Rapid updating of multivariate resource models based on new information using EnKF-MDA and multi-Gaussian transformation

Sultan Abulkhair, Peter Dowd, Chaoshui Xu, Penny Stewart · 2025

Read Rapid updating of multivariate resource models based on new information using EnKF-MDA and multi-Gaussian transformation by Sultan Abulkhair, Peter Dowd, Chaoshui Xu, Penny Stewart (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-04694.txt.

Introduction

Abulkhair, Dowd, Xu, and Stewart speed up the updating of mine resource models in this 2025 paper. As new drill data arrives, operators must merge it into models of several linked ore variables at once. The standard filter for this job handles one variable at a time and can drift from the readings.

Their method assimilates the same data several times with inflated error bars, and first rotates the data into a bell-shaped form that the filter handles well. On a real case with nine linked variables, updates grew more accurate, uncertainty shrank, and the links between variables survived. The approach suits fast decisions in working mines.

Catalog record

CREATORSultan Abulkhair, Peter Dowd, Chaoshui Xu, Penny Stewart
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-04694

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Rapid updating of multivariate resource models based on new information using EnKF-MDA and multi-Gaussian transformation Sultan Abulkhair, Peter Dowd, Chaoshui Xu, Penny Stewart Abstract Rapid resource model updating with real-time data is important for making timely decisions in resource management and mining operations. This requires optimal merging of models and observations, which can be achieved through data assimilation, and the ensemble Kalman filter (EnKF) has become a popular method for this task. However, the modelled resources in mining usually consist of multiple variables of interest with multivariate relationships of varying complexity. EnKF is not a multivariate approach, and even for univariate cases, there may be slight deviations between its outcomes and observations. This study presents a methodology for rapidly updating multivariate resource models using the EnKF with multiple data assimilations (EnKF-MDA) combined with rotation based iterative Gaussianisation (RBIG). EnKF-MDA improves the updating by assimilating the same data multiple times with an inflated measurement error, while RBIG quickly transforms the data into multi-Gaussian factors. The application of the proposed algorithm is validated by a real case study with nine cross-correlated variables. The combination of EnKF-MDA and RBIG successfully improves the accuracy of resource model updates, minimises uncertainty, and preserves the multivariate relationships. 2025 \nomail \nomail \nomail keywords Ensemble Kalman filter with multiple data assimilations; Rotation based iterative Gaussianisation; Geostatistics; Sensor observations; Reconciliation 1 Introduction Resource modelling is a crucial component of the mining value chain, as it outlines the quantity, quality, and location of mineral resources within a specified area. However, resource models are typically based on limited exploration data collected over a large area, often failing to accurately represent reality. As these models are the foundation for future planning, predictions, and optimisations, their accuracy directly impacts production outcomes. To address potential discrepancies, it is essential to evaluate risks by quantifying the uncertainty associated with the orebody using advanced geostatistical simulation algorithms ( Dowd, 1994 ) . Additionally, collecting more direct measurements during operations can enhance the accuracy and precision of these models. Real-time production data from various sensors can quickly update resource knowledge and inform short-term mine planning decisions. Incorporating these observations into geostatistical models can enhance the accuracy and precision of forecasts. Buxton and Benndorf (2013) suggest that integrating sensor data could reduce uncertainty and deviations from production targets, potentially resulting in an average economic benefit of $5 million per year for the studied deposit. To effectively integrate sensor observations, tools such as the Kalman filter (KF) ( Kalman, 1960 ) and the ensemble Kalman filter (EnKF) ( Evensen, 1994 ) are recommended for the rapid updating of resource and grade control models ( Benndorf, 2015 ; Wambeke and Benndorf, 2017 ) . In addition, Benndorf and Buxton (2016) introduced a real-time mining concept that transforms discontinuous process monitoring into a near-continuous framework through data assimilation (see Figure 1 ). Data assimilation applications extend beyond mineral grade estimates and can also be used to update coal quality parameters ( Yüksel et al, 2016 ) , geometallurgical models ( Wambeke et al, 2018 ) , and compositional data ( Prior et al, 2021b ) . However, current data assimilation methods for quickly updating resource models still have limitations. For instance, the EnKF updates one variable at a time and does not consider multivariate relationships. Furthermore, single data assimilation is often insufficient to fully utilise the information obtained from observations. Figure 1: Real-time mining concept inspired by Benndorf and Buxton (2016) . One practical approach for performing multivariate rapid updating is to transform co-regionalised variables into independent factors before data assimilation. This transformation helps preserve multivariate relationships by back-transforming realisations after updates. Techniques such as the minimum-maximum autocorrelation factors (MAF) ( Desbarats and Dimitrakopoulos, 2000 ) and flow transformation (FA) ( van den Boogaart et al, 2017 ) have been used alongside the EnKF to decorrelate multivariate data before rapid updating ( Kumar et al, 2020 ; Prior et al, 2021b ) . However, MAF is not well-suited for handling complex multivariate relationships, and FA tends to be too slow for adequate rapid updating. In a comparison of various multivariate transformations, Abulkhair et al (2023) found that the projection pursuit multivariate transform (PPMT) ( Barnett et al, 2014 ) and rotation-based iterative Gaussianisation (RBIG) ( Laparra et al, 2011 ) are considerably faster and more appropriate for rapid updating than FA. However, it should be noted that only FA can successfully minimise artefacts in the presence of extreme values, making it a more optimal multi-Gaussian transform, provided that runtime is not important ( Cook et al, 2023 ) . RBIG is similar in its methodology to PPMT, but instead of iteratively searching for interesting projections, it applies orthonormal rotations. As it needs fewer iterations to achieve convergence and each iteration is faster, RBIG is, on average, 90% faster than PPMT when applied to five variables with the number of samples between 10,000 and 50,000 ( Cook et al, 2023 ) . Similar to PPMT and FA, RBIG can be paired with other transforms, such as MAF ( Erten and Deutsch, 2021 ; Abulkhair et al, 2023 ) , log-ratio transforms ( van den Boogaart et al, 2017 ; Prior et al, 2021b ) , and non-logarithmic ratio transforms ( Adeli et al, 2017 ; Bassani et al, 2018 ) . In addition to the EnKF, several other methods have been employed for the rapid updating of resource models, including conditional simulation of successive residuals ( Vargas-Guzmán and Dimitrakopoulos, 2002 ) , direct sequential simulation using point distributions ( Neves et al, 2019 ) , a variation of the KF for downscaling resource models ( Li et al, 2021 ) , and deep reinforcement learning ( Kumar and Dimitrakopoulos, 2022 ) . Most of these methods perform single data assimilation, which can lead to some deviations between predicted and observed values, especially when observations are highly uncertain. To improve data assimilation in highly non-linear situations, iterative forms of EnKF have been widely explored in petroleum engineering and hydrogeology. For instance, ensemble randomised maximum likelihood, also known as iterative EnKF ( Gu and Oliver, 2007 ; Chen and Oliver, 2012 ) , yields better-matching results than standard EnKF, although it requires more computational resources. Alternatively, EnKF with multiple data assimilations (EnKF-MDA) ( Emerick and Reynolds, 2012 ; Emerick and Reynolds, 2013 ) performs multiple data assimilations with an inflated measurement error to significantly outperform single data assimilation methods. While both iterative EnKF and EnKF-MDA are more computationally intensive than standard EnKF, the EnKF-MDA approach typically requires fewer iterations. The effectiveness of EnKF-MDA has been demonstrated in hydrogeology ( Li et al, 2018 ) , petroleum engineering ( Emerick and Reynolds, 2012 ; Emerick and Reynolds, 2013 ) and geophysics ( Liu et al, 2023 ) . However, to our knowledge, EnKF-MDA has yet to be applied to the rapid resource model updating problem in mining. Validating the performance of data assimilation algorithms through real case studies is crucial, especially in the mining industry, where data often show significant variability in terms of spacing between data points, measurement volumes, and associated uncertainties. Several studies of rapid resource model updating have demonstrated the effectiveness of various proposed approaches when applied to real data ( Yüksel

Read the complete text