Higgs near-criticality at future colliders
Victor Enguita · 2025
Read Higgs near-criticality at future colliders by Victor Enguita (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-03825.txt.
Introduction
Victor Enguita and co-authors explore whether the Higgs boson sits near a critical edge, and how future colliders could test that idea, in a 2025 paper. The Higgs mass may be small because the vacuum of our universe is only barely stable. That metastability bound ties the Higgs mass to new physics. Strong versions of the bound need particles that shift the vacuum's fate.
The authors study a model of neutrino mass with a Majoron particle. It supplies heavy fermions and an extended scalar sector. Both ingredients help keep the vacuum alive long enough. They generalize the bound to theories with several scalars. Collider planners gain targets for what to measure next.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Victor Enguita |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 101 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-03825
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Higgs near-criticality at future colliders Victor Enguita Abstract The so-called metastability bound on the Higgs mass suggests that the smallness of the Higgs mass may be a byproduct of the metastability of the electroweak vacuum. A significantly strong bound requires new physics capable of lowering the scale where the Higgs quartic coupling turns negative through renormalization group effects, without destabilizing the electroweak vacuum entirely. We analyze in this context the low-scale Majoron model of neutrino masses, which automatically contains two key elements for a viable scenario: heavy fermions to lower the instability scale and a extended scalar sector to stabilize the potential and achieve realistic lifetimes for the electroweak vacuum. We show how the metastability bound can be generalized to theories with multiple scalars and present an efficient way of calculating the tunneling rate in such potentials. We also demonstrate that FCC will probe regions of the parameter space relevant for metastability: large regions of the fermionic sector at FCC-ee and some reach to the scalar sector at FCC-hh. MIT-CTP/5768 IFT-UAM/CSIC-25-10 1 Introduction The present Higgs quest is largely motivated by the so-called naturalness problem: the fact that the value of the Higgs mass is comparable to the electroweak (EW) scale while quantum effects generically try to push it to high values, if there are new physics scales beyond the EW one to which the Higgs mass is sensitive. Within the naturalness paradigm, small and/or apparently fine-tuned parameters would be explained away as being required by underlying symmetries. A plethora of beyond-the-Standard-Model (BSM) scenarios trying to justify the smallness of the Higgs mass through new symmetries has been intensely studied since decades, with no real breakthrough by now and no experimental evidence for the associated scales of new physics. A similar puzzle can be found when analyzing the stability of the Higgs field. Its relevant parameters can be interpreted as fine-tuned to allow this field to decay into an energetically more favorable state, destroying the Universe as we know it in the process, but only with an exceedingly small probability. Altogether, the paradigm of naturalness together with the properties of the Higgs boson would suggest that the LHC should have already found signs of new physics beyond the Standard Model (BSM), to justify those values through symmetry arguments. The situation is so perplexing that it has been questioned whether the principle of naturalness should be applied to the Higgs system at all. An alternative paradigm is that of self-organized criticality [ 1 ] and related developments, which would drive the parameters of the scalar potential of Nature towards near-criticality , i.e., towards apparently fine-tuned values. Indeed, the apparent fine-tuned values of the two independent parameters of the SM Higgs potential can be understood as close to critical values, i.e., the Higgs mass is very small (the limit m_{h}\rightarrow 0 separates the phases with and without spontaneous symmetry breaking) and the value of the Higgs self-coupling \lambda , i.e., the strength with which the Higgs field scatters off itself, is tantalizingly close to the transition from a stable to an unstable one, as mentioned above. To require those two parameters to be close to critical amounts to a drastically unusual perspective on the hierarchy problem: rather than directly trying to explain the relative lightness of the Higgs, one might instead try to focus on the mechanism responsible for favoring metastability, and find a small Higgs mass as a byproduct. For concrete examples of physical underlying mechanisms see Refs. [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] , which speculate that the near-criticality of the Higgs potential parameters could be the result of a dynamical mechanism in the early Universe. 1 1 1 Beyond the vacuum selection mechanism developed in these references, it was recently argued in Ref. [ 7 ] that a metastability bound also emerges naturally in any theory whose vacuum manifold (or landscape) satisfies certain generic conditions. This work will remain agnostic and it will not rely on any particular mechanism favoring near-criticality, but it will rather build upon the interdependence of the parameters of the scalar potential required by near-criticality. Amongst the previous efforts in this direction are the metastability bounds for the Higgs system developed in Refs. [ 8 , 9 , 7 ] , and this is the path adopted in this work. The metastability bounds represent a significant deviation from usual model-building efforts: rather than trying to construct an explicit model capable of explaining the apparent fine-tunings of the potential, these bounds establish an interdependence between them. More concretely, they state that the metastability of the EW arising from the renormalisation group (RG) flow of the quartic coupling \lambda to negative values at high energies imposes an upper limit on the Higgs mass. This suggests that finding an explanation for the apparent metastability could also offer a solution to the EW hierarchy problem. Crucially, the metastability bounds do not depend on the details of the mechanism responsible for the vacuum’s metastability. This insensitivity establishes the universality of the bounds and makes transparent their most important dependencies. The precise value of the metastability bound on the Higgs mass is roughly set by the instability scale \mu_{I} , defined as the scale at which \lambda vanishes and then becomes negative when loop corrections are taken into account. In the SM – see; for instance, Refs. [ 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] , \displaystyle m_{h}^{2}<|\beta_{\lambda}|e^{-3/2}\cdot\mu_{I}^{2}\,, (1) where \beta_{\lambda} is the beta function for \lambda . Intuitively, Eq. ( 1 ) suggests that the upper limit on m_{h} is about one order of magnitude smaller than \mu_{I} . In the SM \mu_{I}\sim 10^{11} GeV, which translates into a SM bound m_{h}^{2}\leq 10^{10} GeV, which is a very weak and in practice irrelevant constraint. Nevertheless, the bound may be very sensitive to BSM matter contents, which can strongly lower the value of \mu_{I} down to values \mathcal{O}(1) TeV, allowed by current colliders. Indeed, it has been shown that strict bounds on m_{h} can emerge in the presence of heavy exotic fermions, which strongly affect the renormalization group (RG) running of \lambda and lower the instability scale. However, a byproduct of this mechanism to lower the instability scale is a further destabilization of the vacuum: for couplings strong enough to get the bound close to the observed value of the Higgs mass, the effect is also strong enough to lower the vacuum’s lifetime \tau below the current age of the Universe, contradicting our ongoing existence. This establishes another necessary condition for the metastability bound’s ability to explain the Higgs mass, namely the need for some additional new physics capable of partially stabilizing the vacuum at energies above the instability scale. In summary, viable scenarios that achieve a strict metastability limit on the Higgs mass can be achieved with the combination of: • Heavy fermions to lower the instability scale \mu_{I} so that the limit on m_{h} is close to the observed value. • At least one BSM scalar to stabilize the vacuum at a scale \mu_{S}>\mu_{I} , so as to raise the vacuum’s lifetime above the current age of the Universe. Note that this very specific combination and ordering of new physics scales is, as