Refraction of light and conservation laws

R. Dengler · 2025

Read Refraction of light and conservation laws by R. Dengler (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-04206.txt.

Introduction

Dengler (2025) revisits how light bends when it enters a material, using a particle-like picture of light. Refraction by media that do not spread colors can be modeled with compact wave packets. These packets behave like pseudo-particles. The picture is a favorite in thought experiments about which form of light momentum is correct, the long-running Abraham-Minkowski debate.

Working at an elementary level, Dengler shows how the different kinds of momentum each play their role. He shows how the bending of light follows from conservation laws applied to the particles. A special microscopic model that can be solved exactly is used as a test case. It shows where the simple particle picture and the standard wave equations for materials pull against each other. The paper aims to make the interplay concrete rather than settle the debate by decree.

Catalog record

CREATORR. Dengler
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE29 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-04206

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Refraction of light and conservation laws R. Dengler Abstract The refraction of light by dispersion-free dielectric media can be modeled using well-localized macroscopic wave packets, enabling a description in terms of pseudo-particles. This approach is often used in thought experiments to illustrate aspects of the Abraham-Minkowski debate. This work uses the particle picture to show at an elementary level how different types of momenta come into play, and how light refraction can be explained at the level of particles. A special exactly solvable microscopic model is used to illustrate the interplay and tension between microscopic physics and the conventional effective-medium Maxwell equations. 1 Introduction In Newton’s corpuscular theory of light, light is composed of of tiny, massive corpuscles, and the sine law of refraction is explained using a mechanical model (proposition 95 of book 1 of his Principia (1686)). In modern terms, Newton proposed that a refracting body acts as a potential well of constant depth for the corpuscles, causing a higher speed within the medium due to energy conservation. Upon entering the medium the perpendicular component of momentum changes, while the component p_{\|} parallel to the surface remains unchanged. This relationship is expressed as p_{\|}=p\sin\alpha=p^{\prime}\sin\alpha^{\prime}, (1) where p is total momentum in vacuum, p^{\prime} total momentum in the medium, and \alpha and \alpha^{\prime} are the angle of incidence measured from the normal vector, see Fig. 1 . If p is constant then p^{\prime} only depends on the type of medium, and also is constant, and equation ( 1 ) is Snell’s law, the law of sines. The corpuscular theory of light gradually lost its status in favor of the wave theory of light, largely due to the work of C. Huygens, T. Young, and A. J. Fresnel. The possibility to measure wavelengths also demonstrated that light propagates in matter with a speed reduced by a factor n , the refractive index, while Newton’s model requires greater speed in the medium, in contradiction also to special relativity. Nevertheless, the concept of light particles reemerged in the form of photons within the framework of quantum field theory. Newton’s original model cannot be reconciled with modern physics. However, by considering the refraction of localized wave packets with definite momentum and energy, it should be possible to explain the kinematics of refraction in terms of particles, wave packets of light in vacuum and pseudo-particles 1 1 1 One could also speak of photons in the vacuum and quasiparticles in the medium, but what is meant here are macroscopic classical signals, which can be measured and observed along their path like classical particles. in the medium. This would again represent a valid mechanistic model for refraction. The basic assumptions for an idealized physical scenario can be summarized as follows: • Wave packets are small, with a narrow frequency range, system can be large. • Dispersion can be ignored. • Transverse polarization does not play a role. • Interactions are local. • Quantum randomness does not play a role (surfaces can have an anti-reflection coating). • Electrostriction is negligible. • Dissipation is negligible. • Refraction does not transfer momentum in directions parallel to the surface. The last condition is not as intuitive or self-evident as it might seem. Translational invariance in the direction parallel to the surface requires only conservation of the component of total momentum in this direction. A counterexample is a charged particle in a continuous resistive medium. The essential additional input is that the wavelength \lambda in a medium with refractive index n is reduced by a factor 1/n . Correspondingly, the signal speed becomes c/n , where c , is the speed of light in a vacuum. 2 Conservation laws Under these assumptions, wave packets behave like macroscopic particles with localized energy and momentum, and therefore must satisfy the standard conservation laws. 2.1 Momentum conservation Figure 1: Law of refraction in the corpuscular theory of light. Conservation of the parallel component of momentum ( p_{\|} ) at the surface of incidence, assuming constant total momentum p outside and p^{\prime} inside the medium, leads to the law of sines. If the component of signal momentum parallel to the surface is conserved, and if p represents signal momentum in vacuum, then Snell’s law implies that signal momentum in the medium is given by p^{\prime}=pn. (2) Newton explained this by conceiving the medium as a potential well, but this contradicts the lower signal speed in the medium. Instead, the signal in the medium must be interpreted as a different type of particle. The momentum ( 2 ) for a signal in a medium also is referred to as Minkowski momentum [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 10 ] . An argument in favor of Minkowski momentum ( 2 ) is that it agrees with the quantum mechanical formula for the momentum p_{QM}=\hbar k of a quasiparticle, where \hbar is Planck’s constant and k=2\pi/\lambda is the wavevector. The momentum ( 2 ) also appears to agree with measurements in liquids or gases, for a review see [ 8 ] . Conservation of momentum implies that a momentum \pm\left(p-p^{\prime}\right) is transferred to the surface of the medium when the signal enters or exits 2 2 2 In the natural scenario, without an anti-reflective coating, the additional incoming and reflected the signal also transfers momentum to the surface. . This sudden momentum transfer generates small sound waves propagating into the medium. It is not difficult to verify that these sound waves contain a negligible amount of energy in realistic situations (section 3 ). A superficial analysis might end here, but there is a caveat, and this is also where the Abraham-Minkowski controversy comes into play. 2.1.1 Connection to Abraham-Minkowski debate For many scenarios propagation of light in a medium is well understood. If the wavelength is much larger than the distance between atoms, Maxwell’s equations combined with the linear relation D=\epsilon E between the electric displacement field D and the electric field E , are sufficient to derive the rules of optics. This includes the laws of reflection and refraction for different polarizations, as well as the intensities of reflected and transmitted light in both isotropic and anisotropic media [ 7 , 9 ] . Complications include nonlinear dispersion, electro- and magnetostriction [ 1 , 2 , 12 ] , which also transfer momentum to matter. However, even the fundamental problem of disentangling electromagnetic and mechanical momentum is full of pitfalls. The root of the Abraham-Minkowski controversy are the expressions of Minkowski and Abraham for electromagnetic momentum in a medium, in terms of the electromagnetic fields D and B or E and H . The expression should contain or should not contain the material momentum, and one source of the difficulty are the phenomenological equations D=\epsilon E and H=B/\mu . More recent reviews are [ 1 , 8 ] . Yet, even after more than a century, the situation remains unsatisfactory. A more fundamental question concerns the validity [ 14 ] of the usual Maxwell equations in matter, which replace atomic matter with an averaged (coarse-grained) substance. Such an approximation is adequate for effects depending on average polarizability and magnetizability. Difficulties arise when attempting to calculate bilinear local microscopic quantities, such as the momentum of matter.

Read the complete text