The Simultaneous Operation of a Controllable Segmented Primary Mirror and Single Conjugate Adaptive Optics System part 1 - Design Concept and Sensitivity Analysis
Benjamin Calvin, Michael P. Fitzgerald · 2025
Read The Simultaneous Operation of a Controllable Segmented Primary Mirror and Single Conjugate Adaptive Optics System part 1 - Design Concept and Sensitivity Analysis by Benjamin Calvin, Michael P. Fitzgerald (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-02026.txt.
Introduction
Benjamin Calvin and Michael Fitzgerald propose steering a telescope's segmented main mirror through its adaptive optics system. Their paper from twenty twenty-five is part one of a study, on design and sensitivity. Segmented mirrors must hold their pieces in phase to form sharp images. Speckle gauges at Keck found steady surface flaws that the phase control missed.
The fix treats the primary as a controllable segmented primary, sensed and driven by the optics loop itself. The authors give a way to split the mirror's own control signal from the rest of the system. Models of the Keck-II adaptive optics setup then gauge how fine a read is within reach. The study sets up later parts on build and tests. It aims at sharper images from ground giants whose mirrors come in pieces.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Benjamin Calvin, Michael P. Fitzgerald |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-02026
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Simultaneous Operation of a Controllable Segmented Primary Mirror and Single Conjugate Adaptive Optics System part 1 - Design Concept and Sensitivity Analysis Benjamin Calvin, Michael P. Fitzgerald Abstract The maintenance of primary mirror segment co-phasing is a critical aspect to the operation of segmented telescopes. However, speckle-based measurements of the phasing of the Keck primary have estimated semi-static surface aberrations of approximately 65 nm rms, which were not sensed by the current phasing control system. We propose directly sensing and controlling the primary via the adaptive optics (AO) system, as a Controllable Segmented Primary (CSP), to actively correct its phasing. We develop a methodology for separating the independent controllable signal of the CSP from the rest of the AO system and show estimations of the achievable measurement precision from models of the Keck-II AO system. keywords astronomical instrumentation: adaptive optics, astronomical instrumentation: high angular resolution, techniques: high angular resolution * Benjamin Calvin, \linkable [email protected], \linkable [email protected] 1 Introduction Segmented telescopes are critical to both current and future optical and near-IR astronomy. Not only are many of the largest single-aperture telescopes in operation today segmented, but the planned extremely large class of telescopes all utilize segmented primary designs as well. Many of the scientific goals of these large telescopes require a stable response function on the science detector. Astrometric measurements of crowded fields, such as the Galactic Center [ 1 ] , consistent coupling into optical fibers for fiber-fed spectroscopy [ 2 , 3 ] , high-contrast imaging techniques [ 4 ] , and many other applications all require stable image quality to be successful. In ground-based telescopes with large apertures, adaptive optics (AO) systems are commonly used to remove the time-varying phase distortions caused by the atmosphere. However, for a segmented telescope with significant misalignments present in the phasing of the primary mirror, the adaptive optics system is unable to perfectly correct the discontinuous phase aberrations that are induced by the physical movement of the primary mirror segments. As such, systems that actively maintain the alignment of segmented mirrors are crucial for the success of the telescopes’ science missions. Every large ground-based segmented telescope and all of the planned extremely large telescopes require active phasing. The telescopes with closely packed hexagonal segment architectures all use or plan to use capacitance-based edge sensor systems to actively control the alignment of the primary mirror [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] . The alignment precision of the segmented primary is fundamentally limited by the electrical noise in the sensors and actuators. For the system implemented in the W. M. Keck telescopes, for example, the edge sensors sustain an uncertainty of 5 nm in the measurement of relative displacement between any two contiguous segments. Reference [ 11 ] states that this sensor noise propagates across the primary to create an expected uncertainty in the alignment of 27 nm rms across the primary, which primarily manifest as a combination of low-order global Zernike modes [ 12 , 13 ] . The observed alignment on the Keck primary mirrors, however, does not meet this target. References [ 14 , 15 ] used speckle-based measurements of the Keck-II primary phasing with NIRC2 to estimate that the surface of the primary mirror is typically misaligned with approximately 65 nm rms of periodic segment piston errors, which occur at much higher amplitudes and spatial frequencies than the expected residual surface error from from edge sensing. Reference [ 16 ] provides further evidence that the surface of the Keck-II primary is subject to segment piston errors on magnitudes and spatial distributions that go beyond the expectations of the residual surface errors from edge sensing. References [ 15 , 17 , 16 ] provide evidence that these surface aberrations evolve as a function of the telescope elevation angle, which would generate semi-static speckles that compromise the stability of the PSF over the course of extended observations. Therefore, to maintain high wavefront quality and PSF stability, there must be some auxiliary sensor to help monitor the alignment of the primary. In real systems, static surface aberrations on the primary mirror segments can create ambiguity in when the primary mirror is ”properly phased,” so, for the purposes of this project, we consider the primary mirror to be aligned when the deviation of any of the actively controlled degrees of freedom of any segment would decrease the Strehl ratio at the focal plane of interest. Several studies have proposed using a dedicated downstream wavefront sensor for monitoring the phase of the primary [ 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 ] . For its capability to directly measure phase discontinuities, characteristic of segment misalignments on the primary, the Zernike wavefront sensor has been investigated as an option for maintaining the primary mirror alignment [ 22 , 23 , 24 ] and has been demonstrated on-sky [ 25 , 16 ] . The Pyramid Wavefront Sensor (PyWFS), as a wavefront sensor with a larger linear range at the cost of lower sensitivity [ 26 ] , has also been investigated as a sensor to phase segmented mirrors, including lab tests where a PyWFS senses the piston, tip, and tilt modes of the primary segments [ 27 ] , controls them in closed loop [ 28 ] , and implements techniques to solve wavelength phase ambiguities [ 29 ] . However, adding any new dedicated wavefront sensor for tracking the segment phase will come with the trade-off of increasing the optical complexity of the wavefront control system, while potentially incurring throughput and sensitivity impacts to science observation. This work analyzes the counterpart of this trade-off by exploring the capabilities of tracking the segment phase without increasing the optical complexity of the system by using sensors already in use. In this two-part paper, we consider using a preexisting AO system’s PyWFS to additionally sense the phase of the primary segments. By monitoring the phase of the primary with the existing wavefront sensor, we effectively incorporate the primary into the AO system as an auxiliary deformable mirror operating at a low temporal bandwidth. We refer to a primary mirror monitored and controlled in this way as a Controllable Segmented Primary (CSP). When considering the CSP and AO systems operating simultaneously with a single wavefront sensor, we refer to the combined system as the CSP+AO system. We note that this setup is not fundamentally dissimilar to a two-stage AO system operating as a woofer and tweeter, but as the temporal bandwidths, Fourier domains, and roles in the observatory as a whole differ greatly from each other, we approach this work from first principles. This paper details the approach for accurately measuring the phase of the CSP and distinguishing it from the phase of the AO system. In Sec. 2 , we discuss our methodology for modeling the combined CSP+AO system and disentangling the two phases. In § 3 , we describe the metrics we use to measure the sensitivity and precision in the measurement of the CSP phase. In § 4 , we present the results of these simulations, which are then discussed in § 5 . In the companion paper (part two), we present simulations of a CSP+AO system in