Performance Comparison of Quantum Otto and Stirling Engines Using Atom-Photon Interactions

Indrajith.V.S · 2025

Read Performance Comparison of Quantum Otto and Stirling Engines Using Atom-Photon Interactions by Indrajith.V.S (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-05314.txt.

Introduction

Indrajith, writing alone, compares two quantum heat engines in a 2025 paper. A heat engine turns heat flow into work, and quantum versions use single atoms and light as their working parts. The two cycles compared are the Otto cycle and the Stirling cycle, each with its own pattern of heating, cooling, and expansion.

Two working setups are studied. One pairs a two-level atom with light in a cavity under a classic interaction model. The other uses a four-level atom in the same kind of cavity. The author traces how key points in each cycle, quantum links between atom and field, and the strength of their coupling shape efficiency and work output. The paper weighs the gains and limits of each design for turning energy at the quantum scale.

Catalog record

CREATORIndrajith.V.S
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-05314

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Performance Comparison of Quantum Otto and Stirling Engines Using Atom-Photon Interactions Indrajith.V.S Abstract This article presents a comparative analysis of quantum Otto and Stirling engines using atom-photon interactions as the working substance. Two models are considered: a two-level Jaynes-Cummings system and a four-level atomic system confined in an optical cavity. The thermodynamic cycles are analyzed, highlighting the role of critical points, quantum correlations, and atom-field interactions in determining efficiency and work output. Our findings provide insights into the advantages and limitations of QHEs, offering a deeper understanding of energy conversion in quantum systems. I Introduction Throughout history, humanity’s progress has been driven by remarkable innovations, with fire and the wheel standing as early milestones. Among these, the development of machines—particularly thermal machines—has played a pivotal role in shaping civilization. The ability to harness and convert heat energy into mechanical work marked the dawn of industrialization, revolutionizing transportation, manufacturing, and energy production. Over centuries, while the materials and mechanisms of these machines have evolved, their fundamental purpose has remained unchanged: the efficient transformation of thermal energy into useful work. Quantum heat engines (QHEs) operate based on quantum mechanical principles, distinguishing them from classical thermal machines. Unlike classical engines, which rely on macroscopic thermodynamic processes, QHEs incorporate uniquely quantum effects such as superposition, coherence, and entanglement, fundamentally altering how energy is transferred and utilized. Since the introduction of the first theoretical model in 1959 ( qhe1 ) , extensive research has led to the development of numerous QHE models, each leveraging different quantum properties to enhance performance. Studies have highlighted several advantages of quantum thermal machines over their classical counterparts qhe2 ; qhe_book ; qhe3 . One of the key factors contributing to this advantage is the role of quantum coherence and entanglement in thermodynamic processes. These quantum correlations can enhance the efficiency and power output of heat engines beyond what is achievable with classical systems adv1 ; adv2 ; adv3 ; adv4 ; adv5 ; adv6 ; adv7 ; adv8 . Remarkably, research has shown that the efficiency of QHEs can even surpass the classical Carnot limit without violating the second law of thermodynamics coh_bath1 ; coh_bath2 ; coh_bath3 ; coh_bath5 ; sq_bath1 ; sq_bath2 ; sq_bath3 ; non_mar_bath1 ; corr_bath1 . This breakthrough is possible due to the exploitation of quantum resources, which modify the traditional constraints imposed by classical thermodynamics. Researchers have developed various quantum heat engine (QHE) models leveraging distinct quantum properties. Coherent thermal baths enhance energy transfer via quantum coherence coh_bath1 ; coh_bath2 ; coh_bath3 ; coh_bath5 , while squeezed thermal baths utilize non-equilibrium states to reduce entropy and boost work extraction sq_bath1 ; sq_bath2 ; sq_bath3 . Non-Markovian dynamics introduce memory effects that sustain coherence and reduce dissipation non_mar_bath1 . Quantum-correlated baths exploit entanglement between thermal reservoirs, enabling additional energy extraction beyond classical limits corr_bath1 . In this article, we present a comparative study of quantum Otto and Stirling engines, employing an atom-photon interaction as the working medium. Specifically, we consider two models: the two-level Jaynes-Cummings system and a four-level atomic system confined within an optical cavity. The interaction of atoms with photons, which facilitates energy exchange and influences thermodynamic cycles, forms the core of our investigation. We systematically analyze the operation of these engines within the Otto and Stirling cycles and compare their performance under different physical conditions. By examining the thermodynamic characteristics of these two systems, we aim to gain deeper insights into the advantages and limitations of quantum thermal machines in harnessing atom-light interactions for energy conversion. II Operation cycles of Quantum heat engine II.1 Working of Stirling engine A Stirling engine operates on a closed-loop thermodynamic cycle known as the Stirling cycle ( Stirling1 ; Stirling2 ; Stirling3 ) . Unlike many other heat engines that rely on continuous combustion processes, the Stirling engine functions by cyclically compressing and expanding a fixed quantity of working substance within a sealed chamber. In contrast, a quantum Stirling engine leverages quantum mechanics by manipulating the quantum states of its working substance, typically atoms or molecules, to optimize energy conversion. The operation of a quantum Stirling engine involves four distinct stages: two isothermal strokes and two isochoric strokes. During the isothermal stroke, the control parameter changes while the temperature remains constant. In contrast, during the isochoric stroke, the control parameter stays consistent. This four-stroke thermal machine can be characterized by the following stages: Stage A \rightarrow B: This constitutes an isothermal stroke, where the temperature is meticulously maintained by coupling the system to a heat bath, allowing the control parameter to vary quasi-statically. It is crucial to note that the system sustains thermal equilibrium with the heat bath throughout this stroke. Simultaneously, the system yields a certain amount of work. The heat exchanged with the hot reservoir is computed as: Q_{AB}=T_{h}(S_{B}-S_{A}), (1) where S_{k} represents the von Neumann entropy of the system. Stage B \rightarrow C : This encompasses an isochoric stroke, characterized by a constant control parameter. In this phase, the system disengages from the hot reservoir and establishes a connection with a cold reservoir. Given the unaltered energy levels, no mechanical work is executed, and the heat exchange is articulated as: Q_{BC}=\sum_{i}E_{Bi}(p_{Ci}-p_{Bi}). (2) Stage C \rightarrow D: In this isothermal compression phase, the system stays in contact with the cold bath, and the control parameter is tuned to revert to the initial state. The exchanged heat is defined as: Q_{CD}=T_{c}(S_{D}-S_{C}). (3) Stage D \rightarrow A: In this concluding stage of isochoric compression, the system transitions from the cold reservoir to being coupled with the hot reservoir, maintaining a constant control parameter at the lower level. The heat exchange is expressed as: Q_{DA}=\sum_{i}E_{Ai}(p_{Ai}-p_{Di}). (4) The total heat absorbed from the hot reservoir is the sum of heat exchanged in stages I and IV, given by Q_{h}=Q_{AB}+Q_{DA} , while Q_{c}=Q_{BC}+Q_{CD} represents the total heat exchanged with the cold reservoir. II.2 Modelling quantum Otto engine The Otto engine functions based on the Otto cycle, a thermodynamic cycle that outlines the process by which the engine transforms energy stored in the working substance into mechanical work. This fundamental operation adheres to the principles of the Otto cycle, encompassing stages such as compression, heating, expansion, and cooling. The quantum Otto engine is characterized by two adiabatic strokes and two isochoric strokes, detailed as follows: Stage a\rightarrow b : The initial stage involves an adiabatic process where the system is prepared at the initial temperature T_{h} , varying the control parameter quasistatically. This raises the energy levels ( E_{a}\rightarrow E_{b} ) while maintaining a constant probability distribution ( p_{a} ), resulting in net work done on the system. Stage b\rightarrow c : Subsequently, an isochoric stage follows, conserving energy levels by keeping the control parameter constant. The system is in contact with the heat source, absorbing heat and causing a change in the probability distribution ( p_{a}\rightarrow p_{b} ). The heat exchange is given by: Q_{h}=U_{c}-U_{b}=\sum_{i}E_{bi}(p_{bi}-p_{ai}). (5) where U represents the internal energy of the system. Stage c\rightarrow d : In the subsequent adiabatic compression, the control parameter is decreased back to its initial value. This leads to a decrease in energy levels ( E_{b}\rightarrow E_{a} )with the probability distributions remaining constant, thus resulting in no work done. Stage d\rightarrow

Read the complete text