A mirrored pair of optimal non-decomposable entanglement witnesses for two qudits does exist

Dariusz Chruściński, Anindita Bera, Joonwoo Bae, Beatrix C. Hiesmayr · 2025

Read A mirrored pair of optimal non-decomposable entanglement witnesses for two qudits does exist by Dariusz Chruściński, Anindita Bera, Joonwoo Bae, Beatrix C. Hiesmayr (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-04158.txt.

Introduction

Telling whether two quantum particles are entangled, linked in a way no classical pair can be, often relies on test gadgets called entanglement witnesses. Dariusz Chruściński and co-authors study a paired form of these tests in this 2025 paper. A recent paper had guessed that no pair of top-quality tests could both catch the subtlest kind of entanglement, the kind that survives a partial flip.

The authors show such a mirrored pair does exist for two multi-level particles. Both tests are optimal and both catch that bound entanglement. The construction also stretches to higher dimensions. The result uncovers new structure in how these witnesses fit together, against the earlier guess. It sharpens the toolkit for certifying quantum links.

Catalog record

CREATORDariusz Chruściński, Anindita Bera, Joonwoo Bae, Beatrix C. Hiesmayr
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-04158

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A mirrored pair of optimal non-decomposable entanglement witnesses for two qudits does exist Dariusz Chruściński, Anindita Bera, Joonwoo Bae, Beatrix C. Hiesmayr Abstract Two approaches can be utilized to handle the separability problem, finding out whether a given bipartite qudit state is separable or not: a direct procedure on the state space or the effective tool of entanglement witnesses (EWs). This contribution studies the structure of EWs. Exploiting the very concept of mirrored EWs, increasing the detection power, we show, in contrast to the conjecture in a recent paper (Sci. Rep. 13 , 10733 (2023)), there exist pairs of optimal EWs, which are both non-decomposible, i.e. can detect bound/PPT-entangled states in an optimal way. Since we show that the structure also extends to higher dimensions, our results reveal a further structure of entanglement witnesses. 1 Introduction Entanglement witnesses (EWs) are both theoretical and experimental tools to detect entangled states [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] . An EW is represented by Hermitian operator W in \mathcal{H}_{A}\otimes\mathcal{H}_{B} such that W is not positive definite (possesses at least one negative eigenvalue) but \langle\psi_{A}\otimes\psi_{B}|W|\psi_{A}\otimes\psi_{B}\rangle\geq 0 for all product vectors (such operators are often called to be block-positive). It immediately implies that \mathrm{tr}[W\sigma_{\mathrm{sep}}]\geq 0 for all separable states \sigma_{\mathrm{sep}} and hence for any entangled state \rho there exists an EWs W such that \mathrm{tr}[W\rho]<0 [ 1 , 2 ] . There exists a parallel detection scheme based on the concept of positive maps [ 2 ] . Due to the well-known Choi-Jamiołkowski isomorphism [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] (cf. [ 10 ] for a detailed exposition), there is an one-to-one correspondence between the block-positive operators in \mathcal{H}_{A}\otimes\mathcal{H}_{B} and positive linear maps \Phi:\mathcal{B}(\mathcal{H}_{A})\to\mathcal{B}(\mathcal{H}_{B}) , where \mathcal{B}(\mathcal{H}) denotes bounded linear operators acting on \mathcal{H} . Recall that \Phi is a positive map whenever for any X\geq 0 one has \Phi(X)\geq 0 . Moreover, if \mathcal{I}_{n}\otimes\Phi is also positive for all n=1,2,\ldots , then \Phi is called completely positive [ 11 , 12 ] (here \mathcal{I}_{n} denotes an identity map acting on a space of n\times n complex matrices). Completely positive maps are fully characterized by the celebrated Kraus representation \Phi(X)=\sum_{\alpha}K_{\alpha}XK_{\alpha}^{\dagger} with suitable Kraus operators K_{\alpha} . Entanglement witnesses correspond to positive but not completely positive maps [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 13 ] . Unfortunately, in spite of the considerable effort, the structure of positive maps – and hence also entanglement witnesses – is still not fully understood. This, in turn, implies that the full classification of quantum states of composite systems is still missing. An EW is called decomposable if W=A+B^{\Gamma} , with A,B\geq 0 and \Gamma stands for the partial transposition. Otherwise, it is called non-decomposable. Decomposable witnesses cannot detect PPT entangled states, i.e. if W=A+B^{\Gamma} , then {\rm Tr}(W\sigma_{\rm PPT})\geq 0 for all PPT states \sigma_{\rm PPT} . Hence, to classify bound entangled states, the construction of large classes of non-decomposable witnesses is of great importance. A recent review on the current knowledge about bound entangled or PPT entangled states can be found in Ref. [ 14 ] . Among EWs, optimal witnesses are of particular importance [ 15 ] . An EW W is called optimal if, for any P\geq 0 , the following operator W-P is no longer an EW. It means that one cannot improve W by subtracting a positive operator. Entanglement witnesses, being Hermitian operators, represent physical observables and, hence, in principle, can be implemented in the laboratory. Moreover, any EW can be factored into local observables \displaystyle W=\sum_{i}A_{i}\otimes B_{i}, (1) with local observables A_{i} and B_{i} . A collection of expectation values of local observables \mathrm{tr}[A_{i}\otimes B_{j}\rho] can decide whether a state \rho is entangled. Recently, in Ref. [ 17 ] the framework of mirrored EWs was introduced. Given an entanglement witness W one defines a mirrored operator W_{\rm M} by W_{\rm M}=\mu\;{\mathchoice{\rm 1\mskip-4.0mul}{\rm 1\mskip-4.0mul}{\rm 1\mskip-4.5mul}{\rm 1\mskip-5.0mul}}_{A}\otimes{\mathchoice{\rm 1\mskip-4.0mul}{\rm 1\mskip-4.0mul}{\rm 1\mskip-4.5mul}{\rm 1\mskip-5.0mul}}_{B}-W, (2) with the smallest \mu>0 such that W_{\rm M} is block-positive, i.e. \langle\psi\otimes\phi|W_{\rm M}|\psi\otimes\phi\rangle\geq 0 . Now, if the maximal eigenvalue \lambda_{\rm max} of W satisfies \lambda_{\rm max}>\mu , then W_{\rm M} is an EW and therefore this construction gives rise to a pair (W,W_{\rm M}) of mirrored EWs [ 17 ] , which can double up the capability of detecting entangled states. Interestingly, the construction of a mirrored operator W_{\rm M} is closely related to the well-known structural physical approximation [ 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 ] . In a recent paper [ 24 ] we constructed mirrored operators for several classes of well-known EWs both decomposable and non-decomposable. In particular, it was shown that a mirrored operator to any extremal decomposable EW is always a positive operator (cf. the next section for the definition of optimal and extremal EWs). We posed the conjecture that the mirrored operator obtained from an optimal EW is either a positive operator or a decomposable EW. The conjecture [ 24 ] was motivated by the simple observation that there exists a trade-off relation between W and W_{\rm M} displayed by eq. ( 2 ). In particular, it says that there does not exist a mirrored pair of non-decomposable EWs (W,W_{\rm M}) such that at least one of them is optimal. The assumption about optimality turned out to be critical since we provided an example of a mirrored pair of non-decomposable EWs, but none of them was optimal. In Fig. 1 we have visualized our findings, the graphic schematically displays the convex subsets of separable and PPT states and two mirrored pairs of EWs represented by parallel lines. The (dotted) pair of EWs \{W_{3},W_{4}\} was conjectured not to exist. In this paper, we report a counterexample to the above conjecture, providing a mirrored pair of two optimal non-decomposable EWs for two qutrits. Interestingly, both EWs have maximal numbers of negative eigenvalues and the corresponding eigenvectors span a completely entangled subspace. This example further reveals the intricate structure of EWs. Possible examples of mirrored non-decomposable optimal EWs in higher dimensions are also discussed. The paper is organized as follows. In Sec. 2 , we briefly review the concept of optimal EWs. Section 3 presents the construction of a mirrored pair of non-decomposable witnesses. Our main results state that they are both optimal (even non-decomposable optimal [ 15 , 16 ] ). Section 4 contains technical details of the proof. Section 5 discusses generalization for higher dimensional systems. We finally conclude with open questions in Sec. 6 . Figure 1: This graphic displays the set of bipartite states (green) together with convex subsets of PPT states (blue) and separable states (grey). States which are PPT but not separable are bound entangled. Entanglement witnesses W_{i} are represented by straight lines. In Ref. [ 24 ] the conjecture was put forward based on the study of several known examples, that for a pair of mirrored EWs, \{W_{1},W_{2}\} if W_{1} is optimal and non-decomposable then W_{2} is decomposable (or it’s not a witness at all). This paper shows that surprisingly pairs of mirrored optimal EWs exist, here \{W_{3},W_{4}\} (dotted lines), which both detect PPT-entangled states. 2 Optimal entanglement witnesses In this section, we briefly discuss the very

Read the complete text