Mapping the Regulatory Learning Space for the EU AI Act

Dave Lewis, Marta Lasek-Markey, Delaram Golpayegani, Harshvardhan J Pandit · 2025

Read Mapping the Regulatory Learning Space for the EU AI Act by Dave Lewis, Marta Lasek-Markey, Delaram Golpayegani, Harshvardhan J Pandit (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-05787.txt.

Introduction

Dave Lewis and co-authors map the regulatory learning space for the EU AI Act in a 2025 paper. The Act is the first transnational AI law with real enforcement, extending product safety logic to rights protection across sectors.

Enforcement will face many uncertainties, and AI shifts fast, so regulators must learn quickly and broadly. The authors define a parameterized learning space drawn from the Act text. Layered arenas let oversight bodies, firms in the value chain, and affected people interact. Each arena applies technical, organizational, and legal measures and feeds lessons back. Open data policies in the EU could be adapted to speed that learning. The paper frames regulation as a learning system.

Catalog record

CREATORDave Lewis, Marta Lasek-Markey, Delaram Golpayegani, Harshvardhan J Pandit
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-05787

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Mapping the Regulatory Learning Space for the EU AI Act Dave Lewis, Marta Lasek-Markey, Delaram Golpayegani, Harshvardhan J Pandit Abstract The EU AI Act represents the world’s first transnational AI regulation with concrete enforcement measures. It builds on existing EU mechanisms for regulating health and safety of products but extends them to protect fundamental rights and to address AI as a horizontal technology across multiple application sectors. We argue that this will lead to multiple uncertainties in the enforcement of the AI Act, which coupled with the fast-changing nature of AI technology, will require a strong emphasis on comprehensive and rapid regulatory learning for the Act. We define a parametrised regulatory learning space based on the provisions of the Act and describe a layered system of different learning arenas where the population of oversight authorities, value chain participants, and affected stakeholders may interact to apply and learn from technical, organisational and legal implementation measures. We conclude by exploring how existing open data policies and practices in the EU can be adapted to support rapid and effective regulatory learning. Introduction Advances in research on fairness, accountability and transparency of algorithms has normalised approaches towards achieving ethical and trustworthy AI in response to societal concerns and risks posed. Where recent surveys regarding trustworthy AI guidelines demonstrate a high degree of consensus on common principles, including human rights and agency, privacy, non-discrimination, safety and robustness, transparency and accountability ( Hagendorff 2020 ; Jobin, Ienca, and Vayena 2019 ; Fjeld et al. 2020 ; Corrêa et al. 2023 ) , others argue that such a consensus on principles is not reflected in their implementation and raises new forms of avoidance. For instance, using techno-centric approaches such as differential privacy and explainable AI to avoid external inspection of AI design decisions and association with ethical dilemmas and affected stakeholders ( Palladino 2023 ) , or where such principles often represent “ethics washing” as a distraction from harmful behaviour ( Schultz, Conti, and Seele 2024 ) . In addition, uncertainty about the implementation of ethical AI principles is magnified by the rate at which new risks emerge due to the accelerating pace of technological advancement and adoption such as with Large Language Models (LLMs) and Generative AI (GenAI) ( Grace et al. 2024 ) . The AI Act, first proposed in April 2021 and which entered into force in August 2024, makes the EU the first jurisdiction to regulate AI technologies ( AI Act ) . The Act takes a risk-based approach modelled on the existing EU scheme, known as the New Legislative Framework (NLF), for harmonising product health and safety legislation across the EU internal market ( Mazzini and Scalzo 2023 ) . Thus, the AI Act benefits from established rules and practices for product regulation laid out in the so-called “Blue Guide” ( European Commission, Directorate-General for Internal Market, Industry, Entrepreneurship and SMEs 2022 ) . The legislative process preceding the adoption of the Act eloquently demonstrated the technology pacing problem. As powerful classes of General Purpose AI (GPAI) threatened to evade enforcement under the NLF, which is predicated on products with a specific purpose, new provisions had to be introduced to handle the parallel advances in LLMs and GenAI. Market actors, regulators and civil society now have a concrete timetable within which the many remaining uncertainties in enforcing provisions of the Act present a substantial challenge ( kaizenner 2024 ; Keber, Schwartmann, and Zenner 2024 ) . In this paper, we focus on two major areas of uncertainty arising from novelties that the AI Act brings to the NLF. Firstly, the AI Act expands the scope seen in current legislation harmonised under the NLF from protection of health and safety to include protection of fundamental rights. Secondly, the AI Act attempts to regulate AI as a horizontal technology using enforcement mechanisms that are conducted on a sectoral basis under the NLF, i.e. for specific classes of products such as the Medical Device Regulation (MDR) ( Medical Devices Regulation ) . We contend that given the regulatory uncertainties, pace of technological progress, and the relative immaturity of AI risk assessments and mitigations, the Act should in the first instance serve as a framework for learning the appropriate technical, organisational and regulatory measures which then shape future regulatory and technical progress. We therefore argue that a key benefit of the AI Act is the motivation to mobilise resources to resolve and build consensus on these uncertainties in a way that addresses existing and future AI risks in an efficient and legitimate manner. We phrase this gain of knowledge as ‘learnings’. To identify such learnings, we analyse the primary uncertainties arising from the AI Act and define ‘learning arenas’ that are useful to structure and maximise the shared efficiency of learnings under the current complex structures defined in the Act. We conclude with concrete recommendations on how to improve the information flow between actors across learning arenas for accelerating shared learning and to better respond to the pace of advances in AI. Fundamental Rights and Legal Uncertainties This paper argues that regulatory learning in the context of the AI Act should begin, at the most general level, by adequately identifying the role of fundamental rights and addressing issues related to the so-called direct effect of EU law. This section will briefly outline the three sources of fundamental rights protection in the EU with particular focus on issues with direct effect of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights (CFR). It will then consider the application of the Charter to the AI Act. As EU integration progressed over the years, so did protection of fundamental rights. Consequently, within the EU legal order, there is currently no single uniform source of fundamental rights protection ( Spaventa 2018 ) . Instead, Article 6 TEU identifies three sources thereof, in chronological order: 1) constitutional traditions shared by the Member States; 2) the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (ECHR), which all EU Member States are parties to but the European Union is not; and 3) the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. The latter has been gaining in importance since the Treaty of Lisbon’s entry into force (2009), however, the scope of application of the Charter is limited by its so-called horizontal provisions, particularly Article 51. With Lenaerts, we note that the CFR rights are “addressed to the institutions, bodies, offices and agencies of the Union with due regard for the principle of subsidiarity and to the Member States only when they are implementing Union law” ( Lenaerts 2012 ) . Therefore, while the provisions of the Charter bind the EU itself and the Member States, and this has been particularly evident in policymaking, its impact in litigation has been limited due to issues with direct effect of the Charter ( Frantziou 2015 ; Frantziou 2019 ) . To be capable of direct effect, i.e. to create rights for individuals, a provision of EU law must fulfil the following three conditions laid down in the CJEU case 26/62 Van Gend en Loos : it must be 1) clear, 2) precise and 3) unconditional and, therefore, not require any further implementing measures. In relation to CFR rights, the

Read the complete text