Effect of Alloying on Intrinsic Ductility in WTaCrV High Entropy Alloys
Akshay Korpe, Osman El-Atwani, Enrique Martinez Saez · 2025
Read Effect of Alloying on Intrinsic Ductility in WTaCrV High Entropy Alloys by Akshay Korpe, Osman El-Atwani, Enrique Martinez Saez (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-03875.txt.
Introduction
Akshay Korpe, Osman El-Atwani, and Enrique Martinez Saez study how alloying changes the built-in ductility of a tungsten-based high entropy alloy, in a 2025 paper. Tungsten suits extreme settings such as fusion reactor parts, but it forms poorly and resists radiation only weakly on its own. The mixed alloy is known for strong radiation resistance.
They judge ductility by a contest between crack growth and dislocation emission on key crystal planes, computed from first-principles theory. Results suggest that more vanadium and less tungsten can greatly improve ductility. They also analyze how uneven the alloy's stiffness is by direction. The work guides recipes for tougher fusion materials.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Akshay Korpe, Osman El-Atwani, Enrique Martinez Saez |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 60 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-03875
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Effect of Alloying on Intrinsic Ductility in WTaCrV High Entropy Alloys Akshay Korpe, Osman El-Atwani, Enrique Martinez Saez Abstract Tungsten (W) exhibits desirable properties for extreme applications, such as the divertor in magnetic fusion reactors, but its practicality remains limited due to poor formability and insufficient irradiation resistance. In this work, we study the intrinsic ductility of body-centered cubic WTaCrV based high entropy alloys (HEAs), which are known to exhibit excellent irradiation resistance. The ductility evaluations are carried out using a criterion based on the competition between the critical stress intensity factors for emission ( K I e K_{Ie} ) and cleavage ( K I c K_{Ic} ) in the {110} slip planes and {110} crack planes, which are evaluated within the linear elastic fracture mechanics framework and computed using density functional theory calculations. The results suggest that increasing the alloying concentrations of V and reducing the concentrations of W can significantly improve the ductility in these HEAs. The elastic anisotropy for these HEAs is analyzed using the Zener anisotropy ratio and its correlation with the concentration of W in the alloys is studied. Results indicate that these alloys tend to be fairly isotropic independently from the concentration of W in them. The computed data for the elastic constants of these HEAs is also compared against the available experimental data. The results are in good agreement, hence validating the robustness and accuracy of the computational methods. Multiple phenomenological ductility metrics were also computed and analyzed against the analytical model. The results suggest that these models may have higher computational efficiency due to less number of parameters required for their computation. Some models, like the surrogate D parameter and the Pugh ratio, show a good correlation with the Rice model. The potential of these empirical models to serve as surrogate screening models for optimizing the compositional space is also discussed. 1 Introduction In the realm of magnetic fusion reactors, plasma-facing materials (PFMs), such as the divertor in tokamak devices, are subjected to extreme environments during operation with long exposures ( > \mathrm{10^{7}s}) to high temperatures ( > 1000 K) and ionized and energetic deuterium (D) and tritium (T), helium (He) ash fluxes ( > \mathrm{10^{24}m^{-2}s^{-1}}) and neutrons [ 1 ] . The materials used for these applications therefore need to possess exemplary thermo-mechanical properties such as high melting points and good strength retention at elevated temperatures as well as excellent irradiation resistance including low sputter erosion and low tritium retention [ 2 ] . In recent years, a new class of tungsten (W) based high entropy alloys (HEAs) of the form WTaCrV has been studied to show outstanding irradiation resistance that makes them potential candidates for PFM applications. There is good computational data backed by experimental verification that shows the viability of these alloys in environments of extreme irradiation, which tests these materials at elevated temperatures (1073 K) and irradiation up to 8 dpa showing good retention of mechanical properties after exposure [ 2 ] . However, the ductility of these HEAs is not well understood, with not many studies available. In the few experimental works in the literature, these WTaCrV based HEAs show poor ductility (1-2 % fracture strains) at room temperatures [ 3 ] . This problem of poor ductility as well as the relatively sparse understanding of the underlying ductility mechanisms has put forward new challenges both in computational and experimental research pertaining to the viability of these materials in areas of nuclear fusion reactors. The ductility of a material is a widely accepted surrogate indicator of its potential to achieve high fracture toughness. It is also an important property to predict the formability and manufacturing potential of metallic alloys and hence there is an urgent need to study the ductility of these HEAs. Body-centered cubic (BCC) refractory HEAs are generally known to be intrinsically brittle at room temperature [ 4 , 5 ] . Moreover, many BCC refractory metals (V, Ta, Cr, Mo, W) have been observed to show a sharp brittle-to-ductile transition with increasing temperature and are known to be brittle at lower temperatures [ 6 , 7 , 8 ] . This implies that the brittleness of these BCC HEAs is not a property solely to be attributed to HEAs and is a characteristic feature of many other BCC refractory metals. These alloys do not show a clear correlation between the yield strengths and ductility as seen in experiments performed to study ductility under compressive loading. BCC alloys like equimolar VNbMoTaW (1246 MPa at 296 K with 0.5 % peak strain) and NbMoTaW (1058 MPa at 296 K with 1.5 % peak strain) show very low ductility at relatively high yield strengths at ambient temperatures [ 9 ] whereas similar alloys like MoNbTaTi (1800 MPa at 293 K with 25 % peak strain) and WNbTaTi (1800 MPa at 293 K with 20 % peak strain) show high ductility at room temperature with high yield strengths [ 10 ] . Also, the brittle-to-ductile transition temperatures (BDTT) are quite sharp and hence cannot be explained completely by a dislocation plasticity model, which would predict the transition to be smooth [ 6 , 11 ] . Attributable to these anomalous behavior exhibited by BCC refractory HEAs, new models for ductility prediction have been the topic of contemporary research. Most of the available experimental datasets reporting ductility of BCC HEAs are for compressive loading [ 10 , 9 , 3 ] , at least partly for testing the manufacturing potential in the form of formability. Experimental evidence indicates that the mode of failure in compression is mode I (tensile failure) [ 9 ] . Many ideas have been put forward to understand the underlying mechanisms that distinguish between ductile and brittle responses in materials. One of the most widely used frameworks explains intrinsic ductile behavior in terms of atomic structure at an atomistically sharp crack, corresponding to the competition between dislocation emission and cleaving [ 12 , 13 ] . This theory was further developed by Rice and Thomson into continuum models for modeling the behavior of pre-cracked bodies under applied loads [ 14 ] . This theory is in accordance with experimental studies of crack tip behavior using transmission electron microscopy (TEM), which report extensive dislocation emission and blunting in Nb, which is known to be intrinsically ductile and very few dislocation emissions in W, which is known to be a brittle metal at room temperatures [ 15 ] . These observations are also consistent with the BDTT behavior of these BCC HEAs. It has to be noted however, that there are experimental works on BCC HEAs that attribute intrinsic brittleness to inter-granular fracture due to formation of brittle oxides and nitrides at the grain boundaries without significant crack tip plasticity [ 16 ] . In this work, we rely on Rice’s model using Peierls framework into dislocation nucleation [ 17 ] along with the concept of crack propagation due to Griffith’s cleavage [ 18 ] to analyze the ductility of the previously mentioned WTaCrV based HEAs. We make use of the postulated hypothesis by Mak et al. [ 19 ] stating that a material is intrinsically ductile if dislocation emission occurring at a sharp crack