On a Character Correspondence associated to đ \mathfrak{F} -projectors
MarĂa JosĂ© Felipe, Iris Gilabert, Lucia Sanus · 2025
Read On a Character Correspondence associated to đ \mathfrak{F} -projectors by MarĂa JosĂ© Felipe, Iris Gilabert, Lucia Sanus (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-03737.txt.
Introduction
MarĂa JosĂ© Felipe, Iris Gilabert, and Lucia Sanus study in 2025 how certain special characters of a finite group behave when viewed inside a subgroup. The characters in question, called head characters after Isaacs, capture structural information about solvable groups, and their good behavior under restriction is not guaranteed.
The authors find the conditions that make restriction behave, and they pin down the shared kernel of all head characters at once. They then widen the results using Navarro's broader class of characters tied to any saturated formation containing the nilpotent groups. The work tidies a corner of character theory that feeds the classification of finite groups.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | MarĂa JosĂ© Felipe, Iris Gilabert, Lucia Sanus |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-03737
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On a Character Correspondence associated to đ \mathfrak{F} -projectors Thanks: 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification : primary 20C15, secondary 20D10. Thanks: Key words: head characters, đ \mathfrak{F} -projectors, saturated formations Thanks: This research is partially supported by the Generalitat Valenciana (CIAICO/2021/163). The second author is supported by a grant (PAID-01-23 funded by the Universitat PolitĂšcnica de ValĂšncia and subsequently CIACIF/2023/389 funded the Generalitat Valenciana). The second and third authors are partially supported by the Spanish Ministerio de Ciencia e InnovaciĂłn (PID2022-137612NB-I00 funded by MCIN/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and âERDF A way of making Europeâ). The first and second authors are partially supported by the Universitat PolitĂšcnica de ValĂšncia (PAID-06-23). Thanks: We would like to thank Gabriel Navarro for bringing this problem to our attention and for useful conversations on the subject. MarĂa JosĂ© Felipe, Iris Gilabert, Lucia Sanus Abstract . We study the conditions under which the head characters of a solvable group, as defined by I. M. Isaacs, behave well with respect to restriction. We also determine the intersection of the kernels of all head characters of the group. Using G. Navarroâs definition of đ âČ \mathfrak{F}^{\prime} -characters, we generalize these results for any saturated formation đ \mathfrak{F} containing the nilpotent groups. 1. Introduction If G is a solvable group, I. M. Isaacs constructed in 2022 [ 10 ] a canonical subset of the complex irreducible characters of G associated to the linear characters of a Carter subgroup C of G . Recall that a Carter subgroup of G is a self-normalizing nilpotent subgroup of G . He called these the head characters of G , and proved that the number of those was |C/C^{\prime}| , the number of linear characters of C . Long time before, E. C. Dade and D. Gajendragadkar had already constructed in [ 2 , 4 ] another subset of {\rm Irr}(G) , this time associated to the system normalizers of the solvable group G . This subset was described by Gajendragadkar from the better known fully factorable characters . The head characters, on the other hand, remain mysterious, and no general properties are known of them. In our first main result, we prove the following key property. Theorem A . Let G be a solvable group, C a Carter subgroup of G and N normal in G . If \chi is a head character of G , then the restriction \chi_{NC} contains a head character of NC . In particular, \chi_{N} contains a C -invariant character of N . Theorem A was conjectured by G. Navarro in private communications with I. M. Isaacs, and its proof depends on new deep properties of the character theory of fully ramified characters. (See Lemma 3.5 .) In Theorem B, we turn our attention to the kernels of the head characters and prove the following. Theorem B . Let G be a solvable group and C be a Carter subgroup of G . The intersection of the kernels of the head characters of G is the largest normal subgroup N of G such that N\cap C is contained in C^{\prime} . Theorem B is the exact analog of an unpublished result of Navarro which we present here with his permission. Theorem C (Navarro) . Let p be a prime, let G be p -solvable and let P be a Sylow p -subgroup of G . The intersection of the kernels of the p^{\prime} -characters of G is the largest normal subgroup N of G such that {\bf N}_{N}(P) is contained in P^{\prime} . What is the relationship between the head characters and the p^{\prime} -degree characters of a solvable group? If \mathfrak{F} is a saturated formation and G is a solvable group, Navarro defined in [ 14 ] a canonical subset {\rm Irr}_{\mathfrak{F}^{\prime}}(G) of the irreducible characters of G of size |{\rm Irr}(N_{G}(H)/H^{\prime})| , where H is an \mathfrak{F} -projector of G . If \mathfrak{F} is the formation of nilpotent groups, then H is a Carter subgroup, and he proved that {\rm Irr}_{\mathfrak{F}^{\prime}}(G) are the head characters of G ; in particular, reproving Isaacs result. If \mathfrak{F} is the formation of p -groups, then H is a Sylow p -subgroup and this reproved the McKay conjecture for solvable groups. For solvable groups, Carter subgroups are the \mathfrak{F} -projectors associated to the formation of nilpotent groups, in the same way that system normalizers are the nilpotent case of \mathfrak{F} -normalizers. The latter are a conjugacy class of subgroups that was used by Dade and Gajendragadkar in a more general way to define their subset of \text{Irr}(G) when \mathfrak{F} is a saturated formation containing the nilpotent groups. In fact, our Theorems A and B are also far more general. In the same framework as Dade and Gajendragadkar (that is, if \mathfrak{F} is a saturated formation containing the nilpotent groups), we shall prove convenient versions of Theorems A and B for {\rm Irr}_{\mathfrak{F}^{\prime}}(G) (see respectively Theorems 6.2 and 7.5 ) at the same time that we drastically simplify Isaacsâ construction (see Theorem 5.4 ). There are still several questions on the head characters and Carter subgroups that remain open: among them if the character table of G determines the set of its head characters. We are confident that our results might be helpful in solving these and other related questions. 2. Some properties on projectors A class of groups \mathfrak{F} is called a formation if it is closed under quotients and satisfies the following property: whenever G/N,G/M\in\mathfrak{F} for some finite group G , it follows that G/(M\cap N)\in\mathfrak{F} . A formation \mathfrak{F} is said to be saturated if G\in\mathfrak{F} if and only if G/\Phi(G)\in\mathfrak{F} , where \Phi(G) denotes the Frattini subgroup of G . Examples of saturated formations are the classes of finite p -groups, finite nilpotent groups, and finite supersolvable groups. As basic references on this topic, see [ 3 ] and [ 15 ] . The notion of formations was first introduced by GaschĂŒtz in [ 5 ] as a context where both definitions of Carter and Sylow subgroups could be unified under the more general concept of \mathfrak{F} -covering subgroups. GaschĂŒtz later proved that, when \mathfrak{F} is saturated, these subgroups coincide with \mathfrak{F} -projectors , a preferable term in formation theory. Lemma 2.1 . Let \mathfrak{F} be a saturated formation and G a solvable group. There exists exactly one conjugacy class of subgroups H of G such that, for every normal subgroup N of G , the subgroup HN/N satisfies the following properties: (a) HN/N\in\mathfrak{F} ; (b) if HN/N is a subgroup of the subgroup V/N of G/N with V/N\in\mathfrak{F} , then HN/N=V/N . In other words, HN/N is \mathfrak{F} -maximal in G/N for all normal subgroups N of G . We say that these subgroups H are the \mathfrak{F} -projectors of G . As previously mentioned, Carter subgroups can be found through the above definition by choosing the formation to be that of nilpotent groups, which we will note \mathfrak{N} from now on. Similarly, p -Sylow and \pi -Hall subgroups are the \mathfrak{F} -projectors for the saturated formations of p - and \pi -groups respectively. Listed below are some fundamental properties of \mathfrak{F} -projectors which we will need in our proofs. Proposition 2.2 . Let \mathfrak{F} be a saturated formation