Physical, Empirical, and Conditional Inductive Possibility
Balázs Gyenis · 2025
Read Physical, Empirical, and Conditional Inductive Possibility by Balázs Gyenis (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-04601.txt.
Introduction
Balázs Gyenis presents a 2025 philosophy of physics paper on what it means for a state of affairs to be physically possible. A scholar named Norton split possibility into kinds based on evidence: what data show, what-if setups, and contrary-to-fact cases. Gyenis argues those kinds read odd cases of physical possibility better than the standard view. The standard view itself, he shows, is one special case of a broader logical kind in Norton's frame.
Cases from classical mechanics, relativity, and quantum theory carry the argument. He then folds the three kinds into one notion: conditional inductive possibility, which can come in grades of strength. The frame aims to match how working physicists judge what could be. Modality talk in physics gains a finer set of tools.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Balázs Gyenis |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 77 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-04601
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Physical, Empirical, and Conditional Inductive Possibility Balázs Gyenis Abstract I argue that John Norton’s notions of empirical, hypothetical, and counterfactual possibility can be successfully used to analyze counterintuitive examples of physical possibility and align better with modal intuitions of practicing physicists. First, I clarify the relationship between Norton’s possibility notions and the received view of logical and physical possibility. In particular, I argue that Norton’s empirical, hypothetical, and counterfactual possibility cannot coincide with the received view of physical possibility; instead, the received view of physical possibility is a special case of Norton’s logical possibility. I illustrate my claims using examples from Classical Mechanics, General Relativity, and Quantum Mechanics. I then arrive at my conclusions by subsuming Norton’s empirical, hypothetical, and counterfactual possibilities under a single concept of conditional inductive possibility and by analyzing the types and degrees of strengths that can be associated with it. 1 Introduction Norton, 2022 strongly criticizes modality concepts of the philosophical literature, arguing that examples of metaphysical, epistemic, physical, nomic, and conceptual possibility and necessity can either be subsumed under his concepts of logical and empirical possibility and necessity or are not cogent and cannot be responsibly relied upon. This paper examines the relationship between Norton’s concepts of logical and empirical possibility and the received view of physical possibility. Overall, the paper is supportive of Norton’s analysis: the received view of physical possibility leads to a number of counterintuitive conclusions which, I claim, can be resolved by generalizing Norton’s empirical, hypothetical, and counterfactual possibility as conditional inductive possibility. On the other hand, this paper grew out of a concern that the positive results of Norton’s analysis may be obscured by Norton’s unusual usage of terminology and claims regarding the relationship of his new possibility concepts and that of physical and nomic possibility. Thus I start with a conceptual clarification of the relationship between various modality concepts. Norton, 2022 defines what he means by logical, empirical, hypothetical and counterfactual possibility. However, instead of defining what he means by physical and nomic possibility, Norton makes certain claims about physical and nomic possibility by using his earlier defined concepts of empirical, hypothetical and counterfactual possibility. Since the explicitly stated goal of Norton, 2022 is to evaluate modality concepts of the philosophical literature, the reader may infer that Norton’s claims pertain to physical and nomic possibility as they are traditionally understood in the literature. In the first part I show that this cannot be the case. Norton claims that physical possibility is empirical possibility; however, I argue that this cannot hold if physical possibility is understood according to the received view. I also argue that Norton’s hypothetical or counterfactual possibility cannot coincide with the received view either. A simple illustration of my claims is the following: the statement that the world is completely empty describes a physically possible state of affairs according to most physical theories because it is consistent with the laws of said theories, but it cannot be empirically, hypothetically, or counterfactually possible. This is so because Norton’s empirical, hypothetical, and counterfactual possibilities require positive inductive support, but any statement that is positively inductively supported in Norton’s sense requires material facts pertaining to the actual circumstances on which the inductive support is based, and these material facts imply that the world cannot be entirely empty. Thus, the statement that the world is completely empty provides a straightforward example of a statement describing physically possible states of affairs (in the sense of the received view) which is neither empirically, hypothetically, nor counterfactually possible (in Norton’s sense). A further terminological complication arises because Norton also uses the term logical possibility differently from its usual interpretation in the literature, employing it in a much broader sense. As I argue, this has the consequence that the received view of physical possibility is simply a special case of Norton’s logical possibility. This result also clearly indicates that the received view of physical possibility cannot coincide with any notion of possibility that derives from positive inductive support, as does Norton’s empirical, hypothetical, and counterfactual possibility. After the conceptual clarification I argue that the difference between the received view of physical possibility and empirical possibility works for the benefit of Norton’s analysis: so much worse for the received view. By further developing Norton’s account, I argue that the concept of conditional inductive possibility, which generalizes empirical, hypothetical, and counterfactual possibility, can resolve several counterintuitive conclusions in the philosophy of physics literature regarding what is physically possible. Among my examples are the violation of causality in Classical Mechanics, Gödel’s time travel in General Relativity, and the radical freedom of acting otherwise in Quantum Mechanics. In Section 2 , I review various formulations of physical possibility that appear in the philosophical literature. Section 3 presents three examples in which the received view of physical possibility leads to counterintuitive conclusions. In Section 4 , I review Norton’s material theory of induction and his concepts of logical and empirical possibility. In Section 5 , I demonstrate that a physical possibility of the received view is not an empirical possibility, but that the received view of physical possibility is rather a special case of Norton’s logical possibility. In Section 6 , I compare empirical possibility with the three examples. In Section 7 , I introduce a generalization of Norton’s hypothetical and counterfactual possibility, conditional inductive possibility, examine the relationship between conditional inductive possibility and nomic possibility, and introduce and analyze different degrees of conditional inductive possibility. Section 8 returns once more to the three examples, and analyzes them from the perspective of conditional inductive possibility. The last section summarizes the findings. 2 The Received View of Physical Possibility The received view of physical possibility captures the concept of possibilities permitted by the laws of nature. Various philosophers have formulated this idea in different ways: (1) some define physical possibility in terms of possible worlds ( Earman, 1986 , 13) , others in terms of events or states of affairs ( Maudlin, 2007 , 18) ; (2) some employ modal logic ( Bradley & Swartz, 1979 , 6) , while others use non-modal logic ( Chisholm, 1967 , 412) ; (3) some relativize the concept to the actual world ( Carroll, 1994 , 174) , while others relativize it to theories ( Gyenis, 2020 , 569) . 1 1 endnote: 1 For a detailed review of the various formulations and their different philosophical consequences, see Gyenis, 2020 and its references. The following formulation, which defines the physical possibility of possible worlds in a theory-relative, modal way, is frequently utilized in the practice of philosophers of physics: (p) A possible world is physically possible according to theory T if and only if it is consistent with the physical laws of T . Other typical formulations of physical possibility can be seen as special cases of (p): (1) Using (p) we can specify what we mean by the physical possibility of events or states of affairs: events or states of affairs are physically possible according to theory T if the proposition S that expresses their occurrence is true in at least one world that is physically possible according to theory T . I will use the notation \Diamond^{p}_{T}S for the statement of