Quantum probability for statisticians; some new ideas Running head: Quantum probability
Inge S. Helland · 2025
Read Quantum probability for statisticians; some new ideas Running head: Quantum probability by Inge S. Helland (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-02658.txt.
Introduction
Inge Helland argues that quantum style probabilities deserve a place in ordinary statistics, in a paper from 2025. The catalog title adds a running head note. New work on quantum foundations rests on postulates that, the author claims, also make sense for large scale settings, and one such approach is laid out in depth.
The reasoning behind the Born rule, which assigns the probabilities, is presented for that framework. A list of possible statistical uses is given and discussed. One sketched idea uses a quantum model to shrink complex models, with a classic regression method appearing as a special case. Decision theory built on quantum probability is also covered.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Inge S. Helland |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-02658
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantum probability for statisticians; some new ideas Running head: Quantum probability Inge S. Helland Abstract It is argued from several points of view that quantum probabilities might play a role in statistical settings. New approaches toward quantum foundations have postulates that appear to be equally valid in macroscopic settings. One such approach is described here in detail, while one other is briefly sketched. In particular, arguments behind the Born rule, which gives the basis for quantum probabilities, are given. A list of ideas for possible statistical applications of quantum probabilities is provided and discussed. A particular area is machine learning, where there exists substantial literature on links to quantum probability. Here, an idea about model reduction is sketched and is motivated from a quantum probability model. Quantum models can play a role in model reduction, where the partial least squares regression model is a special case. It is shown that for certain experiments, a Bayesian prior given by a quantum probability can be motivated. Keywords: Accessible theoretical variables; Born’s formula; complementarity; machine learning; quantum foundation; quantum probabilities. 1 Introduction The basis for nearly all articles in theoretical and applied statistics is Kolmogorovian probability (Kolmogorov, 1933). Quantum probability is mostly looked upon by statisticians as an exotic tool with no relevance for statistical science and statistical inference. This implies that, in the statistical literature there is very little discussion of possible links between statistical theory and quantum theory. (A good exception is the article Barndorff-Nielsen et al. (2003), where quantum versions of exponential models, sufficiency and Fisher information are discussed, among other related topics.) In my opinion, this has led to a limitation of statistical science, both from a theoretical point of view and from an applied point of view. I relate this statement to the idea that traditional statistical theory only - at least in most cases - looks upon the parameter space as a set with no structure. Introducing more structure into the parameter space will give a richer theory. And I will show in the next Section that some such structures indeed lead to quantum probabilities. Later in this article I will discuss a specific structure, symmetry introduced by letting a concrete group act on the parameter space and the implications for model reduction. It seems as if a discussion of links between quantum theory and statistical theory is more than due now. This can be underpinned by looking at the current revolution in artificial intelligence, in particular machine learning, an area that engages more and more statisticians. It is probably not so well known among statisticians that discussions of connections between machine learning and quantum mechanics have appeared in the literature now; see for instance the review article Dunjko & Briegel (2019). If we really mean that machine learning should be based upon statistics, connections between statistical theory and quantum theory should also be of high interest. One can ask then: Is not quantum probabilities just of relevance to the microcosmos? My answer to this is no. To argue for that answer, one can look at recent derivations of quantum mechanics from various postulates. In two books (Helland, 2021; Helland and Parthasarathy, 2024) and in a series of articles (Helland 2022a,b, 2023a-d, 2024a-f), this author has proposed a completely new foundation of quantum theory, and also, in this connection, discussed the interpretation of the theory. This foundation is summarized in Subsections 2.2 and 2.3 below, where the essence of quantum theory is deduced from 7 postulates. Looking at these postulates, most of them may be seen to be equally valid in a macroscopic setting. Another basis for quantum theory is given in a series of articles by De Raedt and his collaborators. One of these is De Raedt et al. (2014). Here, essential elements of quantum mechanics are derived from what is called logical inference to experiments, an assumption that there are uncertainties about individual events and that the frequencies are robust with respect to small changes in the parameters. One tool in the derivations is that of Fisher information. Fisher information as a general basis for nearly all aspects of science has earlier been advocated by Frieden (2014). Finally, it is of interest in this connection to look at the quantum-like models introduced by Khrennikov and collaborators; see Khrennikov (2010, 2021) and Haven & Khrennikov (2013, 2016). These models are based upon quantum probabilities and are applied to several sciences, including cognitive psychology, sociology, finance and biology. An important element here is a theory of quantum decisions; see also Helland (2023d, 2024e). While there are few examples of statistical papers related to quantum probability, there are several articles in the quantum theory literature that use basic statistical concepts and ideas. Very much discussion among theoretical physicists is concerned with the interpretation of quantum theory. Some still want to look upon it as an ontological theory, but more and more physicists now conclude with the view that quantum mechanics should be interpreted as an epistemic or epistemological theory: It is a theory of our knowledge of the world, in the same way that statistical theory is basically about knowledge from experiments and observations. A strong school in the quantum community is QBism, originally an abbreviation for Quantum Bayesianism, but now by its founders claimed to have a somewhat wider basis, see Caves et al. (2002) and Fuchs (2003, 2010). A very recent article on Bayes’ rule and related inference in quantum mechanics is Liu (2024). The plan of this article is as follows: In Section 2 my own basis for quantum theory is discussed in some detail, together another basis. One aim is to motivate the use of quantum probabilities in macroscopic settings. In Section 3, several potential ideas for the use of quantum probabilities in statistical settings are discussed. This includes model reductions, quantum probabilities as priors for certain experiments, and machine learning. The final section gives some general discussion points. 2 Two basic theories leading to quantum probabilities 2.1 A new approach; the postulates and the first results A completely new approach towards quantum foundations is proposed in Helland (2024a-d), where the formal properties of quantum mechanics are derived from a rather simple set of postulates. These postulates will be repeated below. It should be emphasizes that the postulates imply essential parts of the ordinary formalism, in particular the formalism behind quantum probabilities. The purpose of the postulates is to imply an increased understanding of the quantum formalism. As a possible general interpretation, the basis can be taken to be relative to an actor who is in some fixed (physical or statistical) context. In this context there are theoretical variables , and some of these variables, say \theta,\lambda,\eta,... may be related to the actor C . Some of these variables are accessible to him, which means roughly that it is, in some future, given some estimation principle, in principle possible to obtain as accurate estimates as he wishes on the relevant variable. Other variables are inaccessible . A typical physical example of an inaccessible variable is the vector (position, momentum) of a particle, a variable which by Heisenberg’s inequality can not be given an accurate estimate. In Helland (2024a-d), other physical examples are given. In