Women’s Status and Fertility: A Novel Perspective on Low Fertility Issue

Ruiwu Liu · 2025

Read Women’s Status and Fertility: A Novel Perspective on Low Fertility Issue by Ruiwu Liu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-02237.txt.

Introduction

Ruiwu Liu wrote a 2025 paper, headed Fertility Choices with Career Risk, on how career risk shapes a couple's choice to have children. Couples pick family size before they know the lasting career loss a child brings. Once that loss lands, household means are split again by fresh bargaining, where each spouse's own pay sets their walk away power.

In the model, that weak promise puts an outsized share of female pay risk on the wife, even when mean household means hold still. More child penalty and more career risk both cut agreed family size. Shielding the surprise part of the loss lifts family size, while a flat per child grant works only via mean cost. A test case drops from three children to one as risk climbs.

Catalog record

CREATORRuiwu Liu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE29 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-02237

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Women’s Status and Fertility: A Novel Perspective on Low Fertility Issue Ruiwu Liu Abstract This research delves into the impact of women’s social status on familial fertility choices through a concise microeconomic model. This model offers a compelling explanation for the observed decline in fertility rates in developed countries, correlating it with the rising economic status of women, and thereby providing valuable insights for policy-making. In other words, through a game theory model, we identify the rising economic status of women as the underlying cause of low fertility rates in modern developed countries. \draftSpacing 1.5 \shortTitle Kyushu University Working Paper \pubMonth MAR \pubYear 2025 \pubVolume Vol \pubIssue Issue \JEL \Keywords 1 Introduction In recent decades, fertility rates in developed countries, especially in East Asia, have consistently remained at low levels. Meanwhile, some developing countries, like China, are also encountering this problem. Economists have been working on explaining the causes of this phenomenon from various perspectives. However, these theories remain contentious, and a universal mechanism to explain the low-fertility issue has yet to be established. Becker and Barro’s foundational model (1988) introduced the trade-off between the quantity and quality of children. This framework is crucial to understanding the incentives families have to limit fertility as income rises, especially in developing countries, where studies have confirmed this trade-off more strongly than in developed economies (Rosenzweig and Zhang, 2009). On the other hand, Rindfuss and Brewster (1996) argue that: ”insofar as labor force participation acts as a constraint on fertility, we would expect fertility to rise in response to any easing of the worker-mother conflict”. By extension, they furthermore argue that ”We would expect, other things being equal, that improvements in childcare availability acceptability, and quality, and decreases in its cost would have a positive impact on fertility”. At the core of these hypotheses is the assumption that childbearing is a rational decision, and that parents weigh the costs and benefits of having children against their income, career expectations, own standards concerning the quality of care for children. In addition, according to the neoclassic economic theory of fertility, the decision to have a child is subject to an economically rational decision (a utility maximization process), and is a function of the economic cost and benefits of children, subject to an income constraint and to individuals’ preferences for children (as opposed to other goods). According to this model, any reduction in the cost of children (as a result of public subsidy) or any increase in income is therefore expected to increase the demand for children (Beck 1981; Cigno 1991). Many other studies also suggest an overall positive preference regarding having children when examining the issue of low fertility. As argued in the gender theory proposed by McDonald (2000), gender inequalities are responsible for countries’ low levels of fertility. However, there is little empirical evidence for McDonald’s gender theory. In contrast, a large body of literature (Adserà & Ferrer (2012), Gauthier(2007), Matysiak & Vignoli (2007)) suggests an aversion to having children among females in developed countries. Behrman & Gonalons-Pons (2020) also empirically suggest a positive relationship between women’s salaries and their aversion to childbirth. A prevailing consensus has emerged: as women’s educational attainment and economic status rise, the traditional family fertility patterns are undergoing significant shifts, leading to a substantial decrease in women’s average desire to bear children. This chapter aims to construct a compact and straightforward game theory model to elucidate the impact of women’s economic status on fertility rates, providing theoretical support for policymakers. In summary, under our foundational assumptions, the husband makes transfer payments to facilitate more consumption for the wife in exchange for having offspring. Through implications from this chapter, we further validate the intrinsic link between women’s economic status and fertility rates. In the following section, we first construct a non-game model as a benchmark. 2 A Benchmark Model Consider a representative family where the husband (agent i=m ) always benefits from having children, while the wife (agent i=w ) is averse to childbearing. Specifically, we assume that the wife’s total utility from raising a child is always negative due the physical and time (economic) costs. The utility functions for the husband and the wife in this representative family are given by: u^{m}=\ln(c^{m})+\alpha\ln(n), [formula] and u^{w}=\gamma\ln(c^{w})-\delta\ln(n), [formula] where \gamma indicates that males and females have different preferences for consumption. To begin, assume that if they do not form a family or a marriage, both males and females face a same structured budget constraint: c_{i}+\beta_{i}n\leq a_{i} [formula] where i\in\{w,m\} , a_{i} represents the income of the husband or wife, and \beta_{i} denotes the rearing cost per child. In this benchmark model, although the wife exhibits a negative preference for childbirth, we assume that the representative family operates under a shared constraint due to the wife’s relatively low status. This implies that the wife’s decisions aim to maximize the overall benefits of the representative family while adhering to a unified budget constraint (where \beta=\beta_{w}+\beta_{m} , is the total cost of childrearing): c_{m}+c_{w}+\beta n\leq a_{m}+a_{w}. [formula] Another important assumption is that the husband’s preference for childbirth always outweighs the wife’s aversion to childbirth, \alpha>\delta . Referring to the utility functions for the husband and wife, we can deduce that the husband benefits from having a family (i.e., having children), whereas the wife is always worse off compared to remaining childless. Therefore, the representative family’s utility function is u^{f}=\gamma\ln(c^{w})+\ln(c^{m})+(\alpha-\delta)\ln(n), [formula] where f represents the family. Solving the above utility optimization problem under the family constraint (4.5) leads to the following lemma. Lemma 4.1 Under the assumptions of this benchmark model, a family’s fertility is positively influenced by the husband’s preference for childbirth and negatively influenced by the wife’s aversion to childbirth, her preference for consumption, and the costs of childbearing. We have now constructed the benchmark model for this chapter, which assumes that the representative females hold a relatively low status within the household and have little to no bargaining power. In the next section, we will develop a game theory model to explore another scenario that better reflects the realities of a low-fertility world. 3 A Game between the Wife and Husband With the awakening of women’s self-awareness (or the improvement of their social and economic status), they begin to prioritize their own benefits in marriage rather than solely focusing on family utility. In this context, we introduce two new utility functions for different genders. The wife’s utility function is as follows: u^{w}=\gamma\ln(c^{w})-\delta n. [formula] In contrast, the husband’s utility function is u^{m}=\ln(c^{m})+\alpha n. [formula] Intuitively, the wife will not bear children unless she receives additional benefits (or promises) from her husband. In other words, the wife will choose to bear children only if the utility under the option of childbirth exceeds the utility under no-birth strategy, or \gamma\ln(a^{w})<\gamma\ln(c^{w})-\delta n. [formula] To ensure a feasible condition for childbirth, we assume that the husband transfers a portion of his income to his wife. Thus, the budget constraint for this representative wife is given by: c^{w}\leq a^{w}+\rho n, [formula] where \rho is the husband’s transfer payment per child or his willingness to have children. As discussed, the representative husband in this game will choose to transfer an uncertain portion of his income to encourage his

Read the complete text