Characterization of the spectra of rotating truncated gas planets and inertia-gravity modes

Maarten V. de Hoop, Sean Holman, Alexei Iantchenko · 2025

Read Characterization of the spectra of rotating truncated gas planets and inertia-gravity modes by Maarten V. de Hoop, Sean Holman, Alexei Iantchenko (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-05428.txt.

Introduction

Maarten de Hoop, Sean Holman, and Alexei Iantchenko map the vibration spectrum of a rotating gas giant. The equations for a spinning ball of gas held by its own gravity support two kinds of modes: sound-like acoustic modes and inertia-gravity modes shaped by rotation and buoyancy. The essential spectrum belongs to the second kind.

Under stated boundary conditions, the authors pin down that spectrum with rigor and precision, showing how it separates from the acoustic part. The proof leans on a generalized Helmholtz decomposition and on boundary conditions of Lopantinskii type. Such spectra underpin attempts to read a planet's interior from how it rings.

Catalog record

CREATORMaarten V. de Hoop, Sean Holman, Alexei Iantchenko
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE95 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-05428

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Characterization of the spectra of rotating truncated gas planets and inertia-gravity modes Maarten V. de Hoop, Sean Holman, Alexei Iantchenko Abstract We study the essential spectrum, which corresponds to inertia-gravity modes, of the system of equations governing a rotating and self-gravitating gas planet. With certain boundary conditions, we rigorously and precisely characterize the essential spectrum and show how it splits from the portion of the spectrum corresponding to the acoustic modes. The fundamental mathematical tools in our analysis are a generalization of the Helmholtz decomposition and the Lopantinskii conditions. 1 Introduction We characterize the spectrum of rotating gas planets with a nonvanishing surface density, which we will call truncated, and the spectral component associated with fluid (outer) cores of rotating terrestrial planets. In the case of a polytropic model, truncation yields such a nonvanishing surface density. As commonly done, we assume the absence of viscosity of the fluid. We focus on determining the essential spectrum associated with gravito-inertial (gi) modes, in addition to the discrete spectrum associated with acoustic (p) modes, starting from the acoustic-gravitational system of linear equations for seismology supplemented with appropriate boundary conditions in a rotating reference frame. That is, in the case of gas planets we impose a vanishing (Lagrangian) pressure boundary condition. We do not impose incompressibility as the fluid does support acoustic modes. (We note that inertia-gravity modes in fluid cores of terrestrial planets are sometimes referred to as undertones [ 14 ] .) While gravity modes owe their existence to a buoyancy force and inertial modes use Coriolis force as the restoring force, the inertia-gravity spectrum is controlled by both the Coriolis and buoyancy forces. For the characterization of the spectra we introduce a modification of the classical Helmholtz decomposition and Leray projector (with range reminiscent of the anelastic approximation) while assuming “general” spatial variability in the parameters such as density of mass and Brunt-Väisälä frequency. Related work to the study of inertia-gravity modes, which we will discuss below, has taken the linearized hydrodynamics equations as a point of departure. Assuming an incompressible fluid and homogeneity, inertial waves were studied in a rotating sphere of fluid in the laboratory [ 27 , 3 ] . Kudlick [ 32 ] found an implicit solution for the eigenfrequencies of the inertial modes of a contained fluid spheroid, and Greenspan [ 28 ] calculated a pure point dense spectrum for the Poincaré’s problem (called so after Cartan [ 7 ] who followed Poincaré’s paper [ 38 ] ) for cylindrical and spherical configurations. Bryan [ 6 ] was the first to give the eigenfrequencies of an incompressible axisymmetric ellipsoid including surface gravity waves. However, in the present work we do not consider the incompressible case. Ralston [ 41 ] studied the spectrum of the generator of the group of motions of an inviscid fluid in a slowly rotating container, and of axisymmetric motions of a large rotating ring of fluid. He presented a family of examples exhibiting various mixtures of continuous and point spectra for this case. Colin de Verdière and Vidal [ 12 ] reproved the fact, due to Backus and Rieutord [ 5 ] , that the Poincaré operator in ellipsoids admits a pure point spectrum with polynomial eigenfunctions. (Rapidly rotating fluid masses are usually ellipsoidal at the leading order [ 8 ] because of centrifugal forces and, possibly, tidal interactions due to orbital partners.) They then showed that the eigenvalues of this operator restricted to polynomial vector fields of fixed degree admit a limit repartition given by a probability measure that they construct explicitly. In this context, we mention the work by Ivers [ 31 ] on the enumeration, orthogonality and completeness of the incompressible Coriolis modes in a tri-axial ellipsoid, and the work by Maffei, Jackson and Livermore [ 35 ] on the characterization of columnar inertial modes in rapidly rotating spheres and spheroids. A WKBJ formalism, under the assumption of a spherically symmetric structure, for inertial modes in rotating bodies and a comparison with numerical results were developed by Ivanov and Papaloizou [ 30 ] . We mention the work by Rieutord and Noui [ 42 ] studying the analogy between gravity modes and inertial modes in spherical geometry and the work by Dintrans, Rieutord, and Valdettaro [ 19 ] on gravito-inertial waves in a rotating stratified sphere or spherical shell. Vidal and Colin de Verdière [ 13 ] studied the inertia-gravity oscillations that can exist within pancake-like geophysical vortices; they considered a fluid enclosed within a triaxial ellipsoid which is stratified in density with a constant Brunt-Väisälä frequency. Results of the present work include the case considered in [ 13 ] if we replace the gravitational field of a planet by an externally imposed gravitational field on a rotating fluid. Studies of internal oscillations and inertia-gravity modes specifically pertaining to the Earth’s fluid (outer) core, (again) with simple models, with different boundary conditions date back to the work of Olson [ 37 ] and Friedlander [ 23 ] . (Before that, Friedlander and Siegmann had studied internal oscillations in a contained rotating stratified fluid [ 24 ] and in a rotating stratified fluid in an arbitrary gravitational field [ 25 ] . Seyed-Mahmoud, Moradi, Kamruzzaman and Naseri [ 45 ] studied numerically axisymmetric compressible and stratified fluid core models with different stratification parameters in order to study the effects of the core’s density stratification on the frequencies of some of the inertia-gravity modes of this body. WKB asymptotics of inertia-gravity modes – as well as the ray dynamics including attractors where these modes concentrate or exhibit some singularities – specifically pertaining to axisymmetric stars (but gas planets alike) without rigid boundaries were developed by Prat et al. [ 39 , 40 ] . Colin de Verdière and Saint-Raymond [ 11 ] investigated spectral properties of 0 th order pseudodifferential operators under natural dynamical conditions motivated by the study of (linearized) internal waves on tori. Dyatlov and Zworski [ 21 ] provided proofs of their results based on the analogy to scattering theory. Here, we depart from assumptions invoking symmetry or homogeneity, when the component of the spectrum associated with inertia-gravity modes is no longer pure point or everywhere dense, and aim to characterize the essential spectrum in generality, starting from the full acoustic-gravitational system of (linear) equations supplemented with appropriate boundary conditions in a rotating reference frame. Indeed, the main challenge in the analysis is honoring the boundary conditions. We will not rely on any knowledge of expressions for the modes (generalized eigenfunctions), while this knowledge was essential in many of the works referenced above. In pioneering work, Valette [ 48 , 49 ] presented an initial characterization of the spectrum on similar grounds. We build this, providing a mathematical description of the essential spectrum. In particular, we prove that the essential spectrum has no contributions away from the real and imaginary axes, and the portions on the axes are bounded within a certain region. Our method begins with decomposition into a component with zero dynamic pressure and a corresponding potential component. Using the Schur complement as in [ 47 ] , we see that this decomposition naturally splits the spectrum into one portion that can be associated with acoustic

Read the complete text