Robust design of bicycle infrastructure networks
Christoph Steinacker, Mads Paulsen, Malte Schröder, Jeppe Rich · 2025
Read Robust design of bicycle infrastructure networks by Christoph Steinacker, Mads Paulsen, Malte Schröder, Jeppe Rich (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-04349.txt.
Introduction
Steinacker and co-authors compare in 2025 two ways to design bike networks that hold up well as conditions change. Good bike networks lift cycling, but growth over long horizons is hard to plan. Network effects and shifts in travel choice make the task complex.
One path uses direct welfare optimization, the other a simple network heuristic. Both were tried on plans for cycle superhighways in Copenhagen. The complex models gave better welfare, but only by small margins. They also proved more fragile when inputs were off. The result is a warning that fancy long term plans can rest on shaky ground, despite high benefit to cost ratios.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Christoph Steinacker, Mads Paulsen, Malte Schröder, Jeppe Rich |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 92 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-04349
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Robust design of bicycle infrastructure networks Christoph Steinacker, Mads Paulsen, Malte Schröder, Jeppe Rich Abstract Promoting active mobility like cycling relies on the availability of well-connected, high-quality bicycle networks. However, expanding these networks over an extended planning horizon presents one of the most complex challenges in transport science. This complexity arises from the intricate interactions between infrastructure availability and usage, such as network spillover effects and mode choice substitutions. In this paper, we approach the problem from two perspectives: direct optimization methods, which generate near-optimal solutions using operations research techniques, and conceptual heuristics, which offer intuitive and scalable algorithms grounded in network science. Specifically, we compare direct welfare optimization with an inverse network percolation approach to planning cycle superhighway extensions in Copenhagen. Interestingly, while the more complex optimization models yield better overall welfare results, the improvements over simpler methods are small. More importantly, we demonstrate that the increased complexity of planning approaches generally makes them more vulnerable to input uncertainty, reflecting the bias-variance tradeoff. This issue is particularly relevant in the context of long-term planning, where conditions change during the implementation of the planned infrastructure expansions. Therefore, while planning bicycle infrastructure is important and renders exceptionally high benefit-cost ratios, considerations of robustness and ease of implementation may justify the use of more straightforward network-based methods. 1 Introduction Promoting active mobility, like walking and cycling, is important for achieving sustainable mobility. However, this is only possible with a sufficiently developed infrastructure. Specifically for cycling, demand strongly relies on the quality and quantity of the available bicycle infrastructure [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . Due to its low costs and space requirements compared to other modes of transport [ 4 , 5 ] , there is growing evidence of large, positive welfare benefits of bicycle infrastructure for society [ 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] . However, designing efficient network expansions over time represents one of the most challenging problems in urban planning [ 12 , 13 ] . The complexity of these network design or network expansion problems [ 14 , 15 ] stems from their dynamic nature, where investments in one period affect the usage of the network and the benefits of additional investments in the future (Fig. 1 ). These feedback effects include changes in the routes of cyclists and spillovers from other transport modes as cycling becomes faster and more convenient. The problem presents itself as a dynamic optimization problem with a structure similar to the one presented in the seminal work of Bellman [ 16 ] . Compared to complex network design problems for multimodal or congested transport, bicycle infrastructure planning does not typically include direct interactions between individual travelers. Nonetheless, the problem remains highly complex [ 17 ] due to the strong interactions and indirect feedback loops between available infrastructure, network quality, cycling demand, and route choice (Fig. 1 ) and cannot be solved without substantial simplifications of the underlying problem. This has resulted in a divide between two algorithmic approaches to addressing the problem. One school addresses the problem from the classical operations research perspective, typically framing it as a mathematical program to optimize various objectives. These objectives can range from optimizing travel time [ 18 ] or distance and safety indicators [ 19 ] over minimizing cost and investments [ 20 ] to maximizing connectedness and directness of routes expressed in a set-covering mixed-integer linear programming (MILP) [ 21 ] . Many approaches combine multiple quality measures in a weighted multiple criteria function to represent the costs and benefits of all stakeholders involved [ 22 , 23 ] or employ Pareto-optimization to identify different feasible networks, for example based on the trade-off in travel times between bike and car traffic [ 24 ] . In recent years, a new class of operations research models has emerged, which more closely follows traditional cost-benefit analyses and aims to optimize a general welfare function expressed in terms of the net present value (NPV) of the infrastructure [ 25 , 7 , 8 ] . The net present value models also combine multiple criteria, all weighted into a common monetary base, to evaluate the total societal benefit of network extensions. In the reference model applied in this paper, the multi criteria welfare function includes consumer surplus effects for cyclists, reduced healthcare costs for society due to the benefits of cycling, and the cost of investments and infrastructure maintenance [ 8 ] . Typically, to solve these problems on a large scale, various simplifications are required to enable the evaluation of the objective function or the optimization process itself, such as heuristic search of the possible extension pathways, aggregation and linearization techniques to simplify complex computations, or treating the optimization as a Markov chain problem and iteratively finding the next expansion steps based on the current network state instead of computing the all expansion steps at once. Overall, the operations research perspective focuses more strongly on devising efficient solution methods and achieving network extension plans as close to optimal as possible. Figure 1: The network expansion problem. (a) Designing efficient infrastructure network expansions is a complex problem due to interactions and feedback effects between the available and planned infrastructure, the possible routing options, the resulting cycling demand, and the evaluation of the network quality. (b) Sketch of bike path network extensions over time (left to right). Cyclists prefer to travel along bike paths (blue lines) but avoid large streets without bike paths (thick gray lines). As new bike paths are added (light blue), the cyclists change their routes (black dotted lines) to use the new routing options. This in turn affects the importance of all other existing and potential bike paths in the network, and thus changes which bike paths should be constructed next. The second school has grown out of the network science community and often approaches the problem more conceptually. These network science approaches analyze large-scale network data [ 26 ] and employ simplified heuristic models of network expansion based on conceptual quality measures including connecting fragmented components [ 27 , 28 , 29 ] , directness [ 30 , 31 ] , effective shortest path distances [ 32 ] and coverage of the network [ 33 , 34 ] . A recent model taken as a reference in this paper, for example, generates a sequence of infrastructure networks by iteratively deconstructing a fully expanded network based on a flexible network evaluation scheme [ 32 ] . Overall, unlike the operations research perspective, network science-inspired approaches prioritize understanding common structural characteristics of efficient networks over identifying the exact optimal solution. This understanding can, for instance, inform heuristic search methods or help assess the quality of existing networks with interpretable measures. How do these two communities’ network planning strategies and suggested network expansions compare when applied to the same network expansion problem? Here, we aim to bridge this research gap by directly comparing the suggested expansion steps from a state-of-the-art mathematical programming model recently published by Paulsen & Rich [ 7 , 8 ] to a dynamic percolation model suggested by Steinacker et al. [ 32 ] for planning the cycling superhighway network of Copenhagen with the same underlying network