Super-Linear Growth and Rising Inequality in Online Social Communities: Insights from Reddit
Guilherme Machado, Diogo Pacheco, Ronaldo Menezes, Gareth Baxter · 2025
Read Super-Linear Growth and Rising Inequality in Online Social Communities: Insights from Reddit by Guilherme Machado, Diogo Pacheco, Ronaldo Menezes, Gareth Baxter (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-02661.txt.
Introduction
Guilherme Machado and three co-authors measured in 2025 how comment activity concentrates as Reddit communities grow. Across subreddits, a small core of users writes a large share of comments, and the pattern is lopsided everywhere. The team checked whether bigger communities simply sample that lopsidedness or deepen it.
Inequality, scored by the Gini coefficient, climbs steadily with community size, beyond what sampling explains. Growth itself centralizes talk: extra members add comments mostly through the core. The finding matters for moderators and platform designers who assume growth spreads participation on its own.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Guilherme Machado, Diogo Pacheco, Ronaldo Menezes, Gareth Baxter |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-02661
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Super-Linear Growth and Rising Inequality in Online Social Communities: Insights from Reddit Guilherme Machado, Diogo Pacheco, Ronaldo Menezes, Gareth Baxter Abstract We study the effect of the number of users on the activity of communities within the online content sharing and discussion platform Reddit, called subreddits. We found that comment activity on Reddit has a heavy-tailed distribution, where a large fraction of the comments are made by a small set of users. Furthermore, as subreddits grow in size, this behavior becomes stronger, with activity (measured by the comments made in a subreddit) becoming even more centralised in a (relatively) smaller core of users. We verify that these changes are not explained by finite size nor by sampling effects. Instead, we observe a systematic change of the distribution with subreddit size. To quantify the centralisation and inequality of activity in a subreddit, we used the Gini coefficient. We found that as subreddits grow in users, so does the Gini coefficient, seemingly as a natural effect of the scaling. We found that the excess number of comments (the total number of comments minus the total number of users) follows a power law with exponent 1.27. For each subreddit we considered a snapshot of one month of data, as a compromise between statistical relevance and change in the system’s dynamics. We show results over the whole year 2021 (with each subreddit having twelve snapshots, at most), nevertheless all results were consistent when using a single month or different years. K eywords Collective Behaviour \cdot Social Centralization and Limits \cdot Scaling Systems \cdot Social Network 1 Introduction Social media have become an integral part of individuals’ daily lives, serving as a primary means of social interaction, news dissemination, and information sharing [ 1 , 2 ] . Given that online interactions are a relatively recent phenomenon, humans have not biologically evolved to engage predominantly in virtual communication. In turn, the nature of interactions on social media platforms tends to mirror those found in the physical world, incorporating familiar social behaviours and structures [ 3 , 4 ] . However, unlike face-to-face interactions, virtual communication is not constrained by spatial limitations, thereby facilitating a higher volume and broader scope of interactions. While it is well-established that inequalities arise in real-world social structures due to various factors [ 5 , 6 , 7 ] , the development and manifestation of inequalities within online interactions remain insufficiently explored. Previous studies have explored the statistical properties of social interactions across various platforms, consistently identifying broad, heavy-tailed distributions such as power laws in the dynamics of user engagement [ 8 , 9 ] . These findings indicate that user interactions often follow predictable scaling laws, akin to those observed in natural and social phenomena, although, interestingly, some research has found that not all social media interactions follow pure power laws [ 10 , 11 ] . Furthermore, it is well acknowledged that many social media platforms introduce inherent biases through algorithms that govern content visibility, interaction facilitation, and group formation [ 12 , 13 ] . These algorithmic mechanisms can distort natural interaction patterns, making it challenging to determine whether observed statistical regularities are intrinsic to human behaviour or are a result of platform-specific interventions driven by commercial interests [ 14 , 15 ] . Consequently, to develop more generalisable hypotheses regarding online social interactions, it is imperative to examine platforms with minimal algorithmic interference in content curation and interaction dynamics. While achieving complete impartiality is nearly impossible, Reddit [ 16 ] stands out as a promising candidate due to its comparatively open platform structure, which allows for more organic interaction dynamics and the formation of user-driven communities. This openness reduces the extent of algorithm-induced biases, thereby providing a more authentic environment to study user activity and interaction patterns without the pervasive influence of commercial algorithmic manipulation [ 17 ] . As such, Reddit serves as a better setting for investigating the fundamental principles governing online social interactions and the emergence of inequalities within these virtual communities [ 18 ] . While Reddit differs from other social media in some key respects, it nevertheless exhibits many of the same statistical features as other platforms [ 19 ] . Reddit distinguishes itself through its organisation around topical communities known as subreddits . Unlike platforms such as X (formerly Twitter), Facebook, or Instagram, which are primarily centred on individual profiles as content producers, Reddit’s structure allows users to engage within diverse, interest-specific communities. Users can subscribe to multiple subreddits, each dedicated to a particular subject or theme, ranging from broad topics like news and technology to niche interests such as specific hobbies or regional communities. The size of these subreddits varies widely, hosting anywhere from a handful of active users ( e.g. , r/londonfootballmeetup , r/learnAI , r/starwarslego ) to hundreds of thousands of participants ( e.g. , r/AskReddit , r/memes , r/wallstreetbets ). This community-centric model fosters specialised discussions and enables the formation of tightly-knit groups within the larger Reddit ecosystem. Within subreddits, users have access to a wide array of topics and can engage actively by commenting on posts and other users’ contributions. Moreover, Reddit emphasises anonymity and pseudonymity, as users are not required to disclose personal information beyond what is necessary for account creation. This encourages open and honest discourse, although it also presents unique challenges in content moderation and community management. Each subreddit is typically moderated by a team of volunteer moderators who enforce community-specific rules, maintain discourse quality, and manage content visibility, such as, by removing or approving posts and comments that violate guidelines, as well as categorising content as ‘spoilers’ or NSFW (not safe for work) when necessary. Reddit facilitates community-driven feedback through an upvoting and downvoting system, which plays a pivotal role in determining the visibility and prominence of posts. Additionally, Reddit features a ‘karma’ system [ 20 ] that reflects a user’s reputation within the platform, earned through the reception of upvotes on their posts and comments. In certain subreddits, a minimum karma threshold is even enforced for submitting posts, ensuring a baseline quality of content within the community, which could be seen as algorithm control, but it is more like reputation-based rules. These elements collectively contribute to Reddit’s distinctive environment, balancing open user participation with structured community governance. Another notable aspect of Reddit is that the majority of its content—including posts, comments, usernames, profiles, karma scores, upvote/downvote ratios, and associated metadata—is publicly accessible, reflecting its commitment to an ‘open internet’ [ 21 ] . This extensive dataset has been systematically collected and made available by the Pushshift project [ 22 , 23 ] . Dynamic interaction systems frequently result in the dominance of specific groups or individuals, exhibiting patterns reminiscent of the Pareto Principle, where a small proportion of participants account for the majority of contributions or influence within a community. This phenomenon of inequality is observable across various social, economic, and biological systems, underscoring tendencies towards hierarchical structures and power asymmetries. We aim to investigate the extent to which online systems exhibit such inequalities and to explore whether there are inherent limits to these disparities. By analysing the distribution of user engagement and activity, we seek to contribute to a more