An Oasis in the Brown Dwarf Desert: Confirmation of Two Low-mass Transiting Brown Dwarfs Discovered by TESS
Elina Y. Zhang, Theron W. Carmichael, Daniel Huber, Keivan G. Stassun, Akihiko Fukui, Norio Narita, Felipe Murgas, Enric Palle, David W. Latham, Michael L. Calkins, Sara Seager, Joshua N. Winn, Michael Vezie, Rebekah Hounsell, Hugh P. Osborn, Douglas A. Caldwell, Jon M. Jenkins · 2025
Read An Oasis in the Brown Dwarf Desert: Confirmation of Two Low-mass Transiting Brown Dwarfs Discovered by TESS by Elina Y. Zhang, Theron W. Carmichael, Daniel Huber, Keivan G. Stassun, Akihiko Fukui, Norio Narita, Felipe Murgas, Enric Palle, David W. Latham, Michael L. Calkins, Sara Seager, Joshua N. Winn, Michael Vezie, Rebekah Hounsell, Hugh P. Osborn, Douglas A. Caldwell, Jon M. Jenkins (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-05115.txt.
Introduction
Elina Zhang and co-authors confirm in 2025 two brown dwarfs that cross the faces of their stars. Brown dwarfs sit between stars and planets in mass, so each well measured case helps map how objects change across that range. Both finds came from a space telescope that watches for tiny dips in starlight.
The two dwarfs have similar masses, near thirty times the mass of Jupiter, but quite different ages. The younger one is slightly larger than Jupiter and circles its star in about ten days. The older one is smaller, denser, and faster, with a five-day orbit around an aging star. Models say the younger dwarf is puffed up beyond expectation, while the older one shines less than predicted. The older star also seems spun up by its companion, with its tilt matching the orbit. Such paired cases are rare in a sparse corner of the data.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Elina Y. Zhang, Theron W. Carmichael, Daniel Huber, Keivan G. Stassun, Akihiko Fukui, Norio Narita, Felipe Murgas, Enric Palle, David W. Latham, Michael L. Calkins, Sara Seager, Joshua N. Winn, Michael Vezie, Rebekah Hounsell, Hugh P. Osborn, Douglas A. Caldwell, Jon M. Jenkins |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 58 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-05115
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
An Oasis in the Brown Dwarf Desert: Confirmation of Two Low-mass Transiting Brown Dwarfs Discovered by TESS Elina Y. Zhang, Theron W. Carmichael, Daniel Huber, Keivan G. Stassun, Akihiko Fukui, Norio Narita, Felipe Murgas, Enric Palle, David W. Latham, Michael L. Calkins, Sara Seager, Joshua N. Winn, Michael Vezie, Rebekah Hounsell, Hugh P. Osborn, Douglas A. Caldwell, Jon M. Jenkins Abstract As the intermediate-mass siblings of stars and planets, brown dwarfs (BDs) are vital to study for a better understanding of how objects change across the planet-to-star mass range. Here, we report two low-mass transiting BD systems discovered by TESS, TOI-4776 (TIC 196286578) and TOI-5422 (TIC 80611440), located in an under-populated region of the BD mass–period space. These two systems have comparable masses but different ages. The younger and larger BD is TOI-4776b with 32.0 − 1.8 + 1.9 M Jup 32.0^{+1.9}_{-1.8}\,{\rm M_{Jup}} and 1.018 − 0.043 + 0.048 R Jup 1.018^{+0.048}_{-0.043}\,{\rm R_{Jup}} , orbiting a late-F star about 5.4 − 2.2 + 2.8 5.4^{+2.8}_{-2.2} Gyr old in a 10.4138 ± \pm 0.000014 day period. The older TOI-5422b has 27.7 − 1.1 + 1.4 M Jup 27.7^{+1.4}_{-1.1}\,{\rm M_{Jup}} and 0.815 − 0.026 + 0.031 R Jup 0.815^{+0.031}_{-0.026}\,{\rm R_{Jup}} in a 5.3772 ± \pm 0.00001 day orbit around a subgiant star about 8.2 ± 2.4 8.2\pm 2.4 Gyr old. Compared with substellar mass–radius (M–R) evolution models, TOI-4776b has an inflated radii. In contrast, TOI-5422b is slightly “underluminous” with respect to model predictions, which is not commonly seen in the BD population. In addition, TOI-5422 shows apparent photometric modulations with a rotation period of 10.75 ± \pm 0.54 day found by rotation analysis, and the stellar inclination angle is obtained to be I ⋆ = 75.52 − 11.79 + 9.96 I_{\star}=75.52^{+9.96}_{-11.79} ∘ . Therefore, it is likely that TOI-5422b is spinning up the host star and its orbit is aligned with the stellar spin axis. I Introduction Brown dwarfs (BDs) are defined by mass to be in between low-mass stars and giant planets. The dividing lines between these populations are 11-16 \,{\rm M_{Jup}} [ 65 , deuterium fusion limit,] and 75-80 \,{\rm M_{Jup}} [ 3 , 15 , hydrogen fusion limit,] . As the intermediate-mass siblings of stars and planets, BDs are vital to study for an understanding of the initial mass function, star and planet formation, binary system evolution, and atmosphere of giant planets. How brown dwarfs are formed is still under debate. Two popular theories are star-like formation in molecular clouds via gravitational instability [ 54 , 31 , 38 ] and planet-like formation in protoplanetary disks through core accretion [ 2 , 47 ] . Core accretion is thought to be the dominant mechanisms for less-massive objects up to 4-10 \,{\rm M_{Jup}} [ 61 ] , and gravitational instability favors forming more massive objects. However, there is a likely overlap in the mass ranges for each mechanism. The most massive object with strong evidence to form via core accretion is CWW 89Ab, with 36.5 \,{\rm M_{Jup}} , and it represents the very tail end of the expected mass of the core accretion formation pathway [ 5 ] . Another open question in brown dwarf science is the accuracy of evolutionary models. In particular, the radius of a BD is expected to contract as it ages, since they lack a sustaining mechanism to initiate a mechanism like hydrostatic equilibrium seen in stars. The contraction will be quicker at young ages, and then asymptotically decelerates [ 57 ] . Therefore, the radius for a given BD mass will reach a plateau at ages older than a few Gyr. It is worth to mention that BD will first fuse deuterium in the core at very young ages, causing a temporary increase in radius, but then gradually cool and contract as deuterium in the core exhausts quickly [ 11 ] . BDs are comparable to the size of Jupiter, with a radius range of roughly 0.8 \,{\rm R_{Jup}} to 1.5 \,{\rm R_{Jup}} for BDs transiting main sequence stars (older than 100 Myr). For BD candidates transiting pre-main sequence host stars or particularly young stars less than 100 Myr, larger radii up to 3-5 \,{\rm R_{Jup}} are expected and even observed [ 19 , e.g. RIK 72b;] . Several known BDs have radii that lie far from modeled evolution tracks. A handful of BDs are found to have inflated radius, and they expand the entire mass range from low to high. For the cases of KELT-1b [ 63 ] , GPX-1b [ 6 ] , and TOI-2336b [ 41 ] , the authors argue that irradiation is the cause of inflation. While for ZTF J2020+5033 [ 23 ] and KOI-189b [ 20 ] the argument is that magnetic braking within the brown dwarf might cause the inflation. On the contrary, BDs that is smaller in radius compared to models [ 13 , e.g. TOI-569b;] may be described as “underluminous”, although we don’t technically measure its luminosity. Considering the known BDs that show discrepancies between their radii and model predictions, we need more BD case studies to understand why the discrepancy exists and to improve our substellar evolution models. Transiting BDs provide valuable information on the radius from transit photometry. The radial velocity (RV) method alone provides only a lower mass limit, but when combined with information from transit photometry, this minimum mass M\sin{i} degeneracy can be broken. The TESS (Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite) mission can determine the orbital inclination i from light curves. However, determining the age of BDs is much more difficult than finding their mass and radius. Relatively accurate age estimation can be obtained by measuring the age of sun-like stars the BD transits, as stellar ages are more well-modeled by fitting stellar isochrones. Combining the mass, radius, and age information, transiting BDs are clearly in an advantageous position to test substellar evolutionary models. Previous studies have explored tidal effects between the host star and BD. These tidal interactions can help us understand different formation pathways that may result in the system’s current configuration. For instance, [ 45 ] and [ 29 ] proposed a transition from lower-mass BDs with near circular orbits to more massive BDs with more diverse eccentricity at \sim 42.5\,{\rm M_{Jup}} based on a mass threshold proposed by [ 43 ] . [ 7 ] found that systems with high mass ratios ( M_{BD}/M_{\star}>0.01 ) have a broader eccentricity distribution, so they are more likely to have high eccentricities, while low-mass-ratio systems ( < 0.01) tend to have lower eccentricities. So far there are only six transiting BD systems that have obliquity measured through the Rossiter-McLaughlin observations: CoRoT-3b [ 73 ] , KELT-1b [ 63 ] , WASP-30b [ 74 ] , HATS-70b [ 78 ] , and recently TOI-2533b [ 25 ] and GPX-1b [ 27 ] . Although the sample size is small, it hints that unlike planet companions that can have a diverse range in orbital obliquity, BDs tend to be more aligned with their host stars. The TESS mission has been responsible for the vast majority of new transiting BDs, granting us new perspectives on these objects. Up to now, there are nearly 50 transiting BD system discovered, with more