Understanding Urban-Rural Disparities in Mobility Inefficiency for Colombia, Mexico, and India

Nandini Iyer, Massimiliano Luca, Riccardo Di Clemente · 2025

Read Understanding Urban-Rural Disparities in Mobility Inefficiency for Colombia, Mexico, and India by Nandini Iyer, Massimiliano Luca, Riccardo Di Clemente (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-01810.txt.

Introduction

Nandini Iyer, Massimiliano Luca, and Riccardo Di Clemente compare travel in city and rural areas across three countries. Their 2025 paper uses trip data from location services in Colombia, Mexico, and India. They draw the line between city and rural zones from the trip network itself. That avoids sole reliance on built-up land as the marker.

They score how much longer real trips run than the shortest route. Rural trips were less direct, above all long trips late in the day. In cities, travel ease often did not match access to public transit during commute hours. Rural gaps tied to how areas lean on their nearest city. Weekday and weekend patterns also differed by place.

Catalog record

CREATORNandini Iyer, Massimiliano Luca, Riccardo Di Clemente
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE69 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-01810

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Understanding Urban-Rural Disparities in Mobility Inefficiency for Colombia, Mexico, and India Nandini Iyer, Massimiliano Luca, Riccardo Di Clemente Abstract Rural and urban areas exhibit distinct mobility patterns, yet a systematic understanding of how these trends differ across regions and contexts remains underexplored. By using origin-destination matrices from Location-Based Services data in Colombia, India, and Mexico, we delineate urban and rural boundaries through network percolation, reducing reliance on conventional urbanisation metrics tied to the built environment. We gauge mobility dynamics across regions developing a measure for routing inefficiency, which measures how much longer empirical trips are than their optimal shortest path. Our findings reveal that rural areas experience greater inefficiencies, particularly for longer trips made later in the day. At the urban level, we determine the misalignment between urban mobility efficiency and public transit accessibility, by measuring the difference between their respective vector fields. We observe that most cities experience misalignment during regular commuting hours, with Colombian cities exhibiting particularly high alignment. Meanwhile, mobility inefficiency in rural areas are associated with their orientation around their most proximate city. City-level analyses uncover disparities in the functions of rural and urban areas, with significant variations between weekdays and weekends, reflecting distinct roles in commuting and access to services. These findings highlight the importance of tailored, context-sensitive approaches to improving connectivity and reducing disparities. This study offers new insights into the spatial and temporal dynamics of mobility inefficiency, contributing to equitable regional planning and sustainable mobility solutions. Introduction As rates of urbanisation increase, it has become increasingly important to adopt data-driven approaches to promptly address challenges that arise in both urban and rural areas, such as monitoring economic development [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 ] , accessibility [ 6 , 7 , 8 ] and, inequalities [ 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] . Yet, the process of urbanisation varies across countries and cultures [ 14 , 15 ] . Countries in the Global South tend to exhibit urbanisation through the growth of small urban settlements [ 16 ] , while countries in the Global North do so through population density increases in megacities [ 17 ] . Despite the variability in urbanisation, investments in mobility infrastructure tend to be concentrated in larger urban areas [ 18 ] . Meanwhile, smaller urban areas and rural towns face mobility challenges due to limited transportation options and poorer access to urban hubs, often leading to a higher dependence on private vehicles [ 19 , 20 ] . These disparities in accessibility and infrastructure can hinder economic growth [ 21 ] , exacerbate inequalities in healthcare [ 22 ] and result in disproportionate consequences of climate change [ 23 ] for rural communities. Previous studies examining rural mobility tend to distinguish between urban and rural areas using administrative boundaries, built environment contiguity, and population density [ 24 ] . While these approaches provide a static perspective on cities and rural areas, in terms of the services they offer or their residential landscapes, they often overlook the interdependencies between rural and urban regions. Essential work is needed to infer urban and rural areas using mobility patterns, in order to provide a more coherent framework that can be applied to all countries regardless of their form of urbanisation. Recent works generally compare accessibility or migration patterns between urban and rural areas, leaving a significant gap in understanding the emergence of inequalities in smaller-scale mobility (i.e. routine travel rather than residential migration). Only few approaches explore mobility patterns across both urban and rural areas, due their fundamentally distinct characteristics [ 25 , 26 ] . This poses an additional challenge: comparing rural and urban mobility routing patterns while also considering their inherently distinct topological and demographic features. We address these limitations by investigating mobility inefficiency inequalities in urban and rural areas, across Colombia, India, and Mexico. To define urban and rural boundaries, we apply network percolation to a country’s mobility network, which is defined using origin-destination matrices built from Location Based Data (LBS) [ 27 ] . In doing so, we derive an rural-urban classification that is based on how people move through space, rather than solely relying on static characteristics such as population density [ 24 ] . This approach enables us to create a universal definition of spatial regions – from megacities to smaller urban settlements and rural areas – through the lens of mobility patterns. Building on this definition, we examine mobility inefficiency between rural and urban areas, which refers to trips that exceed the optimal shortest path length between their origins and destinations. To accurately characterise inefficiency inequality, we analyse how infrastructure alignment with mobility demands varies across urban and rural contexts. This comprehensive assessment reveals distinct patterns in how transportation infrastructure serves urban and rural needs. By analysing the angular difference between transit access and urban mobility efficiency vector fields, we pinpoint specific cities and times when access to public transit does not align with mobility efficiency. In rural settings, that tend to have significantly less access to transit [ 28 ] , we identify inequalities in rural-urban connectivity, providing insights into the specific directions around a city where rural areas face poor access to urban centres and, as a result, limited access to essential resources, such as jobs and hospitals [ 29 , 30 ] . Mobility inefficiency serves as a versatile metric, enabling us to not only compare urban-rural disparities but also gain deeper insights into its relationship with urban transit infrastructure and rural accessibility. Using aggregated, GDPR-compliant mobility data from three low- and middle-income countries (LMIC), we analyse these inequalities in the context of urban versus rural settings. Our findings reveal that, compared to urban areas, rural areas generally exhibit more inefficiency than their urban counterparts, particularly for longer trips and later in the day. These results underscore two critical points: first they emphasise the need to improve urban accessibility for rural areas. Second, they highlight the importance of contextually evaluating mobility inefficiency, rather than applying a uniform approach that overlooks the distinct characteristics between urban and rural settings. We reveal four distinct patterns regarding how urban mobility efficiency aligns with public transit accessibility, showing that the majority of cities experience higher transit-efficiency misalignment during working hours on weekdays. Finally, we focus on rural areas, highlighting how their proximity and orientation to their closest city, as well as their population can help provide insights as to where natural barriers or urban sprawl may be impacted by rural mobility inefficiency. Our framework and findings represent a crucial step in order to ultimately understand the consequences of compounded inequalities [ 31 ] (i.e individuals experiencing inequalities in both economic and mobility dimensions). Our results can be further explored here . Results Existing methods struggle to distinguish urban and rural areas in a manner that can account for diverse urbanisation landscapes. This challenge is heightened by the need to understand how mobility features are expressed in urban and rural settings in order to appropriately assess mobility patterns between areas. We leverage origin-destination (OD) mobility data, provided by Cuebiq [ 27 ] for two purposes (1) to create a mobility network to define urban and rural boundaries

Read the complete text