Accumulation of Charge on an Extremal Black Hole’s Event Horizon
Zachary Gelles, Frans Pretorius · 2025
Read Accumulation of Charge on an Extremal Black Hole’s Event Horizon by Zachary Gelles, Frans Pretorius (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-04881.txt.
Introduction
Zachary Gelles and Frans Pretorius analyze, in a 2025 physics paper, how charge piles up on the horizon of an extreme black hole. The hole is an extremal Reissner-Nordström black hole, charged to its limit. Earlier work found an instability that makes fields grow along such horizons.
Simulating a charged wave field on this fixed background, they found the instability extends to charge itself. With strong enough coupling, the charge density on the horizon settles to a nonzero constant at late times. Special starting data ties the effect to a barely damped mode near the point of charged superradiance. The finding sharpens theory about how extreme black holes respond to charged matter.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zachary Gelles, Frans Pretorius |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 106 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-04881
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Accumulation of Charge on an Extremal Black Hole’s Event Horizon Zachary Gelles, Frans Pretorius Abstract We numerically analyze the behavior of a charged scalar field on a fixed extremal Reissner-Nordström background. We find an extension of the Aretakis instability characterized by an accumulation of charge on the extremal event horizon. In particular, when the electromagnetic coupling to the scalar field is sufficiently large, the charge density on the horizon asymptotes to a nonzero constant at late times. By constructing monochromatic initial data at the onset of charged superradiance, we give evidence supporting the claim that this instability is connected to the presence of a nearly zero-damped mode. Throughout this work, we employ a numerical integration scheme in compactified double-null coordinates, which allows us to capture the asymptotic behavior of the matter at the boundaries of the spacetime. I Introduction Black holes in nature are conjectured to be described by three numbers alone: mass M , electric charge Q , and angular momentum J . Extremal black holes — which satisfy J^{2}/M^{2}+Q^{2}=M^{2} — have drawn considerable interest from physicists and mathematicians alike due to the myriad unique phenomena that arise in this limit. In particular, extremal black holes are not linearly stable to external perturbations, setting them apart from their more stable, sub-extremal counterparts. On a fixed background metric, radial derivatives of massless fields will not decay on the horizon of a maximally charged Reissner-Nordström (RN) black hole [ 1 , 2 ] or a maximally rotating Kerr black hole [ 3 ] — a result known as the Aretakis instability. In order to properly understand the physical consequences of this horizon instability, one must analyze the fully nonlinear problem, evolving any external fields in conjunction with the underlying spacetime geometry. In general, and for the simplest scenario where the perturbation does not involve additional matter fields, this requires solving the coupled Einstein-Maxwell system of equations. This is a challenging problem, in particular since it cannot be addressed in spherical symmetry — where the RN solution describes the relevant extremal black hole — as neither the Einstein equations nor the Maxwell equations permit radiation then. As such, studying the stability of extremal RN black holes in the simplest possible setting requires one to couple to a matter field that has non-trivial dynamics in spherical symmetry. In this paper, we will accordingly take a step back and aim to improve our understanding of the Aretakis instability in spherical symmetry. Specifically, we will numerically analyze an extremal RN black hole subject to perturbation by a spherically symmetric, electrically charged scalar field. Our work is intended to build towards an extension of that of Murata, Reall & Tanahashi (MRT [ 4 ] ), who numerically investigated the non-linear evolution of an uncharged scalar field in the presence of a RN black hole. Introducing an electromagnetic coupling to the scalar field may allow us to draw more explicit connections to the extremal-Kerr problem, in that a charged field will allow evolution of the charge Q of the black hole, in analogy with gravitational radiation (or matter) allowing the angular momentum J to evolve. In that sense, one may consider charged matter incident on an extremal RN black hole to serve as a toy model for rotating matter incident on an extremal Kerr black hole. Charged scalar electrodynamics in the presence of a RN black hole is governed by three sets of equations: the wave equations for the components of the complex scalar field, Maxwell’s equations for the electromagnetic field, and Einstein’s equations for the spacetime geometry. The linearized problem for the scalar field — fixing the background metric and electromagnetic potential — was first investigated for general RN black holes by Hod & Piran [ 5 , 6 , 7 ] and specifically in the extremal limit by Zimmerman [ 8 ] . Zimmerman found that the charged scalar field experiences an enhanced Aretakis instability compared to that of the uncharged scalar field, with radial derivatives growing along the horizon instead of remaining constant. Zimmerman also demonstrated that this enhanced instability can indeed be mapped onto analogous results for linearized perturbations of Kerr [ 9 ] . To date, however, the question of horizon (in)stability of a charged scalar field in spherical symmetry in the fully non-linear regime remains largely unexplored 1 1 1 Note that [ 10 ] did perform a fully non-linear investigation of scalar electrodynamics in curved spacetime, albeit without an analysis of horizon instabilities. Also, [ 11 ] demonstrated that an Aretakis-like instability arises from electromagnetic perturbations of an extremal RN black hole, although it is not specific to the case of the charged scalar field. . Our aim is to eventually tackle this problem. But since including back-reaction presents its own set of challenges in numerical analysis, as a first step here, we focus on evolving the coupled charged scalar/Maxwell system — charged scalar electrodynamics (SED) — on a fixed RN background geometry. Specifically, we implement a new finite difference code based on compactified, double-null coordinates to solve the corresponding partial differential equations. Such a coordinate system is advantageous in that it allows us to reach both the future horizon and future null infinity, ensuring that we capture the correct asymptotic behavior of the charged scalar field at the relevant boundaries of the spacetime. In analyzing the numerical output, we find that charged SED exhibits a plethora of interesting phenomena that are not present in the linearized analysis of Zimmerman [ 8 ] . Indeed, we find that for sufficiently large electromagnetic coupling, the charge density does not decay at late times on the extremal event horizon. This result bears striking resemblance to the uncharged Aretakis instability, for which the energy density does not decay at late times on the extremal horizon [ 11 ] . To help explain this similarity, we derive a novel gauge invariant formulation of Maxwell’s equations from which the asymptotic behavior of the matter fields naturally follows. Finally, we explore the physical origins of the charged Aretakis instability by numerically evolving initial data consisting of a monochromatic wave with frequency precisely at the onset of superradiance. This allows us to test the arguments put forth by [ 8 , 9 , 12 ] concerning the relationship between the enhanced Aretakis instability and a weakly damped mode that coincides with the onset of superradiance at extremality. We find that when an extremal black hole is driven with a wave at this frequency, the resulting scalar field amplitude on the horizon grows monotonically until the amplitude is large enough that the non-linearities of SED mitigate the growth. The rest of this paper is organized as follows. In Section II , we provide an overview of the Reissner-Nordström spacetime and the double-null coordinates we use to cover it. In Section III , we explain how to write scalar electrodynamics as a well-posed initial value problem in spherical symmetry. Readers who are not interested in the details of the formalism can skip to Section IV , where we present the results of our numerical simulations initialized with compactly supported data. In Section V , we explicitly analyze the connection between the Aretakis instability and the onset of superradiance. We