Can we disentangle between the emission of an accretion disc around a single black hole and a circumbinary disc ?

Peggy Varniere, Raphaël Mignon-Risse, Fabien Casse · 2025

Read Can we disentangle between the emission of an accretion disc around a single black hole and a circumbinary disc ? by Peggy Varniere, Raphaël Mignon-Risse, Fabien Casse (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-04455.txt.

Introduction

Peggy Varniere, Raphaël Mignon-Risse, and Fabien Casse warn that a lone black hole can masquerade as a merging pair. Their study appeared in twenty twenty-five. Gravitational wave detections launched a hunt for light from binaries before they merge, and simulations promised a pulsing lump as the telltale.

The lump, a bright clump orbiting at the disc's edge, also forms around single holes through a natural instability. The team fit single-hole models to synthetic binary observations across separations and mass ratios. Good fits turned up again and again, with shifted masses, distances, or disc edges. One signal resisted mimicry: two clocks at once, the lump's beat against the binary's. Only that double rhythm, they argue, should qualify a candidate.

Catalog record

CREATORPeggy Varniere, Raphaël Mignon-Risse, Fabien Casse
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-04455

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Can we disentangle between the emission of an accretion disc around a single black hole and a circumbinary disc ? Peggy Varniere, Raphaël Mignon-Risse, Fabien Casse Abstract The detection of gravitational waves from binary black holes (BBHs) started the hunt for their pre-merger electromagnetic emission. In that respect, numerical simulations have been looking for the ‘smoking gun’ signal that could help identify pre-merger systems. Here we study if any of the expected features of circumbinary discs, such as the periodic modulation from the orbiting ‘lump’, could be used to identify pre-merger BBHs or if they could be easily confused with other systems. Indeed, while the timing feature associated with the ‘lump’ seems to be present for a large part of the parameter space defined by the binary separation and mass ratio in circular binaries, it was recently proposed to form thanks to an instability occurring naturally at the edge of accretion discs around single black holes (SBH). In order to check if features of a circumbinary disc could be reproduced by a SBH system, we search for at least one SBH fit able to replicate the given synthetic observations of a circumbinary disc. We found that many of the features from a circumbinary disc can be reproduced by a SBH system with different masses, distances or inner disc positions. Interestingly, while we can always find a SBH model providing a good enough fit to the data, the presence of two variabilities, associated with the lump and the binary, or binary-lump beat, period, is a necessary condition for a wide range of BBH system parameters and should be used as a test to disqualify some BBH candidates. Can we disentangle between the emission of an accretion disc around a single black hole and a circumbinary disc ? – 1 Introduction The detection of gravitational waves (GW) from the merger of compact objects and their electromagnetic counterparts has opened a new era of multi-messenger astronomy both in observations ( Abbott et al., 2017 ; Graham et al., 2020 ) but also in numerical simulations as they are currently the only way to constrain what observables would help us detect a BBH system before or during the early stage of gravitational wave detection. The major part of the numerical studies of pre-merger binary black-holes (BBHs) is looking at the system between the moment a circumbinary disc is formed down to the merger ( Gold, 2019 ; D’Orazio & Charisi, 2023 , e.g. reviews by) . Those numerical studies converged toward a system where the circumbinary disc is feeding the individual black holes through two streams which might form some intermittent disc-like structures around each black hole ( MacFadyen & Milosavljević, 2008 ; Shi et al., 2012 ; Noble et al., 2012 ; D’Orazio et al., 2013 ; Gold et al., 2014 ; Shi & Krolik, 2015 ; Armengol et al., 2021 ; Tiede et al., 2021 ; Liu, 2021 ) . One of the most interesting features is the presence of a strong m=1 azimuthal mode at the inner edge of the circumbinary disc leading to an overdensity that was dubbed ‘lump’ by Shi et al. (2012) . Such an overdense lump is promising as it could lead to an observable feature in the form a modulation of the electromagnetic flux, especially in the case of a high inclination system ( Noble et al., 2012 ; D’Orazio et al., 2013 ; Farris et al., 2014 ; Noble et al., 2021 ) , in turn this signal could allow us to identify pre-merger systems with a circumbinary disc. It is worth noting that this overall structure is also seen in Newtonian simulations ( Lai & Muñoz, 2023 , see the extensive review on circumbinary disc by) and across codes ( Duffell et al., 2024 , as is shown in the Santa Barbara Binary-Disc code comparison in) , hence making it a robust feature of circumbinary discs around circular binaries. In Mignon-Risse et al. (2023b) we proposed an instability ( Lovelace & Hohlfeld, 1978 ; Lovelace et al., 1999 ; Li et al., 2000 , the Rossby-Wave Instability, RWI, ) to be at the origin of the m=1 mode that gives rise to the lump at the edge of the circumbinary disc which would create a quasi-periodic modulation of the lightcurve (e.g. Tang et al. 2018 ).This was a beneficial step as it gives us a better understanding of what causes the lump, hence we can better predict in which systems it would occur, which in turn tells us that such observables are expected for a large range of mass-ratio and time-to-merger. At the same time, it also raises the issue of how to distinguish those observables from the ones arising from the accretion disc orbiting around a single black hole ( Varniere et al., 2020 , see for example) . Indeed, if one wants to use the lump-induced variability as a way to identify pre-merger BBHs, we need to make sure that no other systems, namely a SBH system, could exhibit the same observational features. If the observable cannot be untangled, it could not only mean that some BBHs have been misclassified as single black holes, but also that some of our candidate BBHs are in fact single black-hole systems with quasi-periodic variability. Hence, a more thorough examination is required. To that effect, we will first briefly present which stage of the pre-merger BBH system we are focusing on and what are the potential observables that are associated with it. We will also briefly present the simulations from which our synthetic observations were computed. As we are looking for a possible match between observables from circumbinary discs and SBH accretion discs, the actual origin of the lump is not relevant in this study but rather its impact on the observables. As such we will not discuss in detail these simulations but only display the basic setup from which they originate. In the following two sections we will focus on specific circumbinary observables and their potential matches from SBH systems. Our approach will be to take each observable and check if the SBH model can be disproved or shown to lack some ingredients hinting at a more complex system. The first one will be the full spectral energy distribution (SED) of the circumbinary disc that will be confronted with a few SBH systems able to fully reproduce its observed SED. Then we will focus on the temporal variability of circumbinary discs and compared it with SBH systems that could match it. Here the aim is to see how easy it would be simply fit the BBH’s observables with a SBH. Lastly, we will look at what combination of observables would be needed in order to distinguish both systems. In turn this will allow us to check when the lump’s impact on the observables can be confirmed as a key component to identify pre-merger systems. 2 Binary black hole versus single black-hole system For both systems we are using the units where the gravitational constant \mathrm{G} and velocity of the light \mathrm{c} are set to unity \mathrm{G}\,{=}\,\mathrm{c}\,{=}1 and the gravitational radius r_{g}=\mathrm{G}M/\mathrm{c}^{2} is computed with the total mass M of the system while the mass ratio

Read the complete text