The Nature of Organization in Living Systems

Pedro Márquez-Zacarías, Andrés Ortiz-Muñoz, and Emma P. Bingham · 2025

Read The Nature of Organization in Living Systems by Pedro Márquez-Zacarías, Andrés Ortiz-Muñoz, and Emma P. Bingham (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-03950.txt.

Introduction

Pedro Marquez-Zacarias, Andres Ortiz-Munoz, and Emma Bingham ask what stays fixed in a live thing while its stuff is swapped out. The work came out in 2025. Live things trade stuff with the world round them all the time. Yet one trait lasts through that swap. The team calls that trait the form of the whole.

They set out a math frame and a set of core terms for that form. In their view, the form does not hinge on which bits of stuff are there at one time. The form also comes from inside the thing itself. So the frame must show how self-made form starts and holds. They build up from small base steps to the whole forms that life science studies. They also link their terms to past work in the field and in thought about life.

Catalog record

CREATORPedro Márquez-Zacarías, Andrés Ortiz-Muñoz, and Emma P. Bingham
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-03950

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Nature of Organization in Living Systems Pedro Márquez-Zacarías, Andrés Ortiz-Muñoz, and Emma P. Bingham Abstract Living systems are thermodynamically open but closed in their organization. In other words, even though their material components turn over constantly, a material-independent property persists, which we call organization . Moreover, organization comes from within organisms themselves, which requires us to explain how this self -organization is established and maintained. In this paper we propose a mathematical and conceptual framework to understand the kinds of organized systems that living systems are, aiming to explain how self-organization emerges from more basic elemental processes. Additionally, we map our own notions to existing traditions in theoretical biology and philosophy, aiming to bring the main formal ideas into conceptual congruence. “ In vain we force the living into this or that one of our molds. All the molds crack. They are too narrow, above all too rigid, for what we try to put into them. " –Henri Bergson [ 1 ] . 1 Organization in living systems Living systems exhibit complex organization, with many interacting components producing diverse organized structures and behaviors. Organisms continuously transform matter and energy when coupled to their relevant environments. The complexity of these internal-external interactions often makes it hard to grasp what it is that makes a specific system organized, particularly when attempting to formalize this notion. Traditional theoretical approaches are often based on physical and thermodynamical constraints, frequently requiring system-specific details and assumptions which lose generality when applied to a large class of systems, like the class of the living. Here we take an alternative approach, with minimal physical assumptions or constraints, focusing instead on the features that make organisms organized , which to us is the foundation of the living state. We develop a formalism that allows us to express what is possible for a system, but we acknowledge that physical details and the context of particular systems will influence what is probable . We aim to formally define system-level properties that living systems exhibit across the tree of life, which should also apply to a more general, non-Earth-bound, theory of the living. Our starting point is that despite the endless forms and behaviors exhibited by organisms in the biosphere, they are all organized in some equivalent sense. Thus, it is important to develop a formally grounded and conceptually coherent blueprint of this equivalence. 1.1 Approaches to the study of living organization The study of biological organization has a long history. However, despite this tradition, a formal approach has largely remained peripheral. Some efforts, related but not primarily focused on organisms, emerged in the context of chemical systems, like the work by Ostwald [ 2 ] , Rössler [ 3 ] , Gánti [ 4 ] , Turing [ 5 ] , chemical organization theory and autocatalytic systems theory [ 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] . More general formalisms with a focus on organisms and organization have been scant, but we can mention organismic set theory by Rashevsky [ 11 , 12 , 13 ] , the theory of autopoiesis by Maturana-Varela [ 14 , 15 ] , Ehresmann-Vanbremeersch’s theory of hierarchical evolutive systems [ 16 ] , and (M,R)-systems theory by Rosen [ 17 , 18 ] . Similar in spirit but distinct in their details are the biotonic laws by Elsasser, catastrophe theory by René Thom, and Waddington’s landscapes. To us, the work of Rashevsky-Rosen and Maturana-Varela form a particularly important core of ideas that strongly resemble our own motivations. An important distinction from this core, is that we consider consumptive processes to be as important as productive ones, to maintain self-organization. Most of the literature above ignores, or makes implicit, the consumptive aspects, which we will call autoanalysis . Recently, a handful of theories describing particular aspects of living systems have been proposed, like the free energy principle [ 19 , 20 ] , assembly theory [ 21 , 22 ] , constructor theory [ 23 , 24 ] , and others (e.g. [ 25 , 26 ] ), but these are less relevant to our purposes. Despite the variety of the aforementioned approaches, we agree with Mossio when he points out that there is still a “blind spot for organization" in biology [ 27 ] . In our view, the blind spot lies in the fact that some abstract theories are hard to map to concrete systems, while others take the opposite stance by describing life as the mere “jigglings and wigglings of atoms". We take neither of these approaches. To us, life is a phenomenon that lives in the material world but whose defining properties are not tied to concrete material substrates. While this ontology of the living departs from mainstream theoretical biology, in our view it is not in conflict with it, but in complementarity. 1.2 Lost and found: organisms as objects of study in biology For much of modern science as it arose, organisms were the central objects of study in biology. However, during the last century, particularly after the emergence of the modern synthesis and the development of molecular biology, the organism took a progressively minor role. Over time, organisms became simple ‘vehicles’ for genes and traits, which replaced them as the essential units of analysis and explanation. The modern synthesis and molecular biology are supra-organismal and infra-organismal disciplines, and thus a big part of the contemporary edifice of biology was built by excluding organisms. Moreover, genes were progressively endowed with qualities that used to be exclusive of organisms. Genes became the roots for any biological observable (phenotype), the causes for adaptive advantages/disadvantages, and they even gained agency and autonomy (e.g. in the ‘selfish gene’ metaphor). Although there are some signs that the organism is returning to biology as a central object of study, much work remains to be done given the historical halt. One of the first studies of what an organism is comes from Kant, who developed the idea of self-organized beings as those systems in which the constituent parts exist for and by the system [ 28 ] . This dual aspect of the components of an organism is important conceptually and formally, because it requires the elements of organisms to play at once both functional and structural roles. We will discuss this duality throughout our paper, but here we can mention that modern biology largely treats this duality as a hierarchy instead: structure implies function. We believe that removing this hierarchy and recovering Kant’s duality is necessary to understand why and how living systems are organized, and a primary aim of our work is to formalize these philosophical notions. Kauffman recently borrowed Kant’s definition in his own work (calling such systems ‘Kantian wholes’), to build on a list of essential properties that living systems exhibit [ 29 , 30 , 31 ] . Although Kauffman has come close to a conceptual answer to what makes living systems alive, we believe that more work is needed to provide a formal grounding to some of these concepts. The essence of our method is to define organic, self-organized systems in terms of the properties that emerge from assembling simple processes that on their own are not self-organized.

Read the complete text