Discovery of intertwined spin and charge density waves in a layered altermagnet
Christopher Candelora, Muxian Xu, Siyu Cheng, Alessandro De Vita, Davide Romanin, Chiara Bigi, My Bang Petersen, Alexander LaFleur, Matteo Calandra, Jill Miwa, Younghun Hwang, Ziqiang Wang, Federico Mazzola, Ilija Zeljkovic · 2025
Read Discovery of intertwined spin and charge density waves in a layered altermagnet by Christopher Candelora, Muxian Xu, Siyu Cheng, Alessandro De Vita, Davide Romanin, Chiara Bigi, My Bang Petersen, Alexander LaFleur, Matteo Calandra, Jill Miwa, Younghun Hwang, Ziqiang Wang, Federico Mazzola, Ilija Zeljkovic (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-03716.txt.
Introduction
Christopher Candelora, Ilija Zeljkovic, and a team of co-authors find twin wave patterns in a layered magnet. Their paper, from twenty twenty-five, studies a cobalt-laced form of niobium diselenide. The material is an altermagnet, a new class with split electron spins but no net magnetism. A sharp probe scans its surface at low heat.
The probe sees a partial gap in electron states that standard theory misses. Maps reveal charge and spin ripples running in three directions. Both ripples share the same short wavelength. A magnetic field can tune how strong the ripples grow. The find shows altermagnets can host ordered states ripe for study.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Christopher Candelora, Muxian Xu, Siyu Cheng, Alessandro De Vita, Davide Romanin, Chiara Bigi, My Bang Petersen, Alexander LaFleur, Matteo Calandra, Jill Miwa, Younghun Hwang, Ziqiang Wang, Federico Mazzola, Ilija Zeljkovic |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-03716
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Discovery of intertwined spin and charge density waves in a layered altermagnet Christopher Candelora, Muxian Xu, Siyu Cheng, Alessandro De Vita, Davide Romanin, Chiara Bigi, My Bang Petersen, Alexander LaFleur, Matteo Calandra, Jill Miwa, Younghun Hwang, Ziqiang Wang, Federico Mazzola, Ilija Zeljkovic Abstract I Abstract Altermagnets recently came into the spotlight as a new class of magnetic materials, arising as a consequence of specific crystal symmetries Hayami2019 ; Smejkal2020 ; Yuan2020 ; Mazin2021 . They are characterized by a spin-polarized electronic band structure similar to ferromagnets, but with net zero magnetization, and touted as a promising platform to host a slew of exotic properties, many of which are yet to be explored Smejkal2022_2 ; Parthenios2025DWtheory ; Sim2024PDW . Using spectroscopic-imaging scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and spin-polarized STM, we discover intertwined spin and charge density waves in a layered triangular lattice altermagnet, Co-intercalated NbSe 2 . STM topographs and differential conductance maps in the altermagnetic state show tri-directional modulations with a 2 a_{0} wave length that are robustly present and non-dispersive in a wide range of imaging biases, suggesting a charge ordering origin of the modulations. Spin-polarized STM measurements further reveal that the amplitude of the charge modulations is sensitive to the spin polarization of the tip. This observation demonstrates an additional spin modulation associated with the density wave modulations. Our work uncovers the first density wave instability involving both charge and spin degrees of freedom in an altermagnetic system, accomplished by providing elusive atomic-scale insights. Our experiments thus set the foundation for the studies of correlated electronic states in altermagnets, and motivate comprehensive explorations of intercalated quasi-2D transition metal dichalcogenides in the search for novel phenomena in altermagnets. II Introduction For decades, the field of magnetism has focused on classifying collinear magnetic orders into two main categories: antiferromagnetic orders or ferromagnetic orders. The former is a crystal-symmetry compensated state with a net zero magnetization and Kramers degenerate bands, while the latter arises from spin splitting of the electronic band structure, generating a net magnetization. In recent years, several groups reported theoretical predictions of collinear antiferromagnets demonstrating various time-reversal symmetry breaking phenomena and spin-polarized behaviors Hayami2019 ; Smejkal2020 ; Yuan2020 ; Mazin2021 , subsequently named altermagnets Smejkal2022_2 . Altermagnetism exists in the space between antiferromagnetism and ferromagnetism – it is characterized by a net zero magnetization, yet the Kramers degeneracy is lifted by a non-relativistic, momentum-dependent spin-splitting of the electronic bands. The band splitting is driven by crystal symmetries connecting opposite-spin sublattices, linked by rotational symmetry in real space Smejkal2022_1 . Due to intrinsic time-reversal symmetry breaking predicted to emerge in these systems, altermagnets have been theorized to exhibit numerous exotic phenomena, such as large anomalous Hall effect, spin-polarized currents and magneto-optical Kerr effect Smejkal2020 ; Mazin2022 ; Smejkal2022_3 . Since its initial theoretical formulation, altermagnetism and related properties have now been explored in several materials, such as RuO 2 Gonzalez2021 ; Feng2022 ; Bai2022 ; Karube2022 ; Bose2022 ; Tschirner2023 ; Wang2023 ; Guo2024 ; Wang2024 ; Osumi2025 ; Kebler2024 ; Hiraishi2024 ; Fedchenko2024 , MnTe Krempasky2024 ; Lee2024 ; Osumi2024 ; Betancourt2023 ; Kluczyk2024 ; Gonzalez2024 ; Hariki2024 ; Liu2024 and others Han2024 ; Reichlova2024 ; Biniskos2022 ; Nakatsuji2015 ; Reimers_2024 ; Ghimire2018 ; Jiang2024sdw . MnTe for example has been found to exhibit Kramers degeneracy lifting Krempasky2024 ; Lee2024 ; Osumi2024 , an anomalous Hall effect Betancourt2023 ; Kluczyk2024 , anisotropic magnetoresistance Gonzalez2024 and time-reversal symmetry breaking Hariki2024 . As altermagnetism is generally driven by specific crystal symmetries connecting different spin-sublattices, the phenomena discovered thus far do not necessarily require many-body interactions for their emergence Smejkal2022_2 . Therefore, one of the central thrusts in this budding field remains whether strongly correlated electronic phases prevalent in other families of quantum materials, such as superconductivity, various density waves or electronic nematicity, can be realized and studied in altermagnets Smejkal2022_2 . This has however remained challenging. Recently, a quasi-2D layered system, Co-intercalated 2H -NbSe 2 (Co 0.25 NbSe 2 ), emerged as another altermagnetic candidate Regmi2024 . Experiments, supported by theoretical calculations, showed that it exhibits a spin-polarized electronic band structure consistent with altermagnetism Dale_2024 ; Regmi2024 ; deVita_switch . Given that the “parent” material 2H -NbSe 2 hosts the canonical 3 a_{0} \times 3 a_{0} charge density wave and superconductivity NbSe2_3x3_CDW ; Giambattista1988NbSe2 ; Hess1989NbSe2vortex , Co intercalation of the superconducting 2H -NbSe 2 is a potentially promising platform in the quest for engineering correlated electron states that coexist with altermagnetism. In this work, we study altermagnet Co 0.25 NbSe 2 using a combination of low-temperature spectroscopic imaging STM, spin-polarized STM, angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) and density functional theory (DFT). We observe non-dispersive 2 a_{0} \times 2 a_{0} charge modulations on the Se termination, distinct in wave length from those in the parent compound. Through ARPES, we are able to visualize replica bands accompanying the 2 a_{0}\times 2 a_{0} density wave state. Interestingly, by performing spin-polarized STM, we detect a spectroscopic change in the density of states as a function of magnetic field, accompanied by a change in the relative intensities of the charge modulations. This measurement suggests an additional spin modulation component associated with the charge order. Taken together, our experiments reveal the emergence of a charge density wave (CDW) intertwined with a spin density wave (SDW), both coexisting with altermagnetism. III Results We cleave the samples in ultra-high vacuum at cryogenic temperature and immediately insert them into the microscope head (Methods). The crystals have a 2D layered structure, with interstitial Co atoms residing between adjacent Se-Nb-Se slabs, above the Nb atoms (Fig. 1 a). The topographic height between adjacent layers is 6.2 \mathrm{\text{Å}} (Fig. 1 b), which matches the expected interlayer distance extracted from the diffraction measurements (Fig. 1 a). Typical STM topographs show a hexagonal lattice with two possible surface terminations: the Se termination in which Se atoms form a hexagonal lattice with the lattice constant a_{0}\approx 3.7$\mathrm{\text{Å}}$ (Fig. 1 c), or the Co termination where some of the interstitial Co atoms are left on top of the Se surface (Fig. 1 d). The remaining Co atoms on the surface exhibit a tendency to order into a 2 \times 2 superstructure, consistent with their expected structure in the bulk between the adjacent NbSe 2 slabs Regmi2024 . Interestingly, STM topographs of the Se termination also show additional modulations that are approximately commensurate with the lattice, where every other Se atom appears brighter than the adjacent ones in all in-plane lattice directions (inset in Fig. 1 c). This can be seen in the corresponding Fourier transforms (FTs) of STM topographs where, in addition to the Se atomic Bragg peaks, another set of superstructure peaks with wave vectors \textbf{q}_{2a0}^{i}=\frac{1}{2}\textbf{Q}_{Se}^{i} ( i = 1, 2, or 3 labels different in-plane lattice direction) appears (Fig. 1 e). We have observed these 2 \times 2 modulations on 5 samples with 8 different STM tips. The 3 a_{0} \times 3 a_{0} charge density wave state known to exist in the bulk and on the Se surface of undoped NbSe 2 at about \frac{1}{3}\textbf{Q}^{i}_{Se} NbSe2_3x3_CDW is notably absent in Co 0.25 NbSe 2 (Fig. 1 e,f). It is important to note that the 2 a_{0} \times 2 a_{0} modulations detected on the Se surface