Characterizing S = 3 / 2 S=3/2 AKLT Hamiltonian with Scanning Tunneling Spectroscopy
M. Ferri-Cortés 1 , J. C. G. Henriques 2,3 , J. Fernández-Rossier 3 · 2025
Read Characterizing S = 3 / 2 S=3/2 AKLT Hamiltonian with Scanning Tunneling Spectroscopy by M. Ferri-Cortés 1 , J. C. G. Henriques 2,3 , J. Fernández-Rossier 3 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-04676.txt.
Introduction
Ferri-Cortés, Henriques, and Fernández-Rossier wrote this 2025 physics paper on testing a prized quantum magnet model with a microscope. The AKLT model describes spins linked in a lattice, and its ground state is a prized resource for a style of quantum computing. Real materials may or may not match the model, and the team ask how a tunneling microscope could tell.
For a simple two-spin unit, they show how current-based spectroscopy, run out of equilibrium, reveals every excited level, fixing both the plain and the curved parts of the spin coupling. For a sheet of spins of size three-halves, they turn to the edge. Loose half-spins dangle there in the ideal model, and their faint signals could betray a true AKLT match.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | M. Ferri-Cortés 1 , J. C. G. Henriques 2,3 , J. Fernández-Rossier 3 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-04676
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Characterizing S = 3 / 2 S=3/2 AKLT Hamiltonian with Scanning Tunneling Spectroscopy M. Ferri-Cortés 1 , J. C. G. Henriques 2,3 , J. Fernández-Rossier 3 Abstract The AKLT Hamiltonian is a particular instance of a general class of model Hamiltonians defined in lattices with coordination z z where each site hosts a spins S = z / 2 S=z/2 , interacting both with linear and non-linear exchange couplings. In two dimensions, the AKLT model features a gap in the spectrum, and its ground state is a valence bond solid state; that is an universal resource for measurement based quantum computing, motivating the quest of physical systems that realize this Hamiltonian. Given a finite-size system described with a specific instance of this general class of models, we address the question of how to asses if such system is a realization of the AKLT model using inelastic tunnel spectroscopy implemented with scanning tunnel microscopy (IETS-STM). We propose two approaches. First, in the case of a dimer, we show how to leverage non-equilibrium IETS-STM to obtain the energies of all excited states, and determine thereby the magnitude of both linear and non-linear exchange interactions. Second, we explore how IETS can probe the in-gap excitations associated to edge spins. In the AKLT limit, spins S = 3 / 2 S=3/2 at the edge of the lattice have coordination 2, giving rise to S = 1 / 2 S=1/2 dangling spins that can be probed with IETS. We propose a S = 1 / 2 S=1/2 effective Hamiltonian to describe the interactions between these dangling spins in the neighborhood of the AKLT point, where their degeneracy lifted. I Introduction Quantum computing hinges on certain quantum states that make it possible to solve a variety of important problems Dalzell et al. 2023 outperforming classical hardware. There are two complementary strategies for the generation of these resourceful quantum states. In the gate-based quantum computing approach, quantum algorithms are a prescribed sequence, most often very long, of quantum gates acting on one and two qubits at a time, starting from an initial unentangled product state. In this strategy, the system is driven out of equilibrium. In measurement-based quantum computing Raussendorf et al. 2003 (MBQC), the initial state is entangled in a special way, that makes it possible to implement quantum algorithms combining single-qubit gates and readouts, without having to use two-qubit gates. Importantly, the ground state of some Hamiltonians, such as the AKLT model in two dimensions Affleck et al. 1987 ; Affleck et al. 1988 , belong to this class of initial entangled states and therefore said to be universal resources Wei et al. 2011 for MBQC. In addition, it was demonstrated that the AKLT model is gapped in two dimensions Pomata and Wei 2020 ; Lemm et al. 2020 . Therefore, if it were possible to engineer a physical system so that it realizes the two-dimensional AKLT model, and at a temperature significantly smaller than the gap, such system would spontaneously provide a very good starting point for MBQC. AKLT models Affleck et al. 1987 ; Affleck et al. 1988 ; Wei et al. 2022 are particular instances of a general class of model Hamiltonians describing spins S=z/2 interacting both with linear and non-linear exchange couplings, in lattices with coordination number z . The wave function of the ground state can be written explicitly as a valence bond solid state: in every physical site, the spin S is represented by means of z virtual spins S=1/2 . At each bond between two physical sites, a singlet is formed between two virtual spins. Furthermore, the wave function is symmetrized at each physical site, to ensure that the z virtual spins 1/2 realize a physical spin S . In systems with periodic boundary conditions, the ground state is unique. In contrast, in systems with boundaries, the edge physical spins have dangling virtual spins, giving rise to a degeneracy of the ground state that can be interpreted in terms of emergent fractional S=1/2 degrees of freedom. This constitutes a canonical example of fractionalization. For spin chains Affleck et al. 1987 , the AKLT model is given by the bilinear-biquadratic (BLBQ) Hamiltonian with S=1 : H_{BLBQ}=J\left(\sum_{i}\vec{S}_{i}\cdot\vec{S}_{i+1}+\beta(\vec{S}_{i}\cdot\vec{S}_{i+1})^{2}\right) (1) with \beta=\frac{1}{3} . The most important properties of the one-dimensional AKLT model are the gap in the excitation spectrum, the symmetry protected topological order Pollmann et al. 2012 and the existence of fractional S=1/2 edge excitations in open-end chains, shared Schollwöck et al. 1996 by the BLBQ family in all points between \beta=0 , the Heisenberg model, and the AKLT point \beta=1/3 . These properties define the Haldane phase and have been observed experimentally in a number of systems, including crystals with decoupled spin chains Hagiwara et al. 1990 , cold-atoms Sompet et al. 2022 and, important for this work, artificial one-dimensional S=1 triangulene lattices Mishra et al. 2021 . Whereas these systems provide a unique arena to explore fractionalization and to test the Haldane prediction Haldane 1983 , the ground state of the Haldane phase of the BLBQ model is a universal resource to implement 1-qubit gates only Wei et al. 2011 and, therefore, they do not provide a viable alternative to gate-based quantum computing. The simplest version of the AKLT model in 2D is realized in a honeycomb lattice Affleck et al. 1988 , where z=3 and S=3/2 . The AKLT is a special instance of the bilinear-biquadratic-bicubic (BLBCBQ) Hamiltonian: H_{BLBQBC}=J_{1}\left(\sum_{\langle i,i^{\prime}\rangle}\sum_{n=1}^{3}\beta_{n}\left(\vec{S}_{i}\cdot\vec{S}_{i^{\prime}}\right)^{n}\right) (2) where i runs over the sites of the lattice, i^{\prime} runs over the first neighbours of i and J_{1} is the magnitude of the linear exchange (we consider \beta_{1}=1 ). The relative magnitude of non-linear exchange couplings is controlled by the parameters \beta_{2},\beta_{3} . The AKLT point Affleck et al. 1988 , for which the AKLT state is the ground state of Hamiltonian ( 2 ), is reached when \beta_{2}=\frac{116}{243},\beta_{3}=\frac{16}{243} . We refer to the region in the \beta_{2},\beta_{3} plane that contains the AKLT point and has the same key properties ( S=0 ground state, gap in the excitation spectrum, fractional edge spins), as the AKLT phase. In contrast with the 1D case, very few papers have explored theoretically the boundaries of the AKLT phase in 2D Ganesh et al. 2011 ; Garcia-Saez et al. 2013 ; Huang et al. 2013 . Also in contrast with the one-dimensional case, so far no physical system has been found that realizes the AKLT phase in two dimensions. Promising physical platforms to make this happen would be multi-orbital Mott insulators Koch-Janusz et al. 2015 and, given the successful precedent of S=1 Haldane chains, lattices of S=3/2 nanographenes Catarina et al. 2023 ; Henriques et al. 2024a . The present work is inspired by the experimental approach that has been successful in the exploration of the 1D Haldane phase both in artificial chains made of S=1 nanographenes Mishra et al. 2021 as well as in the dimerized S=1/2 chains Zhao et al. 2024a . In these works, the use of inelastic electron tunnel spectroscopy (IETS) carried out with scanning tunnel microscope (STM), was instrumental to measure the Haldane gap and the in-gap excitations associated to fractional spins at the edges, as anticipated theoretically Delgado et al. 2013 and, in the S=1