On Core Quandles

Filippo Spaggiari, Marco Bonatto · 2025

Read On Core Quandles by Filippo Spaggiari, Marco Bonatto (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-01790.txt.

Introduction

Filippo Spaggiari and Marco Bonatto study a family of algebraic structures called core quandles, in a 2025 math paper. A quandle is a set with an operation shaped by the rules of knot theory. A core quandle is built from a group, using a twisted product of two elements. The pair ask when such structures have key traits, and answer in terms of the group beneath.

They settle an open question by describing exactly which cores are connected. They also give a standard way to present connected cores as actions of groups. With that tool they prove that simple core quandles are primitive, a strong form of structural tightness. The work links two fields: results about quandles now follow from group theory, and group properties gain a new test bed. Knot theorists and algebraists both use such structures.

Catalog record

CREATORFilippo Spaggiari, Marco Bonatto
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-01790

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On Core Quandles Filippo Spaggiari, Marco Bonatto Abstract We characterize several properties of core quandles in terms of the properties of their underlying groups. Specifically, we characterize connected cores providing an answer to an open question in [ 26 ] and present a standard homogeneous representation for them, which allows us to prove that simple core quandles are primitive. Introduction Quandles are binary algebras introduced in the development of the theory of knots as a way to construct knot invariants [ 20 , 24 ] . The origins of quandle theory trace back to self-distributive quasigroups, or what are now referred to as latin quandles, which have been extensively studied in relation to modern theory. Later on, they have proven to be deeply connected to various other mathematical structures, such as solutions to the set-theoretical quantum Yang-Baxter equation [ 11 , 10 ] and pointed Hopf algebras [ 1 ] . Historical examples also stem from group conjugation, which ultimately led to the development of the knot quandle by Joyce and Matveev. Another line of research was inspired by the abstract properties of reflections on differentiable manifolds, giving rise to what is now known as involutory quandles, that is the class of structures where the identity x*(x*y)=y holds [ 22 ] . Core quandles represent a particular class of involutory quandles constructed from a group G , defined by the operation x*y=xy^{-1}x for all x,y\in G . The study of cores as binary algebraic structures has its roots in the analysis of quasigroups and loops (see [ 3 ] ), which served as a foundation for the development of modern core theory. From the perspective of universal algebra, core quandles can be regarded as reducts of groups, inheriting numerous structural properties from the operation of G . Indeed, several properties of the quandle \operatorname{\mathsf{Core}}(G) can be derived directly from those of the underlying group G . The paper was motivated by an open question in [ 26 ] , in which a characterization of connected quandles was asked. Previous investigations have addressed properties such as latinness [ 21 ] , faithfulness [ 28 ] , right self-distributivity [ 2 ] , and mediality (an unpublished result by B. Roszkowska). This paper contributes to this ongoing research on core quandles in purely group-theoretic terms by providing a characterization of other properties, among which connectedness, simplicity, primitivity, abelianness and nilpotency in the sense of [ 14 ] . To ensure comprehensiveness, we also revisit existing results, rephrasing them in the modern framework of quandle theory and presenting independent, complete proofs. The structure of the paper is as follows. In Section 1 , we introduce the foundational concepts and notations of quandle theory. Section 2 examines the homogeneous representations of core quandles and the properties of their associated groups of automorphisms. In particular, we use these homogeneous representations to characterize simple and primitive core quandles. In Section 3 , we focus on the displacement group and we establish the characterization of connected core quandles. In Section 4 , we investigate the above mentioned characterization theorems for several properties of core quandles in purely group theoretical terms. In Sections 5 , we employ tools from universal algebra to examine the notions of abelianness and nilpotence in core quandles (in the sense of [ 14 ] ). In Section 6 we address the problem of embedding into core quandles, also investigated in [ 4 ] . Using a categorical language we obtained a characterization of quandles that can be embedded into core quandles. Finally, in Section 7 we focus on knot colorings by core quandles. The research presented in this work has been facilitated by the computational tools RIG [ 25 ] and GAP [ 16 ] . Notation Let us collect the group-theoretical notation we are using in the paper. Let G be a group. We denote by G^{op} the opposite of G , that is the group with operation x\cdot^{op}y=yx for every x,y\in G . The map \iota:x\mapsto x^{-1} is an isomorphism between G and G^{op} . Let G be acting on a set X . We denote by G_{x} the stabilizer in G of x\in X , and by x^{G} the orbit of x under the action of G . We say that (the action of) G is semiregular if G_{x}=1 for every x\in G and regular if is it transitive and semiregular. We will employ the following standard notation for the canonical left and right actions of a group G on itself: \displaystyle\lambda:G\to\operatorname{\mathsf{Sym}}(G), \displaystyle g\mapsto(\lambda_{g}:x\mapsto gx), \displaystyle\rho:G^{op}\to\operatorname{\mathsf{Sym}}(G), \displaystyle g\mapsto(\rho_{g}:x\mapsto xg). Note that both \lambda and \rho are regular actions and that [\lambda_{g},\rho_{h}]=1 for every g,h\in G . We also denote by \widehat{g} the inner automorphism by G , mapping x to \lambda_{g}\rho_{g}^{-1}(x)=gxg^{-1} for every x\in G . We define the squaring map as s:G\to G such that s(x)=x^{2} for every x\in G . The image s(G)=\{x^{2}\colon x\in G\} is the square of the group G . 1 Core quandles Let Q=(Q,*) be a set with a binary operation. We say that Q is a rack if all left translations L_{x}:Q\rightarrow Q,\quad y\mapsto x*y are automorphisms of Q . Equivalently, we have that L_{x} is bijective and x*(y*z)=(x*y)*(x*z) holds for every x,y,z\in Q . We have introduced quandles as algebras with a single binary operation, but since L_{x}^{-1}L_{x}(y)=y , it is also common to read L_{x}^{-1}(y) as a second binary operation, the left division of the quandle, denoted x\backslash y . In the finite case the algebraic structures (Q,*) and (Q,*,\backslash) are equivalent, so we can study finite racks avoiding the division without loss of generality. If a rack Q is idempotent, that is, if x*x=x for all x\in Q , then Q is called quandle . In particular we can define the left multiplication group of Q as \operatorname{\mathsf{LMlt}}(Q)=\left\langle L_{x}:x\in Q\right\rangle and the displacement group of Q as \operatorname{\mathsf{Dis}}(Q)=\left\langle L_{x}L_{y}^{-1}:x,y\in Q\right\rangle. It is known that \operatorname{\mathsf{LMlt}}(Q) is a normal subgroup of the automorphism group \operatorname{\mathsf{Aut}}(Q) . A rack Q is said to be: (i) homogeneous (resp. connected ) if the natural action of \operatorname{\mathsf{Aut}}(Q) (resp. \operatorname{\mathsf{LMlt}}(Q) ) is transitive on Q . (ii) projection if x*y=y for all x,y\in Q . (iii) a crossed set if it is a quandle and for all x,y\in Q we have x\ast y=y if and only if y\ast x=x . Quandles can be constructed using groups and their automorphisms in several ways. Example 1.1 . (i) Let G be a group. It is easy to see that G endowed with the binary operation \displaystyle x*y \displaystyle=xyx^{-1} is a quandle, called conjugation quandle over G and denoted \operatorname{\mathsf{Conj}}(G) . (ii) Let G be a group, f\in\operatorname{\mathsf{Aut}}(G) and H\leq\operatorname{\mathsf{Fix}}(f)=\{x\in G\,\colon f(x)=x\} . The set G/H endowed with the operation xH*yH=xf(x^{-1}y)H for every x,y\in G is a quandle. We denote such quandle as \mathcal{Q}(G,H,f) and we refer to it as coset quandle . If G is abelian and H=1 , we say that it is affine . In this case, we use the notation \operatorname{\mathsf{Aff}}(G,f) . It can be proven that homogeneous quandles are exactly those that can be built using the above coset construction (see, for instance [ 17 ] ). Note that the statement of [

Read the complete text