Stochastic Description of Dynamical Traps in Human Control
Vasily Lubashevskiy, Ihor Lubashevsky, Namik Gusein-zade · 2025
Read Stochastic Description of Dynamical Traps in Human Control by Vasily Lubashevskiy, Ihor Lubashevsky, Namik Gusein-zade (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-01812.txt.
Introduction
Vasily Lubashevskiy, Ihor Lubashevsky, and Namik Gusein-zade model the stop-and-go rhythm of a person steering an unstable object, in this 2025 paper. Human control is intermittent: people alternate between actively correcting and passively watching, falling into what are called dynamical traps. A good model must capture the randomness of the switching.
Their model drives a variable between zero and one with a specially built stochastic differential equation, each end marking a behavior mode. A trap function scores how far the object has drifted from its target, setting which mode has priority. Crucially, switches, the person's action points, fire before the trap score reaches its limits, matching observed behavior. The authors say this timing detail lets the model describe real intermittent control of physical objects, from balancing tasks to teleoperation.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Vasily Lubashevskiy, Ihor Lubashevsky, Namik Gusein-zade |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 18 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-01812
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Stochastic Description of Dynamical Traps in Human Control Vasily Lubashevskiy, Ihor Lubashevsky, Namik Gusein-zade Abstract A novel model for dynamical traps in intermittent human control is proposed. It describes probabilistic, step-wise transitions between two modes of a subject’s behavior—active and passive phases in controlling an object’s dynamics—using an original stochastic differential equation. This equation governs time variations of a special variable, denoted as ζ \zeta , between two limit values, ζ = 0 \zeta=0 and ζ = 1 \zeta=1 . The introduced trap function, Ω ( Δ ) \Omega(\Delta) , quantifies the subject’s perception of the object’s deviation from a desired state, thereby determining the relative priority of the two action modes. Notably, these transitions—referred to as the subject’s action points—occur before the trap function reaches its limit values, Ω ( Δ ) = 0 \Omega(\Delta)=0 or Ω ( Δ ) = 1 \Omega(\Delta)=1 . This characteristic enables the application of the proposed model to describe intermittent human control over real objects. 1 Introduction The concept of a “dynamical trap,” initially introduced in [ 1 ] , 1 1 1 A different type of dynamical traps is found in the theory of Hamiltonian systems with complex dynamics [ 6 , 7 ] . In this context, a dynamical trap is a region in the phase space with an exceptionally long residence time. This type of traps, however, is fundamentally distinct from the one under consideration, as its emergence results from a delicate balance of several nonlinear properties in a Hamiltonian system. The dynamical trap discussed in this paper, on the other hand, pertains to the general characteristics of human perception. extends the idea of a stationary point—a central concept in dynamical systems theory—to a region with blurred boundaries. Each point within this region can be considered a stationary point of the corresponding dynamical system. Thus, the dynamical trap represents a multitude of neutral equilibrium states. When applied to the context of human perception, particularly from the first-person perspective, the dynamical trap becomes a fundamental component of the formalism due to the bounded capacity of human cognition [ 2 ] . This limitation is especially evident in the inability of humans to clearly distinguish between similar states of an observed object, which differ in terms of certain quantitative parameters in the real world. The dynamical trap formalism has proven useful in explaining human intermittent control, as demonstrated in experiments involving virtual pendulum balance [ 3 ] and car-following scenarios in virtual driving [ 4 ] . Furthermore, dynamical traps can lead to a new class of nonequilibrium phase transitions, where the emergence of new phases is not due to the appearance of new stationary points in the governing equations [ 5 , for a review] . The concept of dynamical traps underpins, explicitly or implicitly, the theory of intermittent human control, for example, in the stabilization of an unstable object, where control repeatedly switches between active and passive phases rather than remaining active throughout the process [ 8 , for a review] . Nowadays, intermittent human control is considered entirely natural, highly effective, and robust [ 9 ] . In the active phase, the subject’s actions aim at making adjustments or correcting the object motion, whereas in the passive phase, the subject temporarily disengages from active control, allowing the system to evolve autonomously. Transitions between the two phases are usually treated as event-driven phenomena, occurring when control is activated or halted due to the discrepancy between the goal and the actual system state exceeding or falling below a certain threshold. These transitions, especially control activation events, can exhibit a pronounced probabilistic behavior, allowing them to be treated as noise-driven control activation [ 3 ] . It is essential that in intermittent human control, the active phase fragments should be characterized as ballistic, i.e., open-loop fragments, rather than feedback control [ 10 ] (see also [ 9 ] for a review). In other words, the subject, responding to a critical deviation of the controlled object from the desired state, initiates corrective actions, which are mainly implemented without feedback on the induced variations in the system state. In this sense, the commonality between passive and active phases is that during both, the subject does not react to the system dynamics; they simply wait until either the system deviation becomes critical or the action is completed. In this case, exactly the transitions between the two control phases—action points [ 11 ] (see also [ 12 ] )—should be characterized as real “active” actions of the subject caused by event-driven decision-making. All the proposed models for the dynamical trap effect, which can be categorized under its continuous description, employ the following trap function \Omega(\Delta)=\frac{\Delta^{2}}{\Delta^{2}+\Delta_{c}^{2}} (1) or a similar function. In general, the variable \Delta represents the intensity of an external stimulus that prompts the subject to act, For instance, \Delta may represent the deviation of a controlled object from its desired equilibrium position or the discrepancy between the object’s actual motion and its expected dynamics. The parameter \Delta_{c} accounts for the uncertainly in the subject’s perception of \Delta . Within this approach, the trap function \Omega(\Delta) characterizes the trap effect as a formal reduction in the subject’s response to the external stimulus \Delta when \Delta\lesssim\Delta_{c} , approaching zero as \Delta/\Delta_{c}\to 0 . The purpose of the present paper is to propose a stochastic description of the dynamical trap effect that accounts for two characteristic features of human control, which cannot be captured within a continuous approach. First, transitions between active subject’s control and temporary disengagement from it typically occur in a step-wise manner, i.e., on time scales determined by the neural-muscular implementation of initiated actions. Second, these transitions must be probabilistic. In this context, the function \Omega(\Delta) should serve as a control parameter that triggers the transitions rather than explicitly describing the subject’s actions. In other words, the proposed description should focus on action points in the subject’s behavior rather than on smooth transitions between the two modes of action. It should be noted that the model introduced in Ref. [ 13 ] may be regarded as a first step toward this approach. 2 Model Two distinct modes of the subject’s actions are represented by the limit values \zeta=0 and \zeta=1 of a continuous variable \zeta\in[0,1] . Specifically, we assume that \zeta=0 corresponds to the subject’s disengagement from active control, while \zeta=1 characterizes continuous feedback to changes in system dynamics. Relatively sharp transitions of \zeta between 0 and 1 represent action points. Additionally, small fluctuations, \delta z|_{\zeta=0}>0 and \delta z|_{\zeta=1}<0 , near these limit values serve as a quantitative measure of the subject’s readiness to switch modes when their preference is no longer clear. A function \Omega(t)\in(0,1) , defined, for example, by Exp. ( 1 ) in terms of the time dependence of the variable \Delta(t) , quantifies the proximity of system dynamics to situations where ( i ) corrective intervention by the subject becomes essential or ( ii ) continued active behavior is not only unnecessary but may also cause undesired effects due to the bounded capacity of human cognition. In this study, which focuses on \zeta -dynamics, we treat \Omega(t) as a given function of time t . Since halting