Joint graphical model estimation using Stein-type shrinkage for fast large scale network inference in scRNAseq data
Duong H.T. Vo, Nelofer Syed, Thomas Thorne · 2025
Read Joint graphical model estimation using Stein-type shrinkage for fast large scale network inference in scRNAseq data by Duong H.T. Vo, Nelofer Syed, Thomas Thorne (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-05448.txt.
Introduction
Duong Vo, Nelofer Syed, and Thomas Thorne propose a fast joint graphical model method for single cell RNA data. Graphical models reveal conditional links between genes. Joint models estimate networks across several related conditions at once, which exposes shared and distinct structure, a prized view in genomics and neuroscience.
Existing joint methods rely on penalties or on Bayesian priors. The new framework, JointStein, uses two target linear shrinkage of covariance matrices with formulas for optimal shrinkage strength. Simulations show it scales to large single cell datasets. Applied to glioblastoma data, it uncovers dynamic shifts in T cell network structure across disease stages. The method offers a fast alternative for large network inference tasks.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Duong H.T. Vo, Nelofer Syed, Thomas Thorne |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-05448
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Joint graphical model estimation using Stein-type shrinkage for fast large scale network inference in scRNAseq data Duong H.T. Vo, Nelofer Syed, Thomas Thorne Abstract Graphical modeling is a widely used tool for analyzing conditional dependencies between variables and traditional methods may struggle to capture shared and distinct structures in multi-group or multi-condition settings. Joint graphical modeling (JGM) extends this framework by simultaneously estimating network structures across multiple related datasets, allowing for a deeper understanding of commonalities and differences. This capability is particularly valuable in fields such as genomics and neuroscience, where identifying variations in network topology can provide critical biological insights. Existing JGM methodologies largely fall into two categories: regularization-based approaches, which introduce additional penalties to enforce structured sparsity, and Bayesian frameworks, which incorporate prior knowledge to improve network inference. In this study, we explore an alternative method based on two-target linear covariance matrix shrinkage. Formula for optimal shrinkage intensities is proposed which leads to the development of JointStein framework. Performance of JointStein framework is proposed through simulation benchmarking which demonstrates its effectiveness for large-scale single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) data analysis. Finally, we apply our approach to glioblastoma scRNA-seq data from [ 20 ] , uncovering dynamic shifts in T cell network structures across disease progression stages. The result highlights potential of JointStein framework in extracting biologically meaningful insights from high-dimensional data. I Introduction The introduction of single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNAseq) using high-throughput next-generation DNA sequencing (NGS) transformed transcriptomic research by providing data at a higher resolution with information on cellular states and the molecular interactions of individual cells [ 27 ] . The development of scRNAseq has allowed researchers to collect transcriptomic information from more than 20,000 genes from more than 10,000 cells in one experiment [ 8 ] . This requires computational methods that support big data analysis while maintaining performance in inference processes such as network estimation. Gene network inference is one of the active research fields where computational biologists aim to extract interaction information between genes or their products. These networks can include DNA-protein interaction, protein-protein interaction or gene regulatory network. In the studies Pearson or Spearman correlation tests are often used to build correlation matrices which contribute to the construction of gene co-expression networks. However, these tests fail to exclude indirect correlations between variables under third-party effects [ 29 ] . Graphical modeling instead records conditional independencies between random variables in a connectivity graph [ 1 ] . To extract direct connections between variables in graphical modeling, the partial correlation matrix is often used. Multiple methods have been developed for graphical modeling under the assumption of high sparsity in the final network [ 18 , 2 , 3 ] . Joint graphical modeling, an extension to standard graphical models, collates a common network structure from other related networks to improve the overall performance of network inference compared to separate estimation [ 5 ] . Joint graphical modeling acts on multiple groups of observations for a common set of variables, learning a specific network for each set of observations. In the case of biological network inference, joint network estimation supports the identification of conserved networks between different biological groups, whilst also highlighting specific edges in each group. Its application in biology has been highlighted in a protein signaling pathway study [ 30 ] . Multiple approaches have been developed for modeling joint network structures, including regularization and Bayesian methods. In this study, the application of two-target linear covariance matrix shrinkage (TTLS) as a new approach to joint graphical modeling is explored. TTLS method extends Stein-type linear shrinkage, an approach in standard graphical modeling that does not incorporate joint estimation. Instead, it separately estimates the covariance matrix for each group which ensures independent shrinkage within distinct subsets of data. Stein-type covariance shrinkage has been widely use to shrink the sample covariance matrix towards the identity matrix [ 7 ] . In TTLS, rather than shrinking the sample covariance to the identity matrix, the sample covariance matrix is shrunk towards a shared covariance matrix containing information on the common network structure shared between all groups. With the rapid pace of development in single-cell RNA sequencing technology, inference methods able to perform joint graphical modeling on large-scale datasets are becoming increasingly important. In this study, TTLS is implemented in a framework we refer to as JointStein , which is designed for large-scale joint graphical model inference. JointStein is benchmarked against current joint graphical modeling approaches in terms of performance and computational time. We also apply JointStein to joint network inference in experimental data from glioblastoma and Plasmodium falciparum scRNAseq data [ 20 , 19 ] . II Methods II-A Overview of joint graphical model estimation Graphical modeling allows us to extract conditional dependence and independence relationships between random variables [ 1 ] . Conditional independency is defined as the case where the joint probability of two variables X and Y conditional on a third variable Z can be rewritten as: P(X,Y|Z)=P(X|Z)P(Y|Z) (1) This states that given knowledge of Z , the two variables X and Y are independent of one another. Gaussian Graphical Models (GGMs) are used to describe the conditional dependence structure among multiple Gaussian-distributed variables [ 1 ] . In these models, edges between nodes represent direct interactions, as captured by the nonzero elements of the precision matrix, after adjusting for the influence of all other variables [ 1 ] . One popular approach for Gaussian graphical modeling is through estimating the partial correlation matrix by inverting the unknown and nonsingular population covariance matrix \Sigma [ 1 ] . The population covariance matrix \Sigma is often estimated from the sample covariance matrix S . The implementation of graphical models for real-world network inference has been proposed in various fields such as biology, economy and finance [ 1 ] , and in most cases, the underlying network is assumed to be sparse. To induce sparsity in the network and overcome the large p small n challenge, in which sample covariance matrix S becomes singular, various different methods of graphical model inference have been developed. These include minimizing the negative log-likelihood with L_{1} regularization, and shrinking the sample covariance matrix S towards the identity matrix [ 2 , 3 , 4 ] . An extension to standard graphical modeling is the application of joint graphical modeling, as the presence of a partially shared network structure, allowing information sharing between related data sets, has been shown to boost the power of network inference, especially in high-dimensional data analysis [ 5 ] . The idea of joint graphical modeling is illustrated in Figure 1 . Specifically, in heterogeneous data when multiple related groups are present, joint estimation aims to borrow and extract a common network structure between all of the groups. Then individual graphs containing some of the shared structure, but also unique group specific edges can be inferred. This allows us to identify network edges that are shared across multiple groups, while also allowing distinct connections in individual groups. In the case of gene network inference, joint estimation can reveal both core and discrete genetic network structures in different environments or cell types [ 6 ] . Fig. 1: Joint estimation of related networks. The shared network between groups is