 ) shows how to apply transform T^{ab} to point \bm{p}^{b} , transforming it to frame a . \displaystyle\bm{p}^{a} \displaystyle=T^{ab}(\bm{p}^{b}) (1) Sometimes we represent transforms as a translation vector \bm{o}^{ab} and a rotation matrix R^{ab} , as shown in.( 2 ). \displaystyle\bm{p}^{a} \displaystyle=R^{ab}\bm{p}^{b}+\bm{o}^{ab} (2) II Overview The goal of our robot-surgeon collaborative system