A confirmed deficit of hot and cold dust emission in the most luminous Little Red Dots Facilities: JWST (NIRCam, NIRSpec, MIRI), ALMA, Spitzer (MIPS), Herschel (PACs)
David J. Setton, Jenny E. Greene, Justin S. Spilker, Christina C. Williams, Ivo Labbé, Yilun Ma (马逸伦), Bingjie Wang (王冰洁), Katherine E. Whitaker, Joel Leja, Anna de Graaff, Stacey Alberts, Rachel Bezanson, Leindert A. Boogaard, Gabriel Brammer, Sam E. Cutler, Nikko J. Cleri, Olivia R. Cooper, Pratik · 2025
Read A confirmed deficit of hot and cold dust emission in the most luminous Little Red Dots Facilities: JWST (NIRCam, NIRSpec, MIRI), ALMA, Spitzer (MIPS), Herschel (PACs) by David J. Setton, Jenny E. Greene, Justin S. Spilker, Christina C. Williams, Ivo Labbé, Yilun Ma (马逸伦), Bingjie Wang (王冰洁), Katherine E. Whitaker, Joel Leja, Anna de Graaff, Stacey Alberts, Rachel Bezanson, Leindert A. Boogaard, Gabriel Brammer, Sam E. Cutler, Nikko J. Cleri, Olivia R. Cooper, Pratik (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-02059.txt.
Introduction
Setton and colleagues wrote in twenty twenty-five about the missing dust glow in compact red galaxies called Little Red Dots. These distant objects look red and shine brightly in visible light. That redness suggested heavy dust around furious star birth or a hidden black hole. Yet far-infrared glow from such dust had not been seen. The team gathered deep images from space and ground telescopes. They targeted two of the brightest known examples.
Near-infrared data ruled out a strong hot dust component. Far-infrared non-detections ruled out much cold dust as well. A carbon gas signal expected from dusty starbursts was also absent. The limits clash with fits that assume heavy dust reddening. The authors favor models where these galaxies are naturally red instead. That shift eases the need for extreme dust in the early universe.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | David J. Setton, Jenny E. Greene, Justin S. Spilker, Christina C. Williams, Ivo Labbé, Yilun Ma (马逸伦), Bingjie Wang (王冰洁), Katherine E. Whitaker, Joel Leja, Anna de Graaff, Stacey Alberts, Rachel Bezanson, Leindert A. Boogaard, Gabriel Brammer, Sam E. Cutler, Nikko J. Cleri, Olivia R. Cooper, Pratik |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-02059
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A confirmed deficit of hot and cold dust emission in the most luminous Little Red Dots Facilities: JWST (NIRCam, NIRSpec, MIRI), ALMA, Spitzer (MIPS), Herschel (PACs) David J. Setton, Jenny E. Greene, Justin S. Spilker, Christina C. Williams, Ivo Labbé, Yilun Ma (马逸伦), Bingjie Wang (王冰洁), Katherine E. Whitaker, Joel Leja, Anna de Graaff, Stacey Alberts, Rachel Bezanson, Leindert A. Boogaard, Gabriel Brammer, Sam E. Cutler, Nikko J. Cleri, Olivia R. Cooper, Pratika Dayal, Seiji Fujimoto, Lukas J. Furtak, Andy D. Goulding, Michaela Hirschmann, Vasily Kokorev, Michael V. Maseda, Ian McConachie, Jorryt Matthee, Tim B. Miller, Rohan P. Naidu, Pascal A. Oesch, Richard Pan, Sedona H. Price, Katherine A. Suess, John R. Weaver, Mengyuan Xiao, Yunchong Zhang, Adi Zitrin Abstract Luminous broad H α \alpha emission and red rest-optical SEDs are the hallmark of compact Little Red Dots (LRDs), implying highly attenuated dusty starbursts and/or obscured active galactic nuclei. However, the lack of observed FIR emission has proved difficult to reconcile with the implied attenuated luminosity in these models. Here, we utilize deep new ALMA imaging, new and existing JWST/MIRI imaging, and archival Spitzer/Herschel imaging of two of the rest-optically brightest LRDs ( z = 3.1 z=3.1 and z = 4.47 z=4.47 ) to place the strongest constraints on the IR luminosity in LRDs to date. The detections at λ rest = 1 − 4 μ \lambda_{\mathrm{rest}}=1-4\ \mu m imply flat slopes in the rest-IR, ruling out a contribution from hot ( T ≳ 500 T\gtrsim 500 K) dust. Similarly, FIR non-detections rule out any appreciable cold ( T ≲ 75 T\lesssim 75 K) dust component. Assuming energy balance, these observations are inconsistent with the typical FIR dust emission of dusty starbursts and quasar torii, which usually show a mixture of cold and hot dust. Additionally, our [C II ] non-detections rule out typical dusty starbursts. We compute empirical maximum IR SEDs and find that both LRDs must have log ( L IR / L ⊙ ) ≲ 12.2 \log(L_{\mathrm{IR}}/L_{\odot})\lesssim 12.2 at the 3 σ 3\sigma level. These limits are in tension with the predictions of rest-optical spectrophotometric fits, be they galaxy only, AGN only, or composite. It is unlikely that LRDs are highly dust-reddened intrinsically blue sources with a dust temperature distribution that conspires to avoid current observing facilities. Rather, we favor an intrinsically redder LRD SED model that alleviates the need for strong dust attenuation. Astropy [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] , STScI JWST Calibration Pipeline [ 74 , https://jwst-pipeline.readthedocs.io/ ] , grizli [ 18 , github.com/gbrammer/grizli ] , msaexp [ 19 , https://github.com/gbrammer/msaexp ] , Matplotlib [ 43 ] , Flexible Stellar Population Synthesis [ 24 , 23 ] , SEDPy [ 48 ] I Introduction One of the central mysteries of the early JWST era has been the population of compact, red sources that have been dubbed “Little Red Dots” [ 64 , LRDs,] . While a number of LRD selections that identify a range of compact red objects with varying physical properties are employed in the literature [ 39 , 54 , 52 , 70 , 13 , e.g.,] , in this work we are specifically interested in the population of sources with a characteristic “V shaped” transition between the rest optical and red continuum that tends to be associated with the Balmer limit [ 83 , 62 , 56 , 77 , 45 , e.g.,] , broad and luminous Balmer emission [ 53 , 51 , 39 , 52 , 64 , which is often attributed to an AGN broad line region, e.g.,] , and unresolved rest-optical continuum emission [ 34 , 39 , 57 , 64 , e.g.,] . These sources have a high number density [ 39 , 3 , 54 , 52 , 64 , 81 , \rho\sim 10^{-5} cMpc -3 at 4<z<8 ,] , making understanding their properties crucial to the study of galaxy and AGN evolution. However, there has been no clear consensus on the engine that powers their luminous red continua. Because of the extremely red colors of LRDs, essentially every model of their light invokes a highly reddened galaxy [ 55 , 2 , 70 , 10 , 11 , 87 , 14 , 3 , 75 , e.g.,] , a highly reddened quasar [ 52 , 39 , 60 , 57 , 45 , 14 , 3 , 75 , e.g,] , or composite models that are a combination of the two components [ 83 , 84 , 62 , 59 , 49 , 13 ] . While the specific ingredients and details of these models vary, they all share the common assumption that the engine of the LRD that ionizes the broad lines is intrinsically blue, and that the red color comes from the attenuation of that engine. Because highly reddened sources re-emit their attenuated luminosity as dust emission in the infrared (IR), there has been considerable interest in constraining the IR properties of LRDs. However, the observed properties of small samples have in some ways made the LRD SED more confusing. Spatially extended red sources at 2<z<7 that occupy a similar color space to LRDs are commonly detected at 1.2mm, indicating that cold dust is emitting reprocessed UV radation. In contrast, LRDs are never detected at 1.2 mm, even in stacks [ 57 , 87 ] , casting doubt on the viability of dusty starburst solutions. However, LRDs also lack the characteristic steeply rising hot ( T\gtrsim 500 K) dust emission at \lambda_{\mathrm{rest}}\sim 1-5\ \mu m commonly seen in AGN, whether in individual luminous sources [ 83 , 13 ] or in stacks [ 87 ] , meaning that if they are indeed reddened quasars, they do not present similarly in the IR to dusty AGN seen locally [ 71 , e.g.,] or at cosmic noon [ 38 , 6 , 40 , 61 , e.g.,] . The most extensive stacking analysis of LRDs to date was carried out in [ 3 ] , leveraging the wide area of COSMOS-Web [ 21 ] to photometrically select hundreds of LRDs at z=5-9 , many of which were covered by MIRI imaging and legacy mid- and far-IR observations. Their stack consists entirely of non-detections at \lambda_{\mathrm{rest}}>2\ \mu m, but it represents the best limits on the maximal IR SED of a typical LRD. [ 60 ] use this stack to demonstrate that a physically extended dust distribution that outputs the majority of its luminosity at \lambda_{\mathrm{rest}}=10-100\ \mu m could be consistent with energy balance solutions of reddened quasars. Additionally, [ 20 ] argue that the compact sizes (and consequently, their low dust masses) should indeed result in dust temperatures that peak in that same wavelength range, with IR SEDs that remain undetectable by sub-mm facilities like ALMA. While these works represent an important step forward in constraining the dust SED of LRDs, they are subject to all the usual limitations of stacked analyses of heterogeneous samples, especially given that the [ 3 ] LRDs were selected only on red color and compactness, not “V shape” or the explicit detection of a broad line. Moreover, because the typical source included in the stack is optically faint, the constraints on L_{\mathrm{IR}}/L_{\mathrm{optical}} are still