Resonant Drag Instabilities for Polydisperse Dust

Sijme-Jan Paardekooper, Hossam Aly · 2025

Read Resonant Drag Instabilities for Polydisperse Dust by Sijme-Jan Paardekooper, Hossam Aly (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-05359.txt.

Introduction

Sijme-Jan Paardekooper and Hossam Aly wrote this paper in two thousand twenty-five. It asks whether a fast drag instability of dust in gas survives when the grains come in many sizes, not just one.

Drifting dust can lock onto a passing gas wave and swell fast, even when dust is scarce. This acoustic form may stir AGB star winds and supernova wreckage. The team solves the flow laws for a spread of grain sizes at low dust loads. The growth then slows from a square-root pace to a plain one. The fastest short waves of the one-size case are damped out. The instability still grows, but at a gentler rate, and the math turns from singular to regular.

Catalog record

CREATORSijme-Jan Paardekooper, Hossam Aly
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE62 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-05359

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Resonant Drag Instabilities for Polydisperse Dust Sijme-Jan Paardekooper, Hossam Aly Abstract Context. Dust grains embedded in gas flow give rise to a class of hydrodynamic instabilities that can occur whenever there exists a relative velocity between gas and dust. These instabilities have predominantly been studied for single grain sizes, for which a strong interaction can be found between drifting dust and a travelling gas wave, leading to fast-growing perturbations (growth rates ∝ μ \propto\sqrt{\mu} ) even at small dust-to-gas ratios μ \mu . They are called resonant drag instabilities. We focus on the acoustic resonant drag instability, which is potentially important in AGB star outflows, around supernova remnants and star clusters in starburst galaxies. Aims. We study the acoustic resonant drag instability, taking into account a continuous spectrum of grain sizes, to determine whether it survives in the polydisperse regime and how the resulting growth rates compare to the monodisperse case. Methods. We solve the linear equations for a polydisperse fluid for the acoustic drag instability, focusing on small dust-to-gas ratios. Results. Size distributions of realistic width turn the fast-growing perturbations ∝ μ \propto\sqrt{\mu} of the monodisperse limit into slower growing perturbations ∝ μ \propto\mu due to the fact that the backreaction on the gas involves an integration over the resonance. Furthermore, the large wave numbers that grow fastest in the monodisperse regime are stabilized by a size distribution, severely limiting the growth rates in the polydisperse regime. Conclusions. The acoustic resonant drag instability turns from a singularly perturbed problem in μ \mu in the monodisperse limit into a regular perturbation for a sufficiently wide size distribution. It can still grow exponentially in the polydisperse regime, but at a slower pace compared to the single size case. I. The Acoustic Resonant Drag Instability 1 Introduction Visible matter in the universe consists mostly of gas, 0.99 being the canonical fraction ( Draine et al. 2007 , see e.g.) . The remaining 1\% is in solid form, and consists of particles of various sizes, from sub-micron size to planetary size, that are often mixed with the gas. Examples of dusty gas flows include AGB star winds ( Höfner & Olofsson 2018 ) , the interstellar medium ( Draine 2003 ) , and protoplanetary discs ( Bae et al. 2023 ) . The dust component can play an important role in the chemistry and opacity of the mixture, for example, but also in its dynamics. In particular, adding dust to a gas in an otherwise stable configuration can make the system go hydrodynamically unstable. One particular class of instabilities in gas-dust mixtures are the so-called Resonant Drag Instabilities ( Squire & Hopkins 2018a ; Squire & Hopkins 2018b , RDIs, see) . These instabilities rely on the fact that gas and dust are usually drifting relative to each other. If a wave in the gas can propagate at the same velocity as the drift velocity of the dust, the result is often a very strong instability that grows fast even if the total amount of dust is very small ( Squire & Hopkins 2018b ) . Of particular interest is the Streaming Instability ( Youdin & Goodman 2005 , SI,) , which can play an important role in planet formation, and was shown to be an inertial wave RDI ( Squire & Hopkins 2018a ; Zhuravlev 2019 ; Magnan et al. 2024b ) . If the system of interest allows for different gas waves, different types of RDI can manifest, such as the acoustic RDI ( Hopkins & Squire 2018 ) or RDIs in magnetized gas ( Hopkins et al. 2020 ) . Dust drift speeds usually depend on particle size. When accelerated for example due to gravity, dust particles will eventually reach an equilibrium terminal velocity where the acceleration is balanced by (size-dependent) gas drag. The smallest particles, tightly coupled to the gas, will drift slowest, while larger particles will drift faster. Since RDIs rely on the drift speed being equal to the gas wave speed, it is natural to ask what happens to an RDI when there is a distribution of dust sizes, and therefore a distribution of drift velocities. In this paper we focus on the acoustic resonant drag instability. This instability occurs in systems where drift is fast enough to couple to sound waves, and where magnetic forces are subdominant ( Hopkins et al. 2022 , see figure 2 of ) . A recent physical picture of the acoustic RDI was presented in Magnan et al. (2024a) . The instability occurs for example in dust-driven outflows, where radiation pressure drives dust particles away from AGB stars ( Höfner & Olofsson 2018 , e.g.) , around supernova remnants ( Micelotta et al. 2018 ) , or around star clusters in starburst galaxies ( Menon et al. 2023 ) . The nonlinear outcome of the acoustic RDI can be virulent turbulence with strong dust clumping ( Moseley et al. 2019 ) . This will have strong implications for the chemistry and opacity in the system ( Seligman et al. 2019 ; Hopkins et al. 2020 , see also) . The purpose of this paper is twofold: first of all, we want to study the linear phase of the acoustic RDI with a dust size distribution for its own sake. In this sense, we are continuing the work of Squire et al. (2022) , who mostly focused on the case where all sizes have the same drift velocity (but see their appendix a3). We will deal exclusively with the case where the drift speed is different for different grain sizes. The second purpose of this paper is to provide a framework for interpreting RDIs in the polydisperse regime. Since the acoustic RDI (hereafter ARDI) is probably the simplest RDI (in terms of physics required as well as the number of spatial dimensions), it lends itself well for this. In a companion paper, we use the framework to deal with more complex cases of the streaming instability ( Youdin & Goodman 2005 ) and settling instability ( Squire & Hopkins 2018b ; Squire & Hopkins 2018a ) , which are likely important in protoplanetary discs during planet formation. The plan of this paper is as follows. We introduce the basic equations in section 2 , where we also define our equilibrium state and derive equations for linear perturbations. Results are presented in section 3 , and we conclude in section 4 . 2 Governing equations The equations governing a mixture of gas and dust, where the dust component consist of a continuum of sizes, were presented in Paardekooper et al. (2021) : \displaystyle\partial_{t}\sigma+\nabla\cdot(\sigma{\bf{u}})= \displaystyle 0, (1) \displaystyle\partial_{t}{\bf{u}}+({\bf{u}}\cdot\nabla){\bf{u}}= \displaystyle\bm{\alpha}_{\rm d}-\frac{{\bf{u}}-{\bf{v}_{\rm g}}}{{\tau_{\rm s}}}. (2) Here, \sigma the size density ( Paardekooper et al. 2020 ) , {\bf u} the size-dependent dust velocity, and {\bf{v}_{\rm g}} the gas velocity. We specialize drag law of the form ({\bf{u}}-{\bf{v}_{\rm g}})/{\tau_{\rm s}} to couple gas and dust, with stopping time {\tau_{\rm s}} ( Woitke & Helling 2003 , see e.g.) . While the stopping time can in principle depend on gas density and |{\bf{u}}-{\bf{v}_{\rm g}}| ( Squire & Hopkins 2018b ) , we will consider only the simple case where the stopping time does not depend on any dynamical

Read the complete text