Annotating and Inferring Compositional Structures in Numeral Systems Across Languages
Arne Rubehn, Christoph Rzymski, Luca Ciucci, Kellen Parker van Dam, Alžběta Kučerová, Katja Bocklage, David Snee, Abishek Stephen, Johann-Mattis List · 2025
Read Annotating and Inferring Compositional Structures in Numeral Systems Across Languages by Arne Rubehn, Christoph Rzymski, Luca Ciucci, Kellen Parker van Dam, Alžběta Kučerová, Katja Bocklage, David Snee, Abishek Stephen, Johann-Mattis List (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-01625.txt.
Introduction
Arne Rubehn and co-authors build a coding scheme for numeral systems across languages in a paper from two thousand twenty-five. Number words vary widely across the world's tongues, in both shape and history. Fair comparison needs a standard way to write them down.
Their scheme and workflow support computer-aided coding, shown on numerals one to forty in twenty-five diverse languages. The analysis contrasts each system's deep structure with its surface word forms. Trials of automatic word splitting found that sound changes at joins, called allomorphy, caused most errors. The authors also report that subword methods from language tech fail to find word parts in such low-resource data.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Arne Rubehn, Christoph Rzymski, Luca Ciucci, Kellen Parker van Dam, Alžběta Kučerová, Katja Bocklage, David Snee, Abishek Stephen, Johann-Mattis List |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-01625
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Annotating and Inferring Compositional Structures in Numeral Systems Across Languages Arne Rubehn, Christoph Rzymski, Luca Ciucci, Kellen Parker van Dam, Alžběta Kučerová, Katja Bocklage, David Snee, Abishek Stephen, Johann-Mattis List Abstract Numeral systems across the world’s languages vary in fascinating ways, both regarding their synchronic structure and the diachronic processes that determined how they evolved in their current shape. For a proper comparison of numeral systems across different languages, however, it is important to code them in a standardized form that allows for the comparison of basic properties. Here, we present a simple but effective coding scheme for numeral annotation, along with a workflow that helps to code numeral systems in a computer-assisted manner, providing sample data for numerals from 1 to 40 in 25 typologically diverse languages. We perform a thorough analysis of the sample, focusing on the systematic comparison between the underlying and the surface morphological structure. We further experiment with automated models for morpheme segmentation, where we find allomorphy as the major reason for segmentation errors. Finally, we show that subword tokenization algorithms are not viable for discovering morphemes in low-resource scenarios. 1 Introduction Numeral systems represented by the words for cardinal numbers used in counting are an interesting kind of linguistic data: they code a part of the lexicon of human languages that is potentially large and often exhibits a regularity that increases with higher numbers. Regularity is reflected in the recycling of linguistic material used to create higher numbers, where morphemes for smaller number words are often reused to motivate the formation of larger numerals. In addition, numeral systems are also maximally distinctive . Being used to distinguish ordinal numbers, we rarely find cases in which two distinct numbers are expressed by the same word form, even if numeral words themselves can have multiple meanings outside of the number domain (as can be seen in the Database of Cross-Linguistic Colexifications , Rzymski et al., 2020 ). Another important aspect of numeral systems is that they are not created in an ad-hoc fashion but have instead often evolved over hundreds of years. The evolution can leave traces in numeral systems that counter-act former regularity, leading to allophonic variation in the morphemes that compose numeral words. Language contact can also feature as an important aspect of evolution, resulting in extreme cases where languages use two or more numeral systems in combination, reflecting different stages of their history. The fact that most numeral systems are compositional , while at the same time being distinctive and discrete in their denotation, makes them an interesting test object for linguistic analyses that deal with lexical compositionality in the context of language change. While one would otherwise have to cope with problems resulting from various kinds of morphological and semantic variation, numeral systems can be seen as an ideal test ground for the annotation and inference of compositional structures in the lexicon of human languages. In the following, we will try to illustrate this point in more detail. After a short overview on numeral systems in the context of descriptive and computational linguistics (§ 2 ), we present a small collection of numeral systems along with methods that can be used to annotate numeral systems manually or to segment numeral words automatically into morphemes (§ 3 ). After testing these methods and reporting the results on our small cross-linguistic sample of numeral systems (§ 4 ) we discuss our findings and point to ideas for future work (§ 5 ). 2 Background The cross-linguistic diversity of numeral systems has attracted the interest of scholars since Hervás y Panduro ’s comparative work ( 1786 ), which presented data from missionaries on many then little-known languages. Today, the most comprehensive database on numerals is Chan (2024) , who collected data on more than 5,000 lects, often provided by linguists with first-hand experience of the respective languages. The constant increase in data has allowed for the study of numeral systems from a formal ( Brandt Corstius, 1968 ; Hurford, 1975 , see e.g.) and a typological perspective. The latter approach reached a turning point with Greenberg ’s ( 1978 ) 54 generalizations, most of which stood the test of time ( Comrie, 2020 ) . Even though their synchronic structure may be opaque, numeral systems are diachronically motivated and are built through a limited number of cross-linguistic strategies ( Heine, 1997 , 18-34) . They typically combine a small set of morphemes (mainly numbers, but also linking elements) according to three parameters, including (1) the choice of the base(s), (2) the operations applied to the base(s), and (3) the order of the morphemes ( Greenberg, 1978 ; Moravcsik, 2017 , 459-461) . Despite the presumed regularity and compositionality of numeral systems, they may occasionally display gaps and ambiguities ( Comrie, 1997 ; Comrie, 2005 , 79-80) . The most common bases are ‘five’, ‘ten’, and ‘twenty’, whose conceptual sources are, respectively, the fingers of the hand, of both hands, and of all hands and toes ( Heine, 1997 , 19-24 ; on finger counting and its cultural variability, see Bender and Beller, 2012 ). Decimal systems are the most frequent worldwide, followed by vigesimal and quinary systems ( Skirgård et al., 2023 ). Languages can employ more than one base, resulting in hybrid numeral systems. While languages with no numerals or only the number ‘one’ are rare ( Hammarström, 2010 ) , the numeral systems of many languages, particularly in South America, New Guinea and Australia, are restricted to a few numerals ( Moravcsik, 2017 , 459) . According to Dixon (2012, 71-72) , this indicates that the speakers did not count and enumeration was not the primary use of these number words. Hammarström (2008) observed that pidgins and creoles tend to have more complex numeral systems than the global average. Their frequent origin as trade languages may be a contributing factor. Numeral systems often developed out of contact, which usually comes with societal change, and borrowing may also involve the lowest numbers ( Dixon, 2012 , 75-77) . While numeral systems all over the world have been quite intensively investigated in the past, formal computational studies that account for the degree of compositionality and the individual motivation patterns underlying individual number words have not been carried out so far. Recent advances in the annotation of lexical motivation patterns ( Hill and List, 2017 ) and the automated segmentation of words into morphemes ( Goldsmith et al., 2017 ) open new possibilities for a computational investigation of numeral systems that we will discuss in more detail in the following. 3 Materials and Methods 3.1 Sample of Numeral Systems We collected the cardinal numbers from 1 to 40 in 25 typologically diverse languages from Eurasia and Southern America, spanning ten different language families. Most language families, with the exception of Indo-European (12 languages) and Sino-Tibetan (5 languages), are represented by a single language. Table 1 provides a comprehensive overview of the languages covered in the sample, accompanied by a geographical visualization in Figure 1 . Family Branch Language Base Afro-Asiatic Semitic Maltese 10 Araucanian — Mapudungun 10 Arawak Ta-Arawak Wayuu 10 Aymaran — Aymara 5 / 10 Dravidian Southern Telugu 10 Indo-European Balto-Slavic Czech 10 Russian